DPReview.com is closing April 10th - Find out more

Samsung solved the High Sync speed problem !

Started Jan 2, 2014 | Polls
Mr.NoFlash Senior Member • Posts: 2,374
Samsung solved the High Sync speed problem !
2

A drawback of the Samsung NX system was the low Flash sync speed, you could use Flash only below 1/200th shutter speed.

This was THE flash advantage of the more experienced photographic companies , Oly/Sony/Pentax/Canikon.

But now, let me quote from imagingreporter.com regarding new SEF 580A TTL external flash:

The high speed flash sync mode allows for flash with shutter speeds faster than 1/200 of a second, ideal for brightly lit scenes with selective depth of field.

Now the Samsung NX system also belongs to the systems with which you can use fill flash on a sunny day ( for example fort portraits ). Now you can open up the aperture , what leads to faster shutter speeds in the 1/1000 range, and still use flash ( HSS flash ).

Just for fun a little poll attached ( dont take it to serious ). Cheers

 Mr.NoFlash's gear list:Mr.NoFlash's gear list
Fujifilm FinePix Real 3D W1 Leica Digilux 3 Samsung NX300 Fujifilm X-M1
POLL
I like that Samsung NX now has high speed flash sync.
30.0% 12  votes
Why use flash during day outdoors ?
2.5% 1  vote
I like that Samsung now has wireless flash.
5.0% 2  votes
I like that Samsung now has wireless flash and high speed flash sync (HSS).
27.5% 11  votes
Why open the aperture?
2.5% 1  vote
I am a CaNikon user. Does Samsung make cameras ?
15.0% 6  votes
Everything is so expensive, blaaa
7.5% 3  votes
I do not want to participate in this little poll
10.0% 4  votes
  Show results
NewForce Senior Member • Posts: 1,263
Re: Samsung solved the High Sync speed problem !

For the 2nd time, I've missed what your nick mean.

Does Mr.NoFlash mean hunger for more flash? Just kidding.

HSS flash is good to have it but was never a must features for most photographers.

Furthermore a HSS flash reduce much flash power so it generally good for close up shot, like a close portrait against sunlight. HSS flash also can't be use for shooting sport event as it distance coverage way too short for any good.

-- hide signature --

Kenny

ttbek Veteran Member • Posts: 4,869
Re: Samsung solved the High Sync speed problem !

Wouldn't it be good for freezing faster movement indoors too?  Dance floor, bowling, I dunno, the 1/180th doesn't seem like it's quite fast enough.

 ttbek's gear list:ttbek's gear list
Canon PowerShot SX10 IS Canon EOS 5D Samsung NX300 Canon EOS Rebel SL1 Samsung NX30 +37 more
OP Mr.NoFlash Senior Member • Posts: 2,374
Re: Samsung solved the High Sync speed problem !

NewForce wrote:

HSS flash is good to have it but was never a must features for most photographers.

I accept that its not for everyone.

Furthermore a HSS flash reduce much flash power so it generally good for close up shot, like a close portrait against sunlight.

I do not want to photograph AGAINST the sun with my little Metz flash, but perhaps IN the sun, and there even a little bit of fill flash improves the harsh shadows.

HSS flash also can't be use for shooting sport event as it distance coverage way too short for any good.

Yes. But perhaps 1% of the photographers are serious  sports photographers

 Mr.NoFlash's gear list:Mr.NoFlash's gear list
Fujifilm FinePix Real 3D W1 Leica Digilux 3 Samsung NX300 Fujifilm X-M1
NewForce Senior Member • Posts: 1,263
Re: Samsung solved the High Sync speed problem !

ttbek wrote:

Wouldn't it be good for freezing faster movement indoors too? Dance floor, bowling, I dunno, the 1/180th doesn't seem like it's quite fast enough.

Think most of people mis-concept about flashgun high speed sync working logic.

When flashgun in HSS high speed sync mode, it actually work more like a video light with continuous light. Under HSS mode actually loss about 2.3 stop flash power. Imagine a GN56 flashgun is now at GN24.

When in HSS mode with flash pump out continuous light mean it does not provide fast flash light anymore and more probably it can't stop fast motion at all.

If you are interested, scantips.com provide a very details explaination about the disadvantages about using Flashgun in HSS mode. Below the link to it.

Auto FP mode (HSS) - scantips.com

I read some Chinese websites, they prefer camera with full power flash + ND filter over camera with flash in HSS mode.

-- hide signature --

Kenny

OP Mr.NoFlash Senior Member • Posts: 2,374
Re: Samsung solved the High Sync speed problem !

NewForce wrote:


Auto FP mode (HSS) - scantips.com

I read some Chinese websites, they prefer camera with full power flash + ND filter over camera with flash in HSS mode.

Hello, I have just read that pamphlet.

Indeed HSS flash is not able to stop motion to 1/20000 in portraiture, what is what they say against HSS flash.

But that is not my intention, to stop motion to a Microsecond in simple portraiture - what nonsense, sorry.

-- hide signature --

cheers
Mr.NoFlash

 Mr.NoFlash's gear list:Mr.NoFlash's gear list
Fujifilm FinePix Real 3D W1 Leica Digilux 3 Samsung NX300 Fujifilm X-M1
Kaziklu Senior Member • Posts: 1,301
Re: Samsung solved the High Sync speed problem !

So a few issue.

HSS allows you to use flash at a higher shutter speed.

When you are shooting a Dancer you need to freeze motion, you can do this in a few different ways. a low ambient light and a short flash duration, or a fast shutter speed and longer flash wit high ambient.

If you are shooting at F11 with a strobe firing at 1/2000 of a second with low ambient 1/100th of a second will be fine. If you can't get enough light out of your flash to get the exposure that fast, then HSS would allow you to pull the power up and use the increased shutter speed to compensate.

The easiest way to think of flash is an external shutter, and it's duration is what will freeze motion most of the time.

I really can't think of another occasion when you need it.

I mean if you are outside and you want F4 and it's the middle of a bight day so you have to put your shutter to 1/2000 of a second which leave the subject underexposed HSS would be a requirement... or you just put a ND Filter on, or light your model with a reflector and it does the same exact thing.

Oh the other time is if you shoot on Aperture Priority mode or TTL and have no idea how to change your settings.

 Kaziklu's gear list:Kaziklu's gear list
Samsung NX20 Samsung NX1 Samsung NX 30mm F2 Pancake Samsung NX 18-55mm F3.5-5.6 OIS Samsung NX 50-200mm F4-5.6 OIS +1 more
NewForce Senior Member • Posts: 1,263
Re: Samsung solved the High Sync speed problem !

Mr.NoFlash wrote:

NewForce wrote:

Auto FP mode (HSS) - scantips.com

I read some Chinese websites, they prefer camera with full power flash + ND filter over camera with flash in HSS mode.

Hello, I have just read that pamphlet.

Indeed HSS flash is not able to stop motion to 1/20000 in portraiture, what is what they say against HSS flash.

But that is not my intention, to stop motion to a Microsecond in simple portraiture - what nonsense, sorry.

Oh that was for ttbek (or others) in case he's interested to find out more.

Since you're interested at simple portrait, here's one for your interest. Neil has all the pros & cons and advices about HSS, for portrait. I would say, Neil just Nail it.

tutorial: high-speed flash sync - by Neil van Niekerk

-- hide signature --

Kenny

JoePhoto Veteran Member • Posts: 6,916
Re: Samsung solved the High Sync speed problem !

Kaziklu wrote:

So a few issue.

HSS allows you to use flash at a higher shutter speed.

When you are shooting a Dancer you need to freeze motion, you can do this in a few different ways. a low ambient light and a short flash duration, or a fast shutter speed and longer flash wit high ambient.

If you are shooting at F11 with a strobe firing at 1/2000 of a second with low ambient 1/100th of a second will be fine. If you can't get enough light out of your flash to get the exposure that fast, then HSS would allow you to pull the power up and use the increased shutter speed to compensate.

How are you going to "pull the power up" when the power drops DRASTICALLY in HSS mode.

And the flash "duration" in HSS mode is 1/200 sec.

I am not sure you understand how HSS flash works ???

It is only useful for very short distances, and usually indoors because GN is further derated outdoors.

The easiest way to think of flash is an external shutter, and it's duration is what will freeze motion most of the time.

I really can't think of another occasion when you need it.

I mean if you are outside and you want F4 and it's the middle of a bight day so you have to put your shutter to 1/2000 of a second which leave the subject underexposed HSS would be a requirement... or you just put a ND Filter on, or light your model with a reflector and it does the same exact thing.

Oh the other time is if you shoot on Aperture Priority mode or TTL and have no idea how to change your settings.

-- hide signature --

Thanks for reading .... JoePhoto
( Do You Ever STOP to THINK --- and FORGET to START Again ??? )

NewForce Senior Member • Posts: 1,263
Re: Samsung solved the High Sync speed problem !

JoePhoto wrote:

Kaziklu wrote:

So a few issue.

HSS allows you to use flash at a higher shutter speed.

When you are shooting a Dancer you need to freeze motion, you can do this in a few different ways. a low ambient light and a short flash duration, or a fast shutter speed and longer flash wit high ambient.

If you are shooting at F11 with a strobe firing at 1/2000 of a second with low ambient 1/100th of a second will be fine. If you can't get enough light out of your flash to get the exposure that fast, then HSS would allow you to pull the power up and use the increased shutter speed to compensate.

How are you going to "pull the power up" when the power drops DRASTICALLY in HSS mode.

And the flash "duration" in HSS mode is 1/200 sec.

I am not sure you understand how HSS flash works ???

It is only useful for very short distances, and usually indoors because GN is further derated outdoors.

The easiest way to think of flash is an external shutter, and it's duration is what will freeze motion most of the time.

I really can't think of another occasion when you need it.

I mean if you are outside and you want F4 and it's the middle of a bight day so you have to put your shutter to 1/2000 of a second which leave the subject underexposed HSS would be a requirement... or you just put a ND Filter on, or light your model with a reflector and it does the same exact thing.

Oh the other time is if you shoot on Aperture Priority mode or TTL and have no idea how to change your settings.

Good points and very informative. Perhaps I'm too lazy nowaday to type a lot for more flash skill sharing, especially when there's a lot of abusing and mislead info threads around in the forum. 

-- hide signature --

Kenny

OP Mr.NoFlash Senior Member • Posts: 2,374
Re: Samsung solved the High Sync speed problem !

JoePhoto wrote:


I am not sure you understand how HSS flash works ???

It is only useful for very short distances, and usually indoors because GN is further derated outdoors.

It IS useful for portraits, and especially outdoors.

I know that the GN is derated, but the sun shadows are very bad, and flash makes them less bad. The flash dos not have to light the scene - just make the black shadows non-black.

-- hide signature --

cheers
Mr.NoFlash

 Mr.NoFlash's gear list:Mr.NoFlash's gear list
Fujifilm FinePix Real 3D W1 Leica Digilux 3 Samsung NX300 Fujifilm X-M1
Kaziklu Senior Member • Posts: 1,301
Re: Samsung solved the High Sync speed problem !

JoePhoto wrote:

Kaziklu wrote:

So a few issue.

HSS allows you to use flash at a higher shutter speed.

When you are shooting a Dancer you need to freeze motion, you can do this in a few different ways. a low ambient light and a short flash duration, or a fast shutter speed and longer flash wit high ambient.

If you are shooting at F11 with a strobe firing at 1/2000 of a second with low ambient 1/100th of a second will be fine. If you can't get enough light out of your flash to get the exposure that fast, then HSS would allow you to pull the power up and use the increased shutter speed to compensate.

How are you going to "pull the power up" when the power drops DRASTICALLY in HSS mode.

And the flash "duration" in HSS mode is 1/200 sec.

I am not sure you understand how HSS flash works ???

It is only useful for very short distances, and usually indoors because GN is further derated outdoors.

The easiest way to think of flash is an external shutter, and it's duration is what will freeze motion most of the time.

I really can't think of another occasion when you need it.

I mean if you are outside and you want F4 and it's the middle of a bight day so you have to put your shutter to 1/2000 of a second which leave the subject underexposed HSS would be a requirement... or you just put a ND Filter on, or light your model with a reflector and it does the same exact thing.

Oh the other time is if you shoot on Aperture Priority mode or TTL and have no idea how to change your settings.

Do you know how flash works? and can you read? 
The Dancer may not have been a great example, the whole purpose of the example was to say that in HSS the motion freezing element stops being the flash and is left reliant on shutter speed. 
HSS duration is 1/200th (I actually think it's 1/250th) of a second and pulses. This is about 1/2 power. at 1/2000th duration you are at about 1/16th power. If you can freeze the motion at 1/800th shutter, so you pick up a little extra light. 
But really you could just raise your strobe power a little and still get the motion. 
There is no reason to use it in doors. I honestly can't think of a single reason to use it indoors. (well maybe indoor sports but even then there are other ways)

 Kaziklu's gear list:Kaziklu's gear list
Samsung NX20 Samsung NX1 Samsung NX 30mm F2 Pancake Samsung NX 18-55mm F3.5-5.6 OIS Samsung NX 50-200mm F4-5.6 OIS +1 more
ttbek Veteran Member • Posts: 4,869
Re: Samsung solved the High Sync speed problem !

NewForce wrote:

ttbek wrote:

Wouldn't it be good for freezing faster movement indoors too? Dance floor, bowling, I dunno, the 1/180th doesn't seem like it's quite fast enough.

Think most of people mis-concept about flashgun high speed sync working logic.

When flashgun in HSS high speed sync mode, it actually work more like a video light with continuous light. Under HSS mode actually loss about 2.3 stop flash power. Imagine a GN56 flashgun is now at GN24.

When in HSS mode with flash pump out continuous light mean it does not provide fast flash light anymore and more probably it can't stop fast motion at all.

If you are interested, scantips.com provide a very details explaination about the disadvantages about using Flashgun in HSS mode. Below the link to it.

Auto FP mode (HSS) - scantips.com

I read some Chinese websites, they prefer camera with full power flash + ND filter over camera with flash in HSS mode.

Thanks to every explaining HSS. I need to get back to threads where I ask something in a more timely fashion. This link was quite helpful. I think that it will do what I was thinking, let me explain. I'm thinking of indoor scenes where the ambient light isn't good, but it's strong enough to still be in your shot and so movement outside the range of the flash is in the shot and not frozen. So with HSS I should be able to light something nearby, and then have the shutter speed freeze both foreground and background. Seems the power in this new flash will be put to work.

Does anyone know if we'll be getting stroboscopic flash?

https://www.metz.de/en/flash-units/hints-guides/stroboscopic-flash.html

 ttbek's gear list:ttbek's gear list
Canon PowerShot SX10 IS Canon EOS 5D Samsung NX300 Canon EOS Rebel SL1 Samsung NX30 +37 more
ernesto74 New Member • Posts: 2
Re: Samsung solved the High Sync speed problem !

works on the samsung nx11???

Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum MMy threads