DPReview.com is closing April 10th - Find out more

A REAL MAJOR PHOTOGRAPHIC REVOLUTION ! The perfect of color's restitution !

Started May 25, 2013 | User reviews
Foveonforever New Member • Posts: 6
A REAL MAJOR PHOTOGRAPHIC REVOLUTION ! The perfect of color's restitution !
5

In a first time excuse me for my bad english wrtitten... i'm a french old professionnal photographer and i used more than half of my career the argentic system...  When i used for the first time the numeric sensors  i had to see that the colors are not really precise when you compare them to the natural subtilities  of colors of skins, flowers, , differents of greens  for the grass for exemple.. : It's very important to understand how the standard bayer color capture is using.. , it's IMPOSSIBLE to this to have a real retranscription of  colors, espescially for the green nuances and  deep of colors of the human skins for exemple.. When i'd use the Foveon's sensor, i understand immediatly that it's THE "miracle" and unique solution to have the potential of exact and  best color's restitution. It's really incredible, this sensor use the same principe of the argentic negative, no artefacts, no interpolations, just and only THE REAL COLORS !!! Please go to the Sigma's official web site and read and see, , they said the thrue, and they prouve it, you can trust  them, this sensor is really a major revolution !

You know that Sigma is a small and young office  if you compare it about Nikon, Canon or Leica, , i'm sure that if it was Leica who discover this Foveon sensor, with their incredible mecanical perfections of their cameras and lenses they may be  became  a new time the king of the photographic world !! But  Sigma had the property of this perfect image capture sensor system and  with this camera, the SD1,  you have the same emotion and image quality than an argentic Hasselblad, deep of colors, , finest of details, and only with an APS-C sensor size !!! You can print  a A0 size with this 15 millions of pixel sensor, cause the finest  of the final RAW image is the same than  a 46 million pix of Bayer sensor.., but with the perfect of color restitution more !! For exemple  with the Sigma's SD15  you have only a final pict with 5 millions of pixels, but you can print a A3 size, it look's like a 15 million of classic bayer's sensor, and deep of colors more.. INCREDIBLE ! Test it  and you will see !

I hope that Sigma make a "SD2 Ultimate" with a 24x36mm sensor size, with the same number of pixels from the SD1 ( 3 x 15millions), but with more bigger size for the photosites, and they can resolve the unique problem of their system : The noise !, cause with this sensor and with the SD15 and SD1  you can use it only to 50 iso to maxi 400 iso. Personaly i use their camera's only at 50 iso's cause i make only statics pics, macro lands, portraits and the results after a small work with the original RAW file is just  PERFECT !!

Thank's to Sigma  to trust  with the foveon's technologie, they give to  the maniacs argentics photographers the same sensations with numerics  than the argentic's deep, natural and exact colors !

Uman R-B

Sigma SD1
15 megapixels • 3 screen • APS-C sensor
Announced: Sep 21, 2010
Foveonforever's score
5.0
Average community score
5.0
bad for good for
Kids / pets
great
Action / sports
awful
Landscapes / scenery
excellent
Portraits
excellent
Low light (without flash)
weak
Flash photography (social)
excellent
Studio / still life
excellent
= community average
Sigma SD1 Sigma SD15
If you believe there are incorrect tags, please send us this post using our feedback form.
motomanDK
motomanDK Contributing Member • Posts: 917
Re: A REAL MAJOR PHOTOGRAPHIC REVOLUTION ! The perfect of color's restitution !
2

This is going to be a very long thread ..... and all the trolls will be jumping all over it! 

From my perspective, i will respect the statements from a professional photografer trying to replace his equipment with something that gives the same 'feeling' like his film equipment did. 

-- hide signature --

/Henrik - Denmark
(SD14 and SD15 ... and about 5 kg glass)

 motomanDK's gear list:motomanDK's gear list
Sigma SD14 Sigma SD15 Sigma sd Quattro Sigma sd Quattro H Sigma 10-20mm F4-5.6 EX DC HSM +9 more
anfat Regular Member • Posts: 127
Re: A REAL MAJOR PHOTOGRAPHIC REVOLUTION ! The perfect of color's restitution !
1

"Personaly i use their camera's only at 50 iso's cause i make only statics pics..."

The SD1 has only 100 ISO...

 anfat's gear list:anfat's gear list
Hasselblad X2D 100c Hasselblad XCD 90mm F3.2 Hasselblad XCD 55mm F2.5 V
OP Foveonforever New Member • Posts: 6
Re: A REAL MAJOR PHOTOGRAPHIC REVOLUTION ! The perfect of color's restitution !

exacly ! but if you read my topic i said that i have the SD15 and SD1.. of course i use only the SD15 at 50 iso... the SD1 at 100..., if you see the details with photoshop at x4 of magnification you can see that  the 50 iso's fonction can  smooth really the details  in shadows..

Thank's for your topic

xpatUSA
xpatUSA Forum Pro • Posts: 23,017
Re: A REAL MAJOR PHOTOGRAPHIC REVOLUTION ! The perfect of color's restitution !

For those those who didn't get "argentic" I think it means silver halide film i.e. film cameras.

Don't jump on this guy; he did his best. As an engineer, I once wrote "filete matrix" for female screw thread in spanish. Better yet, I wrote our customer in Mexico a "feliz ano nuevo" which means happy new butt-hole - not quite what I meant to say.

-- hide signature --

Regards,
Ted http://kronometric.org
SD9, SD10, EF-500, GH1.

 xpatUSA's gear list:xpatUSA's gear list
Panasonic Lumix DMC-LX1 Sigma SD9 Panasonic Lumix DC-G9 Panasonic Leica DG Macro-Elmarit 45mm F2.8 ASPH OIS Sigma 17-50mm F2.8 EX DC OS HSM +11 more
Nancy and Pete Spader Senior Member • Posts: 2,050
Re: A REAL MAJOR PHOTOGRAPHIC REVOLUTION ! The perfect of color's restitution !

What this professional photographer is saying may not be perfectly expressedin English, but the meaning is clear, and the feeling he expresses is the same feeling I had when I first saw images from the SD9. I had been convinced that digital cameras would not come close to what film could deliver, and had the same feeling of joy when I was proven wrong by the SD9.

The debates will go on, but the reaction he felt will be felt by many other people new to the Sigma/Foveon images, though not by everybody.

Thank you, sir, for reminding me of the joy of discovery.

Pete

mike earussi Veteran Member • Posts: 9,440
Re: A REAL MAJOR PHOTOGRAPHIC REVOLUTION ! The perfect of color's restitution !

anfat wrote:

"Personaly i use their camera's only at 50 iso's cause i make only statics pics..."

The SD1 has only 100 ISO...

If the scene permits I prefer shooting in the iso 64-80 range, either via exposure compensation, if in AE mode, or manual exposure. I find it produces the best overall "look" having minimum shadow noise without blowing out the highlights, depending on the DR of the scene.

 mike earussi's gear list:mike earussi's gear list
Sigma SD1 Merrill Sigma 105mm F2.8 EX DG Macro Sigma 17-50mm F2.8 EX DC OS HSM Sigma 50mm F1.4 DG HSM | A Sigma 24-35mm F2 DG HSM Art +2 more
carlos roncatti
carlos roncatti Senior Member • Posts: 2,679
Re: A REAL MAJOR PHOTOGRAPHIC REVOLUTION ! The perfect of color's restitution !

Foveonforever wrote:

exacly ! but if you read my topic i said that i have the SD15 and SD1.. of course i use only the SD15 at 50 iso... the SD1 at 100..., if you see the details with photoshop at x4 of magnification you can see that  the 50 iso's fonction can  smooth really the details  in shadows..

Thank's for your topic

5 posts? (2013 may 25 member? ok). Where can we see your pictures? Thanks.

NancyP Veteran Member • Posts: 6,608
Re: A REAL MAJOR PHOTOGRAPHIC REVOLUTION ! The perfect of color's restitution !

Monsieur FoveonForever, your written English beats my written French. There is something unique about Foveon, I agree. I enjoyed monochrome film shooting in the 1960s and 1970s, and now have come to enjoy digital imaging with post-processing application of Favorite Monochrome  Filters and to enjoy digital color on both Bayer sensors (Canon) and Foveon. The Foveon images are special.

 NancyP's gear list:NancyP's gear list
Sigma DP3 Merrill
NancyP Veteran Member • Posts: 6,608
Re: A REAL MAJOR PHOTOGRAPHIC REVOLUTION ! The perfect of color's restitution !

Happy new anus?  Now that has to be one of the better "uh, not exactly" examples of Spanish as written by non-Spanish speaker. Unless said non-Spanish speaker is a surgeon who just fixed the guy's hemorrhoids.

All expressions of photographic enthusiasm are welcome.

 NancyP's gear list:NancyP's gear list
Sigma DP3 Merrill
lbjack Regular Member • Posts: 408
Re: A REAL MAJOR PHOTOGRAPHIC REVOLUTION ! The perfect of color's restitution !

Hey, the queen of England once told parliament she'd had an "annus terribilis," and since it was a speech you couldn't distinguish the double from the single n, so everyone was doubtless feeling her pain.

Roland Karlsson Forum Pro • Posts: 30,033
Re: ...

I am totally stunned. Speechless.

 Roland Karlsson's gear list:Roland Karlsson's gear list
Sigma DP3 Merrill Sigma dp2 Quattro Sony RX100 III Pentax K-3 Pentax K-1 +14 more
jrdigitalart
jrdigitalart Veteran Member • Posts: 3,899
Well, Roland ...

Roland Karlsson wrote:

I am totally stunned. Speechless.

As long as it does not do you any further harm, I'm happy to live with that. ;~)

-- hide signature --

Sincere regards, Jim Roelofs
Cherish your privacy? Avoid (sp)iPhones.
You are welcome to visit my portfolio here:
http://www.pbase.com/jrdigitalart

MOD Kendall Helmstetter Gelner Forum Pro • Posts: 20,587
Re: A REAL MAJOR PHOTOGRAPHIC REVOLUTION ! The perfect of color's restitution !

I love your title.  Mentally your title is exactly what goes through my mind when I look at yet another beautifully captured image treating colors with the utmost of respect...

 Kendall Helmstetter Gelner's gear list:Kendall Helmstetter Gelner's gear list
Sigma 70-200mm F2.8 EX DG OS HSM Sigma 8-16mm F4.5-5.6 DC HSM Sigma 24-70mm F2.8 EX DG HSM Sigma 50-500mm F4.5-6.3 DG OS HSM Sigma 85mm F1.4 EX DG HSM +4 more
Roland Karlsson Forum Pro • Posts: 30,033
Re: A REAL MAJOR PHOTOGRAPHIC REVOLUTION ! The perfect of color's restitution !
3

Hi, I have recovered now from all the CAPS written words and all the superlatives.

Bayer sensors are based on RGB filters. Generally, the color rendition is very accurate. Much more accurate than color film. The high degree of accuracy might be somewhat boring. So, its quite customary today to enhance the colors for more spectacular photography.

Bayer sensors have problems with color based micro contrast. This is both due to the fact that often AA filters are used and that 2 out of 3 colors are computed instead of measured.

Regarding Foveon and color accuracy, there are different opinions. It is quite customary that the colors just go crazy. Yellow skin, green sand, pink cars, orange waterposts, cyan sky, ... etc, etc, .... You might also get (e.g. green) color cast in the corners. But you can also get delightful colors. Its not so easy to get boring correct colors

So, you are of course entitled to your opinion ... but that Foveon should have more accurate colors than Bayer I don´t believe and that Bayer cannot reproduce accurate colors I know to be untrue.

When it comes to resolution and sharpness, that's also debatable. A 24 MP APS-C is the same kind of resolution as SD1 and a 35 MP FF camera has more and a medium format much more. But ... sharpness is not the same as resolution. Sharpness depends on resolution and accutance.

You can get more accutance from Bayer cameras by using some sharpening tool. But ... the images Foveon already have that accutance. The latter is probably to prefer.

Lots of people have tried to show/test the difference. Its not easy.

So ... nice you are enthusiastic. But ... I think you have to come down to earth.

BTW - never heard the name Argentic for silver based systems before. Glad to learn a new name. I know though that Ag is silver.

 Roland Karlsson's gear list:Roland Karlsson's gear list
Sigma DP3 Merrill Sigma dp2 Quattro Sony RX100 III Pentax K-3 Pentax K-1 +14 more
3dreal Senior Member • Posts: 2,271
Re: A REAL MAJOR PHOTOGRAPHIC REVOLUTION ! The perfect of color's restitution !

Argentique is french for silvery or silver-, maybe he translated wrongly.

-- hide signature --

www.stereopan.org

Roland Karlsson Forum Pro • Posts: 30,033
Re: A REAL MAJOR PHOTOGRAPHIC REVOLUTION ! The perfect of color's restitution !

3dreal wrote:

Argentique is french for silvery or silver-, maybe he translated wrongly.

It actually seems like argentic photography is an accepted term for silver based photography.

I have never heard it before - but a search on google gives lots of hits.

 Roland Karlsson's gear list:Roland Karlsson's gear list
Sigma DP3 Merrill Sigma dp2 Quattro Sony RX100 III Pentax K-3 Pentax K-1 +14 more
detectorman
detectorman Regular Member • Posts: 150
Re: A REAL MAJOR PHOTOGRAPHIC REVOLUTION ! The perfect of color's restitution !

It is possible that different Bayer camera companies may use different RGB filter specs in their products -- that is, how wide a spectral band each color covers. I believe that the Foveon magic, if I can call it that, is the large amount of overlap between bands. All Bayers may not be equal.

villebon Senior Member • Posts: 2,225
Re: A REAL MAJOR PHOTOGRAPHIC REVOLUTION ! The perfect of color's restitution !

Roland Karlsson wrote:

3dreal wrote:

Argentique is french for silvery or silver-, maybe he translated wrongly.

It actually seems like argentic photography is an accepted term for silver based photography.

I have never heard it before - but a search on google gives lots of hits.

Argentique is used in photography as in "épreuve argentique" which is a silver based print or as in "film argentique", well you've guessed the meaning by now.

-- hide signature --

Villebon

OP Foveonforever New Member • Posts: 6
Re: A REAL MAJOR PHOTOGRAPHIC REVOLUTION ! The perfect of color's restitution !

Well i'm very impressive about all of the differents reactions from my original topic "A real major photographic revolution", in first time "argentic" word came from the french original pro designation of the "old" world when we make pictures with negatives and slides, argentique is the description of the "argentic paper" when we used papers with "alogenure d'argent" on black and wite manuals laboratory's. Please be tolerating with my pooooor english spoken.. thank's !

it's real when you said that a foveon's sensor of 4.6 megapixels can't give the same result of a 15 mpix of bayer's pict, but visually you can print a A3 size picture with the same sensation of sharpness.. and it's only what every photographer want, isn't it ?

Well in fact one of my best friend lent me his SD1 for 3 month next year, and i was very impresssive about it, i have the SD15 and i use it since 2 years with some of the best of sigma's lens : 10-20 f3.5 EX, 30mm f1.4 EX, 85mm f1.4 EX, 105mm f2.8 macro EX, and 100-300mm f4 EX, flash sigma EF610 DG super, and i use only a Sekonic Digilite hand light sensor for an exact direct light mesure.. when i said you that i was an old photographer..hihi, i make picts since more than 30 years..

Next week one of my photographic partner lent me his Nikon D700 with his AF Nikkor 85mm f1.4, and i tested this camera (12Mpix with bayer sensor) and his lense at the same time with my SD15 (4.6 Mpix on final picture) with my sigma 85mm f1.4 EX, ont the same subjects... I was taking the light mesure with my Sekonic and shooting 4 subjects with the Nikon and the Sigma... The subject was the same, light too, light mesure and manual report too, and same treatment with Raw's files with Adobe Photoshop CS6.. Finaly i just resize the Nikon picture with the same size from the Sigma's original size (2640 x1760 pixels for each final image)::

It's very interesting to see them, cause you can see the real difference from the treatment of the micro-contrast with a bayer's sensor and foveon's sensor..

You can see the result on my Flick Galery here..

http://www.flickr.com/photos/uman-foveon-forever/

Click on on of the pictures to see it with  a good size on your screen, the 4 first images are the result of my test, all of other pictures came from my SD15... Just imagine that the SD15 have only a final picture with 4.6 MPixels (4 646 400 pixels), and the SD1 have the same quality  with a 15 Millions pixels  on final image.. I'm sorry but i can't give my result with my long test  with the SD1 cause i used it only for professional order, but it's easy to find exemples on the web..

If you want to see the original size of my test D700 vs SD15 send me a mail here :

nirmalartuman@orange.fr

Thank's !

Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum MMy threads