Macro lens for Sony Nex: SEL30M35 or Vintage/Legacy manual focus?

Started Feb 14, 2013 | Questions
Shop cameras & lenses ▾
Prembo
Prembo New Member • Posts: 23
Macro lens for Sony Nex: SEL30M35 or Vintage/Legacy manual focus?

Hi,

I would like to purchase a macro lens for my Nex-5.  How good would vintage/legacy manual focus macro lenses be on the NEX as opposed to the AF SEL30M35?

What vintage/legacy manual focus macro lenses do you recommend?  What about the following:

  • Canon FD 35-70 mm macro zoom lens
  • Canon FD 28-55 mm macro zoom lens
  • Canon FD 50 mm f3.5 macro
-- hide signature --

Sony Nex-5, 18-55mm Kit Lens

ANSWER:
This question has not been answered yet.
Sony Alpha NEX-5
If you believe there are incorrect tags, please send us this post using our feedback form.
Letsgokoulos
Letsgokoulos Senior Member • Posts: 1,801
Re: Macro lens for Sony Nex: SEL30M35 or Vintage/Legacy manual focus?

Prembo wrote:

Hi,

I would like to purchase a macro lens for my Nex-5. How good would vintage/legacy manual focus macro lenses be on the NEX as opposed to the AF SEL30M35?

What vintage/legacy manual focus macro lenses do you recommend? What about the following:

  • Canon FD 35-70 mm macro zoom lens
  • Canon FD 28-55 mm macro zoom lens
  • Canon FD 50 mm f3.5 macro
-- hide signature --

Sony Nex-5, 18-55mm Kit Lens

Most macro lenses can be good portrait lenses.

In order to help you, it is necessary that you explain what kind of macro photography you intend to produce... Flowers, insects, still objects ? What level of magnification are you expecting ?

Marc

fotowbert
fotowbert Senior Member • Posts: 2,088
Macro vs portrait lens
1

The description of a zoom lens as "macro" implies it focuses closer that an "non macro" zoom lens but it will not focus to anything like the magnification (think life size or even half life size) that a true macro focusing prime lens is capable of.  Therefore the Canon FD 50 mm f3.5 macro will allow you to fill the frame with smaller subjects.

Portrait shots of people look best when taken from a distance that we are used to looking at each other.  This gives a normal looking distance perspective of the facial features.  If you shoot tight head portraits with a 30mm lens you are likely to be close enough that the subject's nose will appear overly large.  A 50mm or even longer (90 to 100mm) would be better at this.  For full body and group portraits 30mm would be fine.

Also if you want really shallow DOF something f/1.8 may be more to your liking than f/3.5.

  • John 

Prembo wrote:

I would like to purchase a macro lens for my Nex-5. How good would vintage/legacy manual focus macro lenses be on the NEX as opposed to the AF SEL30M35?

What vintage/legacy manual focus macro lenses do you recommend? What about the following:

  • Canon FD 35-70 mm macro zoom lens
  • Canon FD 28-55 mm macro zoom lens
  • Canon FD 50 mm f3.5 macro
 fotowbert's gear list:fotowbert's gear list
Canon PowerShot A20 Canon PowerShot SD870 IS Fujifilm FinePix F31fd Panasonic Lumix DMC-LZ8 Canon PowerShot S95 +15 more
El Matadurr
El Matadurr Senior Member • Posts: 4,988
Re: Macro lens for Sony Nex: SEL30M35 or Vintage/Legacy manual focus?

Prembo wrote:

 El Matadurr's gear list:El Matadurr's gear list
Sony Alpha NEX-7 Carl Zeiss Touit 1.8/32
Sonyshine
Sonyshine Senior Member • Posts: 7,936
Re: Macro lens for Sony Nex: SEL30M35 or Vintage/Legacy manual focus?
2

The SEL30M35 gets my vote!

 Sonyshine's gear list:Sonyshine's gear list
Nikon 1 V2 Nikon 1 J5 Nikon 1 Nikkor VR 30-110mm f/3.8-5.6 Nikon 1 Nikkor 10mm f/2.8 Nikon 1 Nikkor 18.5mm f/1.8 +7 more
nevercat Senior Member • Posts: 3,193
Re: Macro lens for Sony Nex: SEL30M35 or Vintage/Legacy manual focus?

First, when you want to do real macro work (like pictures at 1:1 or so) then you will want to manual focus, as the DOF is very small. And manual focussing wil make you in charge of what is sharp and what not, and not the camera. So Manual Focus lenses are good enoug.

Then when you want to do insects or other living creatures, the FL of the macro lens can not be to long. With the 30mm E-mount you will be very close to the object to obtain 1:1 macro shots. I find a 100mm lens the smallest FL to do macrowork on insects.

There are a lot of those lenses for sale, some older MF lenses are very cheap second hand.
An other thing to remember is the apperture, you will most of the time use a small apperture (likr F8 or so) to obtin the best DOF, so there is no real need for a fast macro lense, a macro flash can be very important.

PaddyC Regular Member • Posts: 255
Re: Macro lens for Sony Nex: SEL30M35 or Vintage/Legacy manual focus?

Another option is to use the LAEA2 adapter and purchase some Minolta macros. I have the Minolta 50 2.8 which I use on my a850. But it works great on my 5N with the adapter.

Just something to think about.

 PaddyC's gear list:PaddyC's gear list
Canon EOS M Canon EOS 6D Canon EF-M 18-55mm f/3.5-5.6 IS STM Canon EF-M 22mm f/2 STM Canon EF-M 11-22mm f/4-5.6 IS STM
forpetessake
forpetessake Senior Member • Posts: 4,892
Re: Macro lens for Sony Nex: SEL30M35 or Vintage/Legacy manual focus?

Prembo wrote:

Hi,

I would like to purchase a macro lens for my Nex-5. How good would vintage/legacy manual focus macro lenses be on the NEX as opposed to the AF SEL30M35?

What vintage/legacy manual focus macro lenses do you recommend? What about the following:

  • Canon FD 35-70 mm macro zoom lens
  • Canon FD 28-55 mm macro zoom lens
  • Canon FD 50 mm f3.5 macro
-- hide signature --

Sony Nex-5, 18-55mm Kit Lens

Tried a lot of options: extension tubes, reverse mount, macro add-on lenses, specialized macro lenses. Nothing works better than a good specialized lens, and among everything I tried the Panagor 90/2.8 (also comes under other names) was an absolute winner, great resolution and contrast upto 1:1 around f/11; and it doesn't have any visible chromatic aberrations, coma or astigmatism, which are all important in macro. If you use add-on lenses choose APO glass, I have a Sigma APO add-on lens and it's flawless.

Joachim Wulfers
Joachim Wulfers Senior Member • Posts: 1,572
Re: Macro lens for Sony Nex: SEL30M35 or Vintage/Legacy manual focus?
1

El Matadurr wrote:

Prembo wrote:

I agree that the 105/2.8 Micro Nikkor is probably one of the sharpest lenses I have. Together with the Nikon PN-11 (with tripod mount) it gives you the 1:1 magnification. See the detailed description in Ken Rockwell's Nikon lens review as well

-- hide signature --

Joachim

 Joachim Wulfers's gear list:Joachim Wulfers's gear list
Sony Alpha NEX-5N Sony a6000 Sony E 18-55mm F3.5-5.6 OSS Sony E 16mm F2.8 Pancake Sony E 18-200mm F3.5-6.3 OSS +9 more
Brian Zhou Regular Member • Posts: 133
Re: Macro lens for Sony Nex: SEL30M35 or Vintage/Legacy manual focus?
4

It really depends on what kind of macro you want to do. For flower, half life size is sufficient; for insect eyes, you want > 1:1 magnification. For insect macro, the working distance is also important. The longer the focal length, the longer the working distance.

Most zooms marked with "macro" are not real macro, cannot achieve half life size magnification.

Macro lenses are typically a little too sharp for portrait. For portrait, subject isolation usually is more important. The traditional focal length (Field of view really) for portraiture is 85mm - 135mm. With NEX's 1.5x crop factor, you're looking at 55mm - 90mm.

There're some excellent legacy macro lenses in that range if your main purpose is macro. Micro Nikkor 55mm f/2.8 or f/3.5, Konica Hexanon 55mm f/3.5 Macro, Tamron Adaptall-2 90mm f/2.5 Macro, Tokina AT-X 90mm f/2.5 Macro. 50mm, 100mm, or 105mm is not far either.

If your main purpose is portrait, I'd also consider a 85mm f/1.8 legacy lens, you can use it for macro with some high quality achromatic close-up add-on.

If you're not sure, consider a 70-150mm zoom lens that can focus relatively close, such as Vivitar 70-150mm/3.8, Nikon Series E 75-150mm/3.5, or Kiron 70-150mm/4.

dpdog Forum Member • Posts: 73
Re: Macro lens for Sony Nex: SEL30M35 or Vintage/Legacy manual focus?

I've heard good things about the SEL55-210 + Canon 500D close-up lens. I think there are some posts on this forum with photo examples.

blue_skies
blue_skies Veteran Member • Posts: 9,809
Re: Macro lens for Sony Nex: SEL30M35 or Vintage/Legacy manual focus?

Prembo wrote:

Hi,

I would like to purchase a macro lens for my Nex-5. How good would vintage/legacy manual focus macro lenses be on the NEX as opposed to the AF

They are different lenses:

SEL30M35

  • Maximum Magnification: 1:1 (1.0x)

Consider which macro level (1:1 or 1:5) you need.

Then, a longer FL enables you to be further away from your subject, given its maximum magnification  level. However, at large magnification, this is always short.

The SEL30M35 does 1:1 magnification at extremely short distances, so lighting could be an issue (e.g. you'll need a ring LED or ring Flash light).

But for small objects, you can get incredible amounts of detail.

The SEL30M35 is great for studio work. If outdoors, you'd be using it more like 1:2 or so.

Alternatives would be the SEL18200 OSS or the Vivitar Series 1 70-200 as a legacy MF lens. Both have decent magnification at reasonable distances. I'd guess that these have magnification factors of around 1:2.5 or so.

You can increase the magnification ratio on any lens using extension tubes or by adding a diopter in front of the lens, something else to consider.

-- hide signature --

Cheers,
Henry

 blue_skies's gear list:blue_skies's gear list
Sony Alpha NEX-6 Sony a6000 Sony a5100 Sony Alpha 7 II Sony DT 18-55mm F3.5-5.6 SAM +33 more
Brian Zhou Regular Member • Posts: 133
Re: Macro lens for Sony Nex: SEL30M35 or Vintage/Legacy manual focus?

blue_skies wrote:

  • You can increase the magnification ratio on any lens using extension tubes or by adding a diopter in front of the lens, something else to consider.

Extension tubes does not work very well with native lens, because you lose aperture control.

blue_skies
blue_skies Veteran Member • Posts: 9,809
Re: Macro lens for Sony Nex: SEL30M35 or Vintage/Legacy manual focus?

Brian Zhou wrote:

blue_skies wrote:

  • You can increase the magnification ratio on any lens using extension tubes or by adding a diopter in front of the lens, something else to consider.

Extension tubes does not work very well with native lens, because you lose aperture control.

On e-mount lenses, aperture settings are retained when the lens is removed from the camera while the camera is on. Live view has to be on too.

-- hide signature --

Cheers,
Henry

 blue_skies's gear list:blue_skies's gear list
Sony Alpha NEX-6 Sony a6000 Sony a5100 Sony Alpha 7 II Sony DT 18-55mm F3.5-5.6 SAM +33 more
steve vida Regular Member • Posts: 412
Re: Macro lens for Sony Nex: SEL30M35 or Vintage/Legacy manual focus?

Ive been very happy with my 55micro Nikkor,the 1.5x factor makes it a reasonable portrait lens but as mentioned these lenses are extremely sharp so they may lead to more work in Photoshop.Im sure the 105Micro would be better for portraits with softer backgrounds but are a few hundred dollars more than the 55 & a bit rarer to find.

 steve vida's gear list:steve vida's gear list
Sony Alpha NEX-5N Sony Alpha 7 Sony E 18-55mm F3.5-5.6 OSS Sony E 16mm F2.8 Pancake Sony E 10-18mm F4 OSS +7 more
El Matadurr
El Matadurr Senior Member • Posts: 4,988
Re: Macro lens for Sony Nex: SEL30M35 or Vintage/Legacy manual focus?

steve vida wrote:

Ive been very happy with my 55micro Nikkor,the 1.5x factor makes it a reasonable portrait lens but as mentioned these lenses are extremely sharp so they may lead to more work in Photoshop.Im sure the 105Micro would be better for portraits with softer backgrounds but are a few hundred dollars more than the 55 & a bit rarer to find.

Not if you do some hunting. Snagged my 105 f/2.8 for $200. Sellers on eBay are usually willing to come down (pretty substantially) if their item doesn't sell at a higher price.

http://matthewdurrphotography.com

 El Matadurr's gear list:El Matadurr's gear list
Sony Alpha NEX-7 Carl Zeiss Touit 1.8/32
captura Forum Pro • Posts: 21,867
Re: Macro lens for Sony Nex: SEL30M35 or Vintage/Legacy manual focus?

For my money, I got the Canon FD 50 mm f3.5 macro. Very inexpensive on the bay and check it out; the resolution etc. is as good as the fastest  f1.4 models from Canon.

kerpan Regular Member • Posts: 375
Re: Macro lens for Sony Nex: SEL30M35 or Vintage/Legacy manual focus?

Your Nikon 105 micro shots are gorgeous!

El Matadurr
El Matadurr Senior Member • Posts: 4,988
Re: Macro lens for Sony Nex: SEL30M35 or Vintage/Legacy manual focus?

kerpan wrote:

Your Nikon 105 micro shots are gorgeous!

Thanks a bunch man, I hope to write the review once I can do it justice (i.e. when flowers start coming back, bugs wake up, etc.).

http://matthewdurrphotography.com

 El Matadurr's gear list:El Matadurr's gear list
Sony Alpha NEX-7 Carl Zeiss Touit 1.8/32
keith1101 Regular Member • Posts: 100
Re: Macro lens for Sony Nex: SEL30M35 or Vintage/Legacy manual focus?

canon 50-3.5 macro fd is a great , you dont need a fast lens,as you need good dof.

Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum MMy threads