Sony E-Mount 10-18 f4 or Tokina 11-16 f2.8

Started Feb 10, 2013 | Discussions
Shop cameras & lenses ▾
baidun New Member • Posts: 10
Sony E-Mount 10-18 f4 or Tokina 11-16 f2.8
1

I was wondering if anyone had experience with these two lenses and could provide Pros and Cons? I'm a total newb and have just finished reading Friedman's Sony Nex-7 book a couple of times (and still trying to understand it all), but I've become enamoured at manual focusing (yet very slow at it and miss many shots because of it). I've searched this site but don't see much regarding the Tokina lens. I have a variety of legacy lenses (35mm and up) along with the original SEL 18-200 (my favorite all around lens), the SEL 50, and the SEL 24. I need a wider angle lens for both outdoor and indoor shots, so I figure a wide angle zoom lens that is somewhat fast would be goodness. The Sony seems very nice, albeit a bit slow and more expensive. I'm not sure, but I don't think OSS would be a big factor at these wide angles, especially outdoors? The Tokina seems great spec-wise and less expensive. I don't do RAW as I haven't figured our Photoshop or Lightroom or any of those SW tools.  Does anyone have experience with the Tokina?

Regards

Sony Alpha NEX-7
If you believe there are incorrect tags, please send us this post using our feedback form.
aap292 Regular Member • Posts: 146
Re: Sony E-Mount 10-18 f4 or Tokina 11-16 f2.8

I think one thing you might consider is that the 10-18 would have lens correction (including distortion) from your NEX. Since you aren't using RAW, then you might have some distortion in your shots that wouldn't get corrected (I think) on the Tokina.

I'm a newbie too, so I'm sure someone else can comment on this.

Clayton1985 Veteran Member • Posts: 5,368
Re: Sony E-Mount 10-18 f4 or Tokina 11-16 f2.8

I've used the Tokina with the A77 and it is a great lens.   It is considerably heavier and bulkier especially with the adapter.   I think you will be happy with the image quality of both so I guess it depends on whether you want the f2.8 and lower price more than the lighter, smaller 10-18 f4.

I would also be aware of the potential for color cast with the NEX 7.   I'm not sure how the Tokina 11-16 fares with the NEX 7 but the 10-18 does exhibit the issue from time to time although most people seem to have concluded that it isn't bad enough to be a deal breaker and can be corrected in post.

Dennishh Contributing Member • Posts: 545
Re: Sony E-Mount 10-18 f4 or Tokina 11-16 f2.8

The 10-18 is always on my NEX-7 and I just love this lens. Not heavy or to large. Very sharp plus the stabilization keeps everything sharp. I would highly recommend this lens.

 Dennishh's gear list:Dennishh's gear list
Sony Alpha 7R Sony Alpha 7R II Sony FE 70-200 F4 Sony FE 28mm F2 Nikon AF Micro-Nikkor 60mm f/2.8D +2 more
baidun OP New Member • Posts: 10
Re: Sony E-Mount 10-18 f4 or Tokina 11-16 f2.8

Good point, given I shoot JPEG-only for now, the in-camera lens correction could be an important factor. I had not thought of that. Some of the images with the Sony that others have posted on this site are incredible. Wish I has access to some taken with the Tokina.

baidun OP New Member • Posts: 10
Re: Sony E-Mount 10-18 f4 or Tokina 11-16 f2.8

Good to know. Do you have any experience in low light indoors with the lens?

garwood71
garwood71 Forum Member • Posts: 86
Re: Sony E-Mount 10-18 f4 or Tokina 11-16 f2.8

The OSS will allow you to slow the speed down by a couple/few stops and brighten things up. 2.8 probably won't be sharp and that's shallow for a wide angle.

 garwood71's gear list:garwood71's gear list
Sony Alpha NEX-5N +3 more
indybird
indybird Junior Member • Posts: 46
Re: Sony E-Mount 10-18 f4 or Tokina 11-16 f2.8
1

I've been using the Tokina 11-16 + LA-EA2 for almost a month now and so far I've mostly loved it. The combo focuses fast and accurately in most situations other than low-light (but thats to be expected). This lens is super-sharp even wide open, and also has great contrast.

There are sometimes I wish I had a little more zoom range like the 10-18mm, but I love the wide aperture too much to make that trade.

Before my purchase I did a lot of research between the two and came to these conclusions:

I'd buy the Tokina 11-16 if you:

-Often take shots with moving subjects

-Are looking to squeeze a little bit of background blur out of your shots

-Prefer a mechanical focus ring (as opposed to the focus-by-wire of E-Mount lenses)

-Are looking for slightly faster/more accurate focus (Thanks to LA-EA2)

I'd buy the Sony 10-18 if you:

-Mostly shoot stills

-Need a relatively compact or lightweight lens (The Tokina + LA-EA2 is very big and very heavy)

-Rely on in-camera lens corrections

-Are looking for a slightly more practical zoom range

 indybird's gear list:indybird's gear list
Olympus PEN E-P5 Olympus 12-40mm F2.8 Panasonic Leica DG Summilux 15mm F1.7 ASPH Olympus E-M5 II Olympus M.Zuiko Digital ED 40-150mm 1:4-5.6 R
kazkioken Contributing Member • Posts: 541
Re: Sony E-Mount 10-18 f4 or Tokina 11-16 f2.8

One more option to consider:

If you don't mind the cost, you might want to consider getting the Metabones Speed Booster, and get a Canon copy of the Tokina lens.  You end up with a true full frame 11-16mm f2 from the stop increase.  I have the 10-18, and really love it - the stabilization is great and I use this for a lot of photo and video work as well.  I use my Voigt 15mm for serious landscape work, but the 10-18 is very close.

And now as I type this, it would be pretty amazing to have an f2.0 full frame 11-16mm on my Nex.  Was waiting for the FD version of the Speed Booster but might just get the current EF...

-- hide signature --
kev777zero
kev777zero Senior Member • Posts: 1,556
Re: Sony E-Mount 10-18 f4 or Tokina 11-16 f2.8

I have neither, but I have several E-mount and A-mount lenses with LA-EA2. My vote will go for the E-mount because of size and weight. Any DSLR/SLT lenses becomes much larger on the NEX, and very bad in ergonomics. I would only go for A-mount lenses that don't exist on the E-mount yet (fast zooms, extra reach, telephoto primes/macros, etc...). Tokina is 1 stop faster, but 10-18mm has OSS. And wide zooms autofocus much better to begin with so the faster AF part is rather irrelevant. just my 2 cents.

 kev777zero's gear list:kev777zero's gear list
Sony Cyber-shot DSC-RX100 III Sony Alpha 7 Rokinon 8mm F2.8 UMC Aspherical Fisheye Sony Vario-Tessar T* FE 16-35mm F4 ZA OSS Sony FE 55mm F1.8 +3 more
Koko Monstrum New Member • Posts: 8
Re: Sony E-Mount 10-18 f4 or Tokina 11-16 f2.8

If you don't mind the cost, you might want to consider getting the Metabones Speed Booster, and get a Canon copy of the Tokina lens. You end up with a true full frame 11-16mm f2 from the stop increase. I have the 10-18, and really love it - the stabilization is great and I use this for a lot of photo and video work as well. I use my Voigt 15mm for serious landscape work, but the 10-18 is very close.

And now as I type this, it would be pretty amazing to have an f2.0 full frame 11-16mm on my Nex. Was waiting for the FD version of the Speed Booster but might just get the current EF...

The Tokina is a DX lens and would not work well on the Speed Booster.

-- hide signature --
Nikolai Vassiliev Regular Member • Posts: 359
Re: Sony E-Mount 10-18 f4 or Tokina 11-16 f2.8

10-18 also has OSS - very useful for video.

-- hide signature --
 Nikolai Vassiliev's gear list:Nikolai Vassiliev's gear list
Sony Alpha DSLR-A900 Sony Alpha 7R Sony 24mm F2 SSM Carl Zeiss Distagon T* Sony 85mm F2.8 SAM Samyang T-S 24mm F3.5 ED AS UMC +4 more
baidun OP New Member • Posts: 10
Re: Sony E-Mount 10-18 f4 or Tokina 11-16 f2.8

Thanks for all the replies and feedback. I'm going to have to get to the bottom of things and just make a decision - I think either lens can be resold if I decide incorrectly for me.

The size/weight of the Tokina doesn't bother me too much as I routinely carry the SEL18-200 (original) lens on my Nex 7, love the versatility and IQ, and am used to the weight. I do take videos with the setup, so the OSS in the Sony 10-18 would be helpful and may make up for the difference between f4 and f2.8. I can get the Tokina in used but excellent condition for about 400 less than the Sony; the Sony is too new to be found used. When it comes to lenses, especially in the size I use a lot, I don't like to skimp and tend to put IQ and low light capability at the top of my priority list. In-camera lens correction may end up being a decision factor for me, but being forced into learning Lightroom isn't a bad thing either:)

Regards,

Dennishh Contributing Member • Posts: 545
Re: Sony E-Mount 10-18 f4 or Tokina 11-16 f2.8

I have been loaning this camera to my son to use on assignments at work. He's been using the combination on totally automatic mode which shoots at f4 with the flash bouncing off the ceiling. The images have been very sharp.

 Dennishh's gear list:Dennishh's gear list
Sony Alpha 7R Sony Alpha 7R II Sony FE 70-200 F4 Sony FE 28mm F2 Nikon AF Micro-Nikkor 60mm f/2.8D +2 more
Jefenator
Jefenator Senior Member • Posts: 2,081
Re: Sony E-Mount 10-18 f4 or Tokina 11-16 f2.8

I briefly had the Tokina 11-16 with the LA-EA1 adapter and found the combination to be objectionably bulky. I am an enthusiastic legacy lens user - none of my old Nikkor or Canon primes bug me that way - not even the FL 55/1.2 or the Micro-Nikkor 105/2.8. But for some reason, I felt that Tokina 11-16 would have been a drag to deal with. (Can't just tote it in a jacket pocket, the way I like to do with all my primes...) Since I had a bad copy, returning it was a no-brainer.

A good copy, delivering sharp renderings as per the lens' reputation, that might be a tougher call. The Sony's size point would be a major consideration and would probably win me over if IQ were in the same ballpark. (Speed and focus feel would be very minor considerations for me in a lens of this type.)

As it is, I'm looking hard at the Voigtlander 15mm - or maybe that Zeiss 12mm when it comes out.

 Jefenator's gear list:Jefenator's gear list
Sony Alpha 7 Sony FE 55mm F1.8 Canon EF-M 11-22mm f/4-5.6 IS STM Sony FE 90mm F2.8 macro Canon EOS M +3 more
joun Junior Member • Posts: 37
Re: Sony E-Mount 10-18 f4 or Tokina 11-16 f2.8

apparently it's quite usable at the 16mm end with the Speed Booster, but at 11mm you get vignetting. Same as using it on a FF camera body

Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum MMy threads