Reading mode: Light Dark

Strange Tamron 17-70mm vignetting

Go to last post
Tamron me dijo que era un problema de Adobe. Porque solo existe el problema con el software de Adobe.

Adobe ha registrado el problema.

Estamos esperando una solución.
 
fernandojval said:
Although Adobe has been made aware, in the Adobe community forum, of the double vignetting error of the Tamron 17-70mm f2.8 lens for Fuji, nothing has changed in the latest version of LR, ACR or PS.

If you are thinking of buying this lens and you edit with Adobe software, I give you a recommendation: WAIT, the bug is still there.
Click to expand...
 
Six months after the strange vignetting of the Tamron 17-70mm f2.8 when shooting with Fujifilm at 17mm f2.8 was announced on the Adobe forum, Adobe has not fixed the problem.
 
fernandojval said:
Six months after the strange vignetting of the Tamron 17-70mm f2.8 when shooting with Fujifilm at 17mm f2.8 was announced on the Adobe forum, Adobe has not fixed the problem.
Click to expand...
 
Is the lens profile info dependent on focal length? My guess is yes. So what if in that case the lens reports the incorrect focal length and as such the wrong correction curve is applied?
 
sir_c said:
Is the lens profile info dependent on focal length? My guess is yes. So what if in that case the lens reports the incorrect focal length and as such the wrong correction curve is applied?
Click to expand...
I can’t imagine the “corrections” being applied to be appropriate for any lens. Something is either very corrupted in the firmware data to begin with, or there is glitch in translating the metadata into actual image correction.
 
Erik Baumgartner said:
fernandojval said:
Six months after the strange vignetting of the Tamron 17-70mm f2.8 when shooting with Fujifilm at 17mm f2.8 was announced on the Adobe forum, Adobe has not fixed the problem.
Click to expand...
Who says it’s Adobe’s fault? Adobe didn’t produce the lens correction data, Tamron did, it’s contained in the lens firmware and has nothing to do with Adobe. As Adobe doesn’t seem to be producing these kinds of issues with any other lenses, I’m thinking the issue is with the lens firmware, not Adobe’s processing. Besides, if I apply the corrections using Iridient X-Transformer, I get the same weird error as when Lightroom does it. Talk to Tamron about a lens firmware update.
Click to expand...
I say it. If the error does not appear with other software, the problem is with the software in which the error appears.
 
fernandojval said:
Erik Baumgartner said:
fernandojval said:
Six months after the strange vignetting of the Tamron 17-70mm f2.8 when shooting with Fujifilm at 17mm f2.8 was announced on the Adobe forum, Adobe has not fixed the problem.
Click to expand...
Who says it’s Adobe’s fault? Adobe didn’t produce the lens correction data, Tamron did, it’s contained in the lens firmware and has nothing to do with Adobe. As Adobe doesn’t seem to be producing these kinds of issues with any other lenses, I’m thinking the issue is with the lens firmware, not Adobe’s processing. Besides, if I apply the corrections using Iridient X-Transformer, I get the same weird error as when Lightroom does it. Talk to Tamron about a lens firmware update.
Click to expand...
I say it. If the error does not appear with other software, the problem is with the software in which the error appears.
Click to expand...
Not all other software use the lens-based firmware corrections by default - Capture One and DxO in particular. Have you confirmed that there is no issue with other software using the Manufacturer’s correction profile and not their own?
 
Last edited:
Neither Fujifilm's software, nor Capture One, nor Darkrable, nor Affinity Photo give the double vignetting problem.
 
fernandojval said:
Neither Fujifilm's software, nor Capture One, nor Darkrable, nor Affinity Photo give the double vignetting problem.
Click to expand...
But have you tried them with the built-in Manufacturer's profile? Lightroom uses it by default, but other software does not.

Also, I've got a few RAWs on my computer from other Tamron 17-70s with no vignetting issues at all in Lightroom.
 
Erik Baumgartner said:
fernandojval said:
Neither Fujifilm's software, nor Capture One, nor Darkrable, nor Affinity Photo give the double vignetting problem.
Click to expand...
But have you tried them with the built-in Manufacturer's profile? Lightroom uses it by default, but other software does not.

Also, I've got a few RAWs on my computer from other Tamron 17-70s with no vignetting issues at all in Lightroom.
Click to expand...
How do I apply the manufacturer profile in LR? The vignetting does not appear in all my photographs either and when it appears it is a few moments after importing it into LR. The photo looks good and LR does something and vignetting appears. Thanks for your help.
 
fernandojval said:
Neither Fujifilm's software, nor Capture One, nor Darkrable, nor Affinity Photo give the double vignetting problem.
Click to expand...
I just tested your shared RAF in darktable using the embedded metadata in EXIF vs using calibrated lensfun data. The embedded metadata from the lens is indeed incorrect, it does cause the weird ring in darktable.

FWIW, the X-T4 and X-T5 are both using the new correction format that darktable has reverse-engineered :
  • Exif.Fujifilm.GeometricDistortionParams: 19 values
  • Exif.Fujifilm.ChromaticAberrationParams: 29 values
  • Exif.Fujifilm.VignettingParams: 19 values
My X-T2 is still using the old format (23-31-23 values) which darktable doesn't know how to parse, thus, I'm using my calibrated lensfun data instead.

weird ring when using the embedded metadata
weird ring when using the embedded metadata

no problem with the calibrated lensfun data
no problem with the calibrated lensfun data
 
Last edited:
Sorry but I do not get anything like that with the lens on XT3 then XH2s XH2 and Adobe ACR in PS.

Did you check FW ? are they all upgraded ? There was an upgrade for 17-70mm quite recently
 
When I open your file (RAF) with ACR in PS I get the weird effect. BUT when I open my own RAF files with the lens involved, everything is perfect.

So definitly there is something wrong in your combo XT4+ Tamron

Be sure you have updated both camera and lens to the latest FW. For Tamron

https://www.tamron.jp/en/support/release_note.html#camera 17/11/22 FW 2.0

For Fuji XT4 https://fujifilm-x.com/global/support/download/firmware/cameras/ FW 1.71

There is nothing wrong with the Tamron my system on differnt bodies work perfectly WIN 10 Pro Adob PS last version 24.2 ACR 15.2

Bob
 
I have been using the lens since its launch last year in summer and ACR in PS with XT3 then XH2s and XH2, no problem at all with the RAF files at f 2.8 125 ISO

Clearly there is something wrong in the OP combo. The first step is to check for FW upgrade both body and lens, then if not solved check the SD card. Obviously medata innthe RAF contains an error which is specific to the OP's config
 
5b602b1881ca4e9a8fe1e1c7da14fc79.jpg

--
Good judgment comes from experience
Experience comes from bad judgment
 
Last edited:
baobob said:
baobob escribió:

Cuando abro su archivo (RAF) con ACR en PS obtengo el efecto extraño. PERO cuando abro mis propios archivos RAF con la lente involucrada, todo es perfecto.

Así que definitivamente hay algo mal en tu combo XT4+ Tamron

Asegúrese de haber actualizado tanto la cámara como el lente al último FW. Para Tamron

https://www.tamron.jp/en/support/release_note.html#camera 17/11/22 FW 2.0

Para Fuji XT4 https://fujifilm-x.com/global/support/download/firmware/cameras/ FW 1.71

No hay nada malo con el Tamron mi sistema en diferentes cuerpos funciona perfectamente WIN 10 Pro Adob PS última versión 24.2 ACR 15.2

Bob
Click to expand...
Thank you for your response.

Everything is up to date:
X-T4 v1.71
17-70 v2.01
Camera Raw is the subscription version for Mac
 
Try different sd cards
 
fernandojval said:
Erik Baumgartner said:
fernandojval said:
Neither Fujifilm's software, nor Capture One, nor Darkrable, nor Affinity Photo give the double vignetting problem.
Click to expand...
But have you tried them with the built-in Manufacturer's profile? Lightroom uses it by default, but other software does not.

Also, I've got a few RAWs on my computer from other Tamron 17-70s with no vignetting issues at all in Lightroom.
Click to expand...
How do I apply the manufacturer profile in LR? The vignetting does not appear in all my photographs either and when it appears it is a few moments after importing it into LR. The photo looks good and LR does something and vignetting appears. Thanks for your help.
Click to expand...
Lightroom applies the built-in lens corrections automatically at import - and (unfortunately) it can’t be turned off.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Keyboard shortcuts

f
Forum
m
My threads
Mobile site
About
Editorial content
Cameras & Lenses
Community
All content, design, and layout are Copyright © 1998–2025 Digital Photography Review All Rights Reserved.
Reproduction in whole or part in any form or medium without specific written permission is prohibited.
When you use DPReview links to buy products, the site may earn a commission.
©GPS Media - Guides, Products, Services.
Back
Top