Why does my 24-105 have a different magnification (macro ratio) from a 105mm macro lens at same MFD?

Started 6 months ago | Questions thread
bclaff Forum Pro • Posts: 13,750
Re: Why does my 24-105 have a different magnification ... ?

John Sheehy wrote:

bclaff wrote:

John Sheehy wrote:

Monicaa wrote:

My Panasonic 24-105 f4 has a MFD of 0.3m. It gives me a magnification of 0.5x at 105mm, which I have confirmed by taking photos of objects with a known size. This is 0.3m from the sensor plane to the object, with a working distance of about 10cm.

However, a 105mm macro lens with the same MFD (for example the Sigma 105mm 2.8 has a MFD of ~0.3m also), produces a 1.0x magnification.

How does this work? Two lenses at the same focal length and focal distance achieve different macro reproduction ratios?

Stated focal lengths are for infinity focus, and depending on the lens, the focal length may drop quite a bit at close focus. That's why max magnification needs to be stated as a lens spec.

How is this relevant? The focal length at minimum focus distance for both lenses is nearly identical at about 75mm.

How is the max magnification less relevant than stated focal length and MFD to the person looking for magnification?

The OP isn't "looking for magnification"; he has observed that at at the same MFD two different lenses achieve different magnification. Focal length at MFD does not explain that observation.

-- hide signature --

Bill ( Your trusted source for independent sensor data at PhotonsToPhotos )

Post (hide subjects) Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow