DPReview.com is closing April 10th - Find out more

Serious complaint

Started Jan 6, 2022 | Discussions thread
joenj Contributing Member • Posts: 911
Re: Clarification

Alastair Norcross wrote:

Many years ago I published an article in an academic journal criticizing the common practices involved in raising animals for human consumption. That article has since been reprinted in many textbooks for introductory-level ethics classes in colleges and universities, and my article has been assigned (and sometimes even read!) in many such courses. The article contains an imaginary example involving a person who really loves chocolate, but is involved in a car accident which damages his "Godiva gland" which secretes the hormone responsible for enjoying the taste of chocolate, "cocoamone". The Godiva gland and cocoamone are both, of course, fictitious. However, I still get frequent emails from students who have read my paper, asking me where to find information about this gland and this hormone, because they've never heard of it previously.

I suppose this is understandable (though still amusing). The example occurs in a scholarly article, which also contains a lot of serious arguments (though, to be fair, one or two jokes as well). I can see how students just aren't expecting some lighthearted frivolity to be mixed in with a serious discussion of a serious, and quite gruesome, subject.

But I thought that this post on this discussion forum wouldn't be quite as difficult to interpret. I thought I had given enough clues that it was parody. First, there was the description of my repeatedly pressing the side of my EVF hump to get a non-existent flash to spring up. Then there was the hyperventilating style, like when I claimed of my previous cameras that Every. Single. One. had built-in flashes, and immediately took that back. Surely, you could tell I wasn't serious, when I complained that Canon hadn't sent me a $600 flash for free to go with my $1100 refurbished camera? And finally, I literally quoted the title of another current thread ("Why is Canon so mean?"), and finished with a really over the top repetition. I know that most of you got it, but some really seemed to take it seriously. As someone else pointed out, my post was really long, and maybe people just responded without reading it all. Yes, and so is this one, so I expect lots of people to respond with questions about the Godiva gland and cocoamone. Like, where can we get some of that stuff? How much does it cost? Is it legal in Alabama?

Interesting "study".

Are you writing a paper about this thread or at least use it as an example in your lectures?

Post (hide subjects) Posted by
MAC
KEG
KEG
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow