Sony Alpha 1, SEL 200-600 or Canon R5, RF 100-500

Started 4 months ago | Discussions thread
duncang Contributing Member • Posts: 515
Re: Sony Alpha 1, SEL 200-600 or Canon R5, RF 100-500

nandbytes wrote:

duncang wrote:

I would like to see 200-600 images showing this amount of detail and sharpness. In fact would like to see images from any camera/lens combo that can match this.

And both the FE100-400GM and the 100-500L have a clarity about them that the 200-600 just seem to lack - I guess that's what comes with being a 'budget' lens.

200-600mm isn't a unsharp "budget" lens as you put it. Its perfectly capable of producing equally sharp results. Having had both 100-400mm and 200-600mm, 100-400mm mostly has an advantage in the corners and may be slight advantage mid frame but in no way is 200-600mm a slouch you seem to think it is.

crop from A7RIV of a small bird with 200-600mm

I never said it wasn't sharp or a slouch - it is plenty sharp alright - but it does lack a bit of the contrast and clarity the GM and L series lenses seem to have.  And the "budget" comment was just a quote from someone on the forum who was complaining about comparing what was apparently a "budget" Sony lens with the 100-500 L Series lens.  $2200 hardly seem "budget" to me but then it is quite a bit cheaper than the 100-500L Series here in AU. No longer so for the 100-400GM which can be found for $2800 now.

In any event my comment above was not a general comment about the sharpness of the 200-600 - it was about getting sharp detailed images of flying swallows with the 200-600 where the extra weight means it is much harder to track swallows. And if you are shooting at 400mm then f5.6 means you can shoot with a faster shutter speed to minimise the motion blur at the same or lower iso that with the 200-600 with the resultant lower noise and cleaner final images.

Post (hide subjects) Posted by
(unknown member)
(unknown member)
(unknown member)
(unknown member)
(unknown member)
(unknown member)
(unknown member)
(unknown member)
(unknown member)
(unknown member)
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow