500PF Rectilinear Distortion?

Started 5 months ago | Discussions thread
Henderson92 Junior Member • Posts: 46
Re: 500PF Rectilinear Distortion?

thorsbane wrote:

I should probably cross post on Sigma but figure I'd start here since it affects both of my lenses.

Summary: Is it normal to experience rectilinear distortion on telephoto or zoom lenses? I thought rectilinear distortion was primarily the domain of wide angle lenses. I apologize for my ignorance in advance and welcome constructive feedback!

I was performing an AF fine tune on my Sigma 150-600 lens, shooting my test target at roughly 15 feet @ 600mm. I know this is less than the recommended distance but at longer distances it is harder to gauge front/back focus.

Anyhow, I noticed the lines on the ruler appeared distorted, shown here cropped. This was on my Nikon D300s:

Nikon D300s using Sigma 150-600 HSM-C lens @600mm from roughly 15 feet. f6.3, 1/125

Just in case my sensor was bad, I switched over to my D500 body:

Nikon D500 using Sigma 150-600 HSM-C lens @600mm from roughly 15 feet. f6.3, 1/500

Whoa. I noticed the same effect, so I thought I must have a bad Sigma lens, as on both bodies it exhibited the same distortion.

Just for grins I switched over to my relatively new Nikon 500mm PF lens:

Nikon D500 using Nikon 500mm PF from roughly 15 feet. f5.6, 1/500

Sorry for the quality of these crops and jpg artifacts, but the point is that I noticed similar linear distortion near the 0 degree angle of the ruler.

Not as bad as Sigma but still noticeably present when compared to the Sigma, and at 500 vs. 600mm.

Is this normal for telephoto lenses? Am I worrying about nothing? I don't notice any impact when shooting my primary subjects (birds), however, will this introduce subtle distortion into all of my photos?

Thanks in advance for feedback, even if it is to laugh at my naïveté, as perhaps most photographers already know this stuff and this is a dumb question. I promise I google searched and DPreview searched, but all topics seemed to be on wide angle, not telephoto lenses.


 Henderson92's gear list:Henderson92's gear list
Nikon D300 Nikon D300S Nikon 1 V2 Nikon 1 V3 Nikon D500 +1 more
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow