16-35 f4: Mostly likely cause of soft Left & Right Edges?

Started 3 months ago | Questions thread
nkistrup
OP nkistrup Senior Member • Posts: 2,568
Re: 16-35 f4, in Infrared vs. Sony 10-18 f4 in visible light

Doppler9000 wrote:

Igor Sotelo wrote:

nkistrup wrote:

Agreed that wide lengths will suffer more from edge softness. But still think the Canon 16-35 should be doing better.

Took a photo w. the Canon @ f11, vs. f8 for the Sony (DoF should be the same); Canon shot at 16mm, Sony at 11mm, which should be close. Here are the results:

Sony 10-18 f4

Canon 16-35 f4

In both cases, cropped the lower right 1200x1200.

Canon is definitely softer. So back to my original question: Is the Canon lens a poor copy, or Does it suffer from softer edges in infrared?

Lenses for APS-C are smaller and less expensive to make and easier to make sharp at the edges.

The trade of using cropped sensors however, is lower high iso performance, and a stop less of subject isolation compared to FX.

Exactly. In addition, it is an entirely different lens, so the comparison provides no insight.

I think you will need to compare the lens to a known good copy of the same lens, and/or use the lens on a FF visible spectrum camera to gain insight into what is causing the issues you see.

Decided to reach out to Life Pixel, who sold me the converted A7iii body. Infrared is the culprit ==>

"... edges are soft for all wide angle and super wide angle lenses on any converted camera due to barrel distortion."

Conclusion: Another copy of the lens might be a little sharper.  Fighting another quirk of infrared photography, so my options are:

  1. Search for a group of wide primes.  So far, only the Irix 15mm has both the sharpness & is IR hot spot free.
  2. Scrap the idea of going wide in IR.
  3. Stop pixel peeping & live with it.

Thanks to both you & Igor for chiming in.

-- hide signature --

“Photography is inspired by beauty, captured with passion.”
? Destin Sparks

 nkistrup's gear list:nkistrup's gear list
Olympus XZ-1 Nikon D7100 Sony a7 III Sony a6400 Nikon AF-S DX Nikkor 17-55mm f/2.8G ED-IF +10 more
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow