DPReview.com is closing April 10th - Find out more

A brief initial review of the GX9 vs GX8

Started Oct 23, 2020 | Discussions thread
softmarmotte
softmarmotte Veteran Member • Posts: 4,516
Re: A brief initial review of the GX9 vs GX8

interesting to read your views of the gx9. i can't comment on the comparisons to gx8, as i have never handled one

i bought mine primarily as a backup and light weight camera to my oly em 1 ii, for when i go hiking and also to see if it went better with my pana 100-300 for birding

thought i'd add my comments as there don't seem to be many reviews, comments or users of the gx9...poor seller ?

like you i find the colour rendering pleasant - for me not quite to oly standard but then i like a lush look

i find it much easier to find my way around than with the oly but then it has far less menu choices. this is what i wanted anyway. the menu and fn2 quick menus are very good and easy to change setups, as are the custom choices on the top dial

the screen is good but i prefer fas. no deal breaker and i just adapt my style to suit the camera - which is a bit weird but...

like you the evf is not bad but it's not great. just too small. contrary to popular opinion i find n problem with polarised sunglasses. i have the rubber eye cup thingy, which hekps in most light (i am a speccy person)

compared to the oly the af is slower and misses more. it's still good though and it's not surprising in a camera 1/3 of the price. it wasn't what i bought the thing for. the most irritating thing is that i can't find a way to have peaking in af mode like i can with the oly. i want to be in af, press a button on the back to keep it in af but see focus peaking...anyone ?

noise is not a problem in either camera and i am not sure why all the nonsense is written about noise and mft. it's all about getting your exposure right with ss and aperture. yes i know you need to increase iso if you are after taking moving objects in the dark but i have no issues up to 6400

ergonomics is nothing like the em 1 but then it weighs less and is smaller !. however i find that i support with the lens and not the body. no problem

still trying to find a way to get consistently well focused small birds and have found that using the 4k mode with 49 area and aff gives me my best results

2 cropped pics below. one with 4k and the other with m burst

tufty in the rain

geraldine (and gerald) in the rain

same conclusion. good middle end camera and very well priced at under 500 eur with the invisible 12-32 lens

First, the good:

The best thing about this camera is that the color rendition is just excellent. Panasonic really stepped it up more than one notch here; They finally tweaked out the greenish cast to the yellows that they were prone to, yet didn't go over to the full Oly-type super lush color rendering, for which I am very grateful.

Next is overall functionality. Even though it does not have as many buttons as the GX8, it has enough for my purposes, and it does have the two dials plus the exposure dial, so it's plenty adjustable.

The flippy LCD is also something I prefer, and I find I am using that far more than I use the FAS on the GX8. I'm not a hard head about what kind of articulation a camera has; If a camera has everything I want in other features, the screen type is not a make-or-break issue for me. However, since I do prefer to use the flippy screen and the GX9 has a nice one, it gets points from me on that score.

This brings us to the EVF: I was expecting it to be, well, BAD. Fortunately, I was very pleasantly surprised to find that Panasonic had put a better lens in the front of the EVF this time, so no coke-bottle distortion! Hallelujah! Of course, it's not a BIG panel in there, and it is field sequential, but the FS rainbow effect is much, much, reduced over earlier generation versions. A GX8 it's not, but it is absolutely eminently usable, and noticeably better than its GX7, and GX85 predecessors.

Lower light AF is very good, I think it locks on to things just a little better than the GX8 does in very low light.

Overall sensor noise control is improved over the GX8. This is especially obvious as you start bumping up the ISO a bit. I still wouldn't want to use M43 much over ISO 3200, but my overall impression is that I can shoot acceptably detailed and clean shots in lower light up to ISO 1600 easily with the GX9, and I even have pet shots with very good fur detail at ISO 3200 with it. On the GX8 there is much more detail loss at low light ISO 1600. Now, this is subjective as I have not sat down and shot identical images to compare, but judging from what I have to do in PP to clean up the shots, I think there is a decided advantage to the GX9 in this area.

Now the downsides:

The IBIS is OK, when used on non-stabilized lenses, but it's definitely not as good as the Oly version. It's a little better than the version on the GX8, but not, surprisingly, as much better as I thought it would be. On the other hand, when used with a Panasonic lens with stabilization, the Dual IS is VERY effective. It does makes kind of a clunk when it engages (the version on my GX8 does also, but I was surprised that this one does too).

Panasonic did some tweaks to their touch screen options after the GX8, so the ability to shut off the touch screen while still allowing access to the virtual function buttons on it is no longer an option (I think the GX8 might have been the only camera that let you do that, though, as all of the other current ones don't either).

If you are left eyed, the distance the eyepiece protrudes out behind the screen is too shallow, so your nose tends to move the focus point around....I have the larger eye cup on order, which should take care of that, but, since you can't turn off the touchscreen only partially, it's something left-eyed shooters should be aware of if they want to leave the touch screen functions on.

I have had a couple of instances with the GX9 ( the one I have now, not the defective one I had exchanged) where it simply refuses to focus and yet still takes the shot. It's not common, and it's usually after it has racked the lens back and forth to capture focus on something without success, but instead of continuing to try to focus, at that point it just stops and lets you actually shoot, with the result of just a big blur. Not sure what that's about, and it might be a lens/body issue (it seemed to do it more on the plastic fantastic Oly 40-150mm f 4-5.6). I have to explore that a bit more to see if I can narrow down when it's actually occurring.

The grip is...meh. I'll probably try and dig up a half case for it at some point, which will solve that nicely.

And, last, but not least, it feels and works like a decent, middle of the line camera, which is what it is. It does not have the build quality or feel of a higher end mechanical device, which the GX8 does. I'm not faulting it for this; it was not nearly as expensive as the GX8, so I did not expect all the little niceties that that body has to have made their way to this one. The good thing is that the GX9's output is really excellent, which compensates for losing some of the GX8's elan .

Conclusion:
Excellent middle-end M43 camera in a decently small form factor with great looking output. The EVF isn't world class, but it's very usable, with the updates it has from the previous models with it. I'm keeping this one!

Some photos below with examples of the really quite nice color rendition of this body:

Freshly molted Mallard in his lustrous new plumage

My favorite marsh

Pokeweed berries! No, not edible...

Very slow moving bees in the chill out there today. (It's a Carpenter Bee). And yes, they do bore holes in wood to nest, ergo their name.

-J

-- hide signature --

anyone is welcome to do anything they want with my images except sell them for profit
https://www.flickr.com/photos/softmarmotte/

 softmarmotte's gear list:softmarmotte's gear list
Sony RX100 Olympus E-M1 II Panasonic Lumix DC-GX9 Olympus M.Zuiko Digital ED 14-150mm 1:4-5.6 Olympus M.Zuiko Digital ED 40-150mm F4-5.6 R +13 more
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow