Customer Returns, Lens/Camera

Started 2 months ago | Discussions thread
Todd Jones
Todd Jones Senior Member • Posts: 1,485
Re: Customer Returns, Lens/Camera

ikaika777 wrote:

Todd Jones wrote:

ikaika777 wrote:

Ed B wrote:

ikaika777 wrote:

It’s against the law for retailers to sell used products “as new”. They have to sell it as used or open box/demo. Places like B&H and Adorama offer 30 days return policy on used/open box/demo products. There’s nothing worse than buying someone else’s lemon.

That's 100% false.

There are no laws, of this kind, that protect U.S. consumers.

B&H, along with every other large retailer, that has liberal return policies, inspects, cleans and repacks returns and if there are no visual defects to the equipment or the box, the items are resold as new.

B&H has admitted this several times in the past.

If the box is damaged or there are minor imperfections (scratches, etc.) the item will be sold as an "open box".

Returned items that actually have a manufacturer's defect are returned to the manufacturer but if there no manufacturer's defect they are sold as stated above.

Liberal return policies are great for some people but they're like a pyramid scheme and sooner or later, someone gets stuck with the used camera someone else tried, used, took on vacation and then returned for a refund.

It happens every day, here in the States.

I do agree that in other countries this is against the law but most other countries don't have liberal return policies.

You are 100% wrong.

”No Legal Definition of Refurbished

I think you're moving the goal posts, who's talking about refurbished?

Um, no. You either didn’t read what I posted or didn’t understand. I’ll try again:

Um, I'll try again too.

”While the phrase "refurbished" implies that a seller has repaired the product and put it into good working condition, there's actually no legal definition of refurbished goods. ***As such, the expression can

****CAN can also mean NOT

cover any number of scenarios, such as:

  • *******A brand new item that has been returned by a consumer who never used the product
  • A used item that has been repaired and reconditioned by the manufacturer or a third party
  • A demo unit
  • A new item that has damaged packaging”

As you can clearly see it states that “refurbished” also includes, “A brand new item that has been returned by consumer who never used the product

right, this Can mean that BUT not necessarily. Your lens when returned can be sold as refurbished BUT, it DOESN'T HAVE TO!!!

PLEASE READ THIS FOR YOURSELF, and i quote "We are very strict about returned merchandise. Each piece is individually inspected. That means that when the customer's parcel gets to us, it's unpacked by our staff, each piece inspected and then the whole thing repacked. If it's in as-new condition, according to our strict standards, it's returned to inventory. If not, depending on circumstances, it's marked "open box" and sold that way at a discount, or returned to the customer."

http://www.dpreview.com/forums/post/1944032

That is directly from B&H Photo from all the way back in 2001, IF their policy has changed, and maybe it has, please correct it here for us.

OR a demo unit OR a new item that has damaged packaging. Bottom line is it is unlawful to advertise a used product for sale as “new” as per the Federal truth-in-advertising law, administered by the U.S. Federal Trade Commission. It’s the law.

While the phrase "refurbished" implies that a seller has repaired the product and put it into good working condition, there's actually no legal definition of refurbished goods. As such, the expression can cover any number of scenarios, such as:

  • ***A brand new item that has been returned by a consumer who never used the product
  • A used item that has been repaired and reconditioned by the manufacturer or a third party
  • A demo unit
  • A new item that has damaged packaging

***The basic rule for refurbished goods is that once a product is returned, it cannot be sold as new, even if the product was never used.

So, any of these items may be lawfully sold as "refurbished" for a fraction of the cost of a new item.

Selling Refurbished as New is a Type of Fraud

***Federal truth-in-advertising law, administered by the U.S. Federal Trade Commission, requires that refurbished and reconditioned items are properly labeled. ***This means that a seller cannot describe a returned or refurbished item as "new." Where a seller advertises a smartphone as new, for example, and in fact it has been used and refurbished, he could face criminal fraud charges, fines and jail time, if your local prosecutor deems the case worth pursuing. To get the ball rolling on such charges, you would have to file a police report. Criminal aspect aside, as a buyer, you can file a lawsuit against the supplier for misrepresentation. If successful, you will be able to cancel the transaction and at least get your money back, and your state may have a law that provides you with further money damages.”

”20.1 Deception generally.

(a) It is unfair or deceptive to represent, directly or by implication, that any industry product is new or unused when such is not the fact, or to misrepresent the current condition, or extent of previous use, reconstruction, or repair of any industry product.”

https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/16/20.1

Besides the Federal truth-in-advertising law, administered by the U.S. Federal Trade Commission, states also have their own laws protecting consumers of such unlawful practices.

-- hide signature --

Todd
I'm His, John 6:44

 Todd Jones's gear list:Todd Jones's gear list
Fujifilm X-T2 Fujifilm XF 18mm F2 R Fujifilm XF 35mm F1.4 R Fujifilm XF 16mm F1.4 R WR XF 90mm
Post (hide subjects) Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow