Ethics in Night Photography in the Real World

Started Jul 26, 2019 | Discussions thread
1llusive
1llusive Veteran Member • Posts: 3,313
Re: Ethics in Night Photography in the Real World

Alen K wrote:

1llusive wrote:

Alen K wrote:

Here's another photo from Abe of the same location but with only the foreground illuminated artificially. Comparing the two might reveal something about his techniques. One thing for sure: Abe sure does like a blue night sky.

https://www.abeblair.com/gallery.html?gallery=American+West&folio=The%20Art#/59

A clearer image of the original image in discussion: https://www.abeblair.com/gallery.html?gallery=American+West&folio=The+Art&vimeoUserID=&vimeoAlbumID=#/0

Looking through Abe's gallery, he does take nice photos.

The landscape is too dark and noisy to be a daytime shot. It is definitely not a noon exposure. It is possible that it is a twilight exposure.

However the light is most intense in the immediate foreground, and falls off the further back you go. This would be consistent with attempts to light the scene. I am very skeptical he got that much light on the mountains with small LEDs, though. No way this whole scene was lit with LEDs on a drone.

The glow around the mountain top indicates it is likely a blend. My money is on twilight foreground with LED assist + sky astro blend. The LED assist from above would explain the higher concentration of light on the top of the rocks, and darkness underneath, as well as the bright reflection from the snow.

Interesting. To my eyes the lighting is pretty even throughout the scene. And if the LED lights were flown on a drone which was hovering in one place, the shadows would be at different angles for different objects depending on their distance from the drone. If OTOH the drone was not hovering but moving, then there wouldn't be any distinct shadows. Two different opinions. In any case, we'll never know the truth of it.

PS. Here's a daytime shot of the same scene (more or less) for comparison: https://www.abeblair.com/gallery.html?gallery=American+West&folio=The+Art&vimeoUserID=&vimeoAlbumID=#/8

That link is taking me to the same picture in the OP?

I think if a drone were used to light the scene from above, it would have to be flown pretty high in order to not appear in the image. So with enough altitude, I don't think you'd get a lot of light under that rock.

The mountains in the distance are much darker than the immediate area and the snow in front and center is much brighter than the snow on the far cliffs, hinting at local lighting rather than something global like the sun.

If it was lit during the day, the OP did an awful lot of painting in of exposure reduction to make it appear like a night image lit with LEDs. That would seem unlikely, but possible, I guess.

 1llusive's gear list:1llusive's gear list
Nikon Z6 II Sigma 100-400mm F5-6.3 Nikon Z 24-70mm F4 Nikon Z 85mm F1.8 +1 more
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow