Are we kidding ourselves that we are better than we are?

Started Mar 24, 2017 | Discussions thread
Rod McD Veteran Member • Posts: 6,300
Re: Are we kidding ourselves that we are better than we are?

Shockwave wrote:

Rod McD wrote:


I think there's an inappropriate premise in your question. Your premise is that because well known photographers produce some great images, it's somehow inappropriate for members here to make negative observations about their cameras or lenses or the resulting IQ. I disagree. And underlying the first premise is probably the notion that well known professionals produce better work than not-well-known non-professional photographers, which is undoubtedly true at times, but certainly not true all the time. There are people in all walks of professional life, not just professional photography, who are passionate and excellent photographers.

This is principally a gear site. Members discuss, enthuse, question, compare and complain about gear. I hope it comes through in my posts that I'm in fact very positive about Fuji - I've never been happier with a digital camera than my XT1. And I'll extend that to cover all my film SLRs too. Yet in owning it, I've aired grumbles about and comparisons between individual lenses. I've found that I've had to try a good many lenses to reach a kit I'm happy with. That process has inevitably involved a few rejects, and when I've participated in posts about them, I've called it as I've found it in my experience with them. Why not?

I'm not much interested in famous photographers and the whole Fuji-X strategy isn't one that sells to me. I'm not concerned with what gear other people use, famous or not. I am very interested in my own gear choices. I'd predict that every well known photographer has also been through a process of evaluating their gear, rejecting some lenses and settling to keep and use others. They'd be fools not to. Bear in mind too, that as well known identities in the photographic industry they have to be a bit more judicious about airing their rejects than unknowns like us, writing behind avatars.

Photography is good, choice is good, debate is good. And if that debate finds its way into improvement, well that's no bad thing either.....

Regards, Rod

Hi Rod

I'm not saying that people don't have a right to complain, I'm simply arguing that at times they are arguing and complaining about things that are unlikely to impact their photography at their current level. As an example, could you imagine if I complained about the sharpness of the 90 f2?

Agreed.  The resolution of the 90mm is probably not a limitation to anyone.  (I don't actually own one, but acknowledge the tests and owners reports that say it's excellent.)  If you'd suggested the 18mm, I'd have a different view.  (And I do own one).

If we take lenses, I wholeheartedly agree that there is reason to complain, compare and discuss. AF speed as an example can have a fair amount of impact on a photo. The difference between a $300 lens and a $1000 are more often than not visible when you look at photos.

Agree again.  I don't want to start an off topic argument about individual lenses here, but there's  one that I would find limiting in resolution, and perhaps others in AF speed, if I were doing photography that required faster AF.  Most of my subjects either don't or I suffice with the AF speed I've got, but I can easily envisage limitations.

But when it comes to IQ on a sensor, the question I had is what photos people were taking that could not be achieved with the IQ of the XT2. I ask this because I am interested to know what exeeding the capability of the XT2 looks like. Surely if these photographers are exceed the IQ of the XT2, they must be proud to show what they are achieving. It must be incredible. If you are going to complain about the IQ of something, I can only assume you are exceeding it?

I take your expanded point on this, but I interpreted your title to suggest a broader problem in the perceptions of members about their skill levels.

Regards, Rod

-- hide signature --
Fuji XT-2, Fuji X-E2, XF16-55mmF2.8 R LM WR, XF50-140mmF2.8 R LM OIS WR, XF23mmF2 R WR, XF35mmF2 R WR, XF90mmF2 R LM WR, XF60mm F2.4

 Rod McD's gear list:Rod McD's gear list
Canon PowerShot G1 X Olympus Tough TG-4 Fujifilm X-T1 Voigtlander 90mm F3.5 APO-Lanthar SL II Fujifilm XF 35mm F1.4 R +10 more
Post (hide subjects) Posted by
(unknown member)
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow