Analysis of Rishi Sanyals claims on competence and scientific approach for the K-1 AF test

Started Jul 6, 2016 | Discussions thread
joergensmi New Member • Posts: 6
Re: Focus point
12

I did the same  and got the same results.  Phil Harvey was so kind and removed a bug in the textual output, the new Version 10.22 works

@Rishi Sanyal I'm al little upset now
you answered me:

Why is the central AF point on his tibia? Because we didn't use the center AF point. We used a focus point higher up from center.

If checked all 14 Pictures with the Exiftool from phil harvey the result is

your pictures: checked with exiftool 10.21 selected tag AF Point Selected :
IMGP2505.jpeg: Unknown (17); 0
IMGP2506.jpeg: Unknown (17); 0
IMGP2507.jpeg: Unknown (17); 0
IMGP2508.jpeg: Unknown (17); 0
IMGP2509.jpeg: Unknown (17); 0
IMGP2510.jpeg: Unknown (17); 0
IMGP2511.jpeg: Unknown (17); 0
IMGP2512.jpeg: Unknown (17); 0
IMGP2513.jpeg: Unknown (17); 0
IMGP2514.jpeg: Unknown (17); 0
IMGP2515.jpeg: Unknown (17); 0
IMGP2516.jpeg: Unknown (17); 0
IMGP2517.jpeg: Unknown (17); 0
IMGP2518.jpeg: Unknown (17); 0
IMGP2519.jpeg: Unknown (17); 0

My camera middle row from left to right
PK1_4306.JPG: Unknown (13); 0
PK1_4307.JPG: Unknown (14); 0
PK1_4308.JPG: Unknown (15); 0
PK1_4309.JPG: Unknown (16); 0
PK1_4310.JPG: Unknown (17); 0 der ist in der Mitte
PK1_4311.JPG: Unknown (18); 0
PK1_4312.JPG: Unknown (19); 0
PK1_4313.JPG: Unknown (20); 0
PK1_4314.JPG: Unknown (21); 0

It can be clearly seen that the central AF-point has been selected and none of the upper ones.

For me it is clear now that this test fails due to faults by dpreview.

http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/pentax-k-1/6

There has been an update of the exiftools by Phil Harvey The version is 10.22 dated 07.07.2016 12:26 7.226.089 exiftool.exe

The result is now
Focus Mode : AF-C (Focus-priority)
AF Point Selected : Center; Single Point

 joergensmi's gear list:joergensmi's gear list
Ricoh Theta S Pentax K20D Pentax K-5 Pentax K-3 Pentax K-1 +27 more
Post (hide subjects) Posted by
SBS
ET2
ET2
ET2
tko
ET2
ET2
ET2
ET2
ET2
ET2
ET2
ET2
ET2
ET2
ET2
SBS
mxx
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow