DPReview.com is closing April 10th - Find out more

Defective Oly 25mm lens

Started Mar 16, 2016 | Discussions thread
OP Betarover Senior Member • Posts: 1,049
Additional image

Some here have suggested I test this lens by photographing a sheet of paper.  I do landscapes and for me such a test may not be useful.  Consider the geometry.  If a sheet of paper is photographed, the edges, and especially the corners, would be at a slightly greater distance from the lens than the center.  If the lens is engineered to compensate for this small difference in distance when it is focused near, has it been correctly engineered for a flat plane when focused on infinity?  Are the elements within the lens engineered correctly so that they move relative to each other in a way that allows both near and distant images to be sharp, corner to corner?  How can one be sure, except by photographing a distant landscape where all elements are so distant as to be considered at infinity?

Another posting feels I am expecting too much from this lens.  Not so.  The image below shows that my Panasonic 14-45mm zoom is much sharper on the left.  Clearly the Oly 25mm is a defective lens, and I am "pleased" that others have posted here having had the same experience.

The intent of this thread is to alert others that there are bad lenses out there and if edge to edge sharpness is wanted, one should be afraid to buy from a source not giving a satisfaction guarantee.

The images below show the scene, edge to edge across the middle, for my Panasonic 14-45mm and the defective Olympus 25mm.  Each was taken at their sharpest f stop, and both are taken in the Hi-Res mode.

Images taken with Oly EM5 Mk 2, Hi-Res mode.

Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow