Vibration of the A7R shutter compared to D3 and NEX-7 using a seismometer

Started Dec 20, 2013 | Discussions thread
ferrellmc
OP ferrellmc Regular Member • Posts: 106
Re: Yes it was too harsh
1

Horshack wrote:

ferrellmc wrote:

A possible way to test shutter vibration and eliminate the variables would be to take an image with shutter vibration and then compare it to an image without shutter vibration.

To take the image with NO shutter vibration have the camera set up in a dark studio, open the shutter for say 10-20seconds. While the shutter is open fire a strobe(s) off camera to expose the image. This exposure will have no vibration from a shutter release.

Then take an image normally but don't use the strobes their duration is too short, use hot lights or similar.

If everything is the same: lens, focus, ISO, tripod mount, distance etc. the difference in the two images is shutter vibration. Then do the MTF mapper (I've never worked with it).

This could be done at different shutter speeds.

I actually considered this a while back but then realized it's not a valid test because the duration of the flash strobe is only a handful of milliseconds, so its effective shutter speed is very high.

I did the test here: http://beforethecoffee.com/sony-a7r-vibration-comparison-with-nikon-d3-and-sony-nex-7/

I took 30+ sample images, one set with no shutter vibration and one set with normal shutter vibration exposures. Then I compared the results. I used a Nikon 85mm 1.4 and the Sony FE 35mm 2.8.

I am very pleased to find no visible evidence of shutter vibration in images from the A7R when mounted on a good tripod.

Horshack - Could you please elaborate on why shutter speed in the "no shutter vibration" image matters. The idea is to obtain the "purest" form of an image with no vibration. Although I don't think it's relevant, the fast strobe duration works toward that goal. If you thought a fast strobe might bias the image you could always change methods and turn a light on for a split second to expose the image.

-- hide signature --

www.beforethecoffee.com

 ferrellmc's gear list:ferrellmc's gear list
Nikon D2X Nikon D3 Sony Alpha NEX-7 Sony a7R Sony a6000
Post (hide subjects) Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow