B+W Coated Circular Polarizer filter
That does not sound right at all. I would immediately send it back for a replacement. The surface should be perfectly even. Surprised to hear this about a B+W filter.
For what it is worth, I use the 77mm thin Nikon CP (though I shoot Canon) and it is just amazing with no vignetting, even on a 16mm lens.
|Mig-17-1 by bbmach|
from Low Pass
|Rotting Gracefully by Mond|
from Natural Decay
|attic by wgjohnston|
from In the attic, or in the basement!
|Ox Bow Aspen by McFrost|
from cell phones - nature photographs