S2 Toughness

Frantz Dantzler

Leading Member
Messages
521
Reaction score
0
Location
South Bend, IN, US
Over the weekend I'm shooting our son's graduation events in Bloomington, Indiana so I took my S2, a few lenses and the SB 28DX and a couple of MDs. All went well, shot about 300 frames (great battery life!) and at the end of the last party I attended, all was well.

I left the party to go back to the hotel about 1 AM with the S2, the 17/35 and SB28 attached and as I reached the bottom of a poorly-lit outside staircase, I swore there were no steps remaining before the concrete sidewalk...or maybe it was one too many Guinness's, I don't know, but there was another step that didn't get recorded in my brain and before I knew it I was crashing my 6' 7" frame along with my S2 onto the concrete. Many expletives were uttered and then I realized that the SB28 was no longer attached to the S2, with its batteries scattered all around. I never let go of the S2, so it was still attached to my hand.

Bottom line, I now have a very sore knee, a package containing the SB28 being sent to Nikon today, and a perfectly operating S2 with a small chip knocked off the edge of the battery tray, along with some abrasion marks on the tray. The body has no marks and MD works just as good as before.

I know it's not as durable as my D1x, but I am impressed with the ruggedness of the S2 body. The SB 28 hit so hard that that part of the attaching foot was still in the S2's mounting flange, but the flange remained undamaged. Thought some of you concerned with the S2's body strength might want to know and to be careful of unfamiliar stairways at night with celebrating!
--
F. Dantzler
 
Hey Frantz.

I'm certainly glad things worked out as well as they did for you! My camera has proven to be pretty tough also, though I haven't had to test it quite as thuroughly as you. :)

You say that we should watch out for unknown stareways, but I think I'll just watch out for too many Guinness's! ;)

Thanks for sharing,
Paul
Thought some of you concerned with the
S2's body strength might want to know and to be careful of
unfamiliar stairways at night with celebrating!
--
F. Dantzler
--
http://www.okpablo.com
 
...with other "unfortunate" reports, even though yours looked like more risky (for you). Hope that you recover soon and fully.

Definitely, the S2 body (which feels lightweight and flimsy compared to Canon's 1Ds or Nikon D1X), is more durable that what the eyes or hands suggest..

Kind regards, and good luck,

Ferenc
 
I've dropped my SB-80DX flash, I thought I broke it, but it's perfectly fine (I hope). They make this gear more rugged for careless chumps like us!
...with other "unfortunate" reports, even though yours looked like
more risky (for you). Hope that you recover soon and fully.

Definitely, the S2 body (which feels lightweight and flimsy
compared to Canon's 1Ds or Nikon D1X), is more durable that what
the eyes or hands suggest..

Kind regards, and good luck,

Ferenc
--
---------------------------------------------------



Who said you have to be an old fart to shoot Nikon?

inhousephoto inc. digital ? photography ? media
http://www.inhousephoto.com
 
Thanks for the info/testimonial. Glad you're OK and the S2 body too. The body is surprisingly light, but it seems like the buttons/switches on it are sufficiently solid. Good to know, though, that it can stand up to some punishment. I haven't had a mishap with an SLR yet (almost), but even so I do wonder about durability for extended travel, etc. The internals must be pretty well connected to withstand a jolt like that. Take it easy and happy photographing! :)

Cheers,
Greg

--
http://www.photo.net/shared/community-member?user_id=301372
Greg S
 
Wish I could agree with you on this one.

Check out the thread I started when my S2 hit the pavement about two months ago.
http://forums.dpreview.com/forums/read.asp?forum=1020&message=4737407

Regards,

Ayrow
Thanks for the info/testimonial. Glad you're OK and the S2 body
too. The body is surprisingly light, but it seems like the
buttons/switches on it are sufficiently solid. Good to know,
though, that it can stand up to some punishment. I haven't had a
mishap with an SLR yet (almost), but even so I do wonder about
durability for extended travel, etc. The internals must be pretty
well connected to withstand a jolt like that. Take it easy and
happy photographing! :)

Cheers,
Greg

--
http://www.photo.net/shared/community-member?user_id=301372
Greg S
--
http://www.ayrow.com
 
It seems that dropping an S2 with a large heavy zoom lens onto concrete from a distance of 4 ft is beyond its shock capabilities.

Doesn't surprise me, and I sure don't intend to recreate the test, and I wouldn't count on any other camera holding up to the same impact, but it helps calibrate the bar on limits of abuse the camera will take and not take. :)

I will try very hard to watch my step and think before moving too fast... I chase birds/wildlife around alot.

Cheers,
Greg

http://www.photo.net/shared/community-member?user_id=301372
Check out the thread I started when my S2 hit the pavement about
two months ago.
http://forums.dpreview.com/forums/read.asp?forum=1020&message=4737407

Regards,

Ayrow
Thanks for the info/testimonial. Glad you're OK and the S2 body
too. The body is surprisingly light, but it seems like the
buttons/switches on it are sufficiently solid. Good to know,
though, that it can stand up to some punishment. I haven't had a
mishap with an SLR yet (almost), but even so I do wonder about
durability for extended travel, etc. The internals must be pretty
well connected to withstand a jolt like that. Take it easy and
happy photographing! :)

Cheers,
Greg

--
http://www.photo.net/shared/community-member?user_id=301372
Greg S
--
http://www.ayrow.com
--
Greg S
 
By the way, I don't discount 'luck' into my conclusion that the S2 is pretty tough. I shutter (pardon the pun) to think what kind of trouble my Visa would be in if the S2 had taken the brunt of the force with the 17/35, or if it had made its initial contact with the concrete in a less reinforced part of the body. That said, even the D1x could suffer some problems if the 'right' angle or the 'right' force happened at just the wrong place.

Nothing is indestructible in the worse-case scenario. But, the S2, along with a little luck and fewer operator-induced disasters, will serve you well.

The knee is getting better but still sore enough to get me out of chores like picking up countless tree debris and limbs from the yard after weekend wind and storm damage :-)

Sometimes there's a silver lining...
Doesn't surprise me, and I sure don't intend to recreate the test,
and I wouldn't count on any other camera holding up to the same
impact, but it helps calibrate the bar on limits of abuse the
camera will take and not take. :)

I will try very hard to watch my step and think before moving too
fast... I chase birds/wildlife around alot.

Cheers,
Greg

http://www.photo.net/shared/community-member?user_id=301372
Check out the thread I started when my S2 hit the pavement about
two months ago.
http://forums.dpreview.com/forums/read.asp?forum=1020&message=4737407

Regards,

Ayrow
Thanks for the info/testimonial. Glad you're OK and the S2 body
too. The body is surprisingly light, but it seems like the
buttons/switches on it are sufficiently solid. Good to know,
though, that it can stand up to some punishment. I haven't had a
mishap with an SLR yet (almost), but even so I do wonder about
durability for extended travel, etc. The internals must be pretty
well connected to withstand a jolt like that. Take it easy and
happy photographing! :)

Cheers,
Greg

--
http://www.photo.net/shared/community-member?user_id=301372
Greg S
--
http://www.ayrow.com
--
Greg S
--
F. Dantzler
 
...with bodies like 1Ds, D1X, etc... The extra weight of the materials used in these bodies will just work against them, especially in situations like these, were you crashed your equipment right on its weakest spot...

Best regards,

Ferenc
Check out the thread I started when my S2 hit the pavement about
two months ago.
http://forums.dpreview.com/forums/read.asp?forum=1020&message=4737407

Regards,

Ayrow
Thanks for the info/testimonial. Glad you're OK and the S2 body
too. The body is surprisingly light, but it seems like the
buttons/switches on it are sufficiently solid. Good to know,
though, that it can stand up to some punishment. I haven't had a
mishap with an SLR yet (almost), but even so I do wonder about
durability for extended travel, etc. The internals must be pretty
well connected to withstand a jolt like that. Take it easy and
happy photographing! :)

Cheers,
Greg

--
http://www.photo.net/shared/community-member?user_id=301372
Greg S
--
http://www.ayrow.com
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top