Considering selling my SEL 16 and adaptors and replacing with the Nikon 1 6.7-13 VR...

Started Jan 30, 2013 | Discussions thread
OP Herts_JoaTMoN Contributing Member • Posts: 773
Re: Considering selling my SEL 16 and adaptors and replacing with the Nikon 1 6.7-13 VR...

seachicken2000 wrote:

I reckon the 10-18mm lens has a lot going for it.

Converting the Nikon and Sony lenses to FF equivalent to compare.

Nikon: 18-35mm f/9.5-15; Sony: 15-28mm f/6

Personally I quite like the wider end of the range but you may have other ideas :-).

The Nikon lens includes the 28-35mm range which you might appreciate but at f/15 equiv. you are in the zone where diffraction is starting to have an impact. This range would be covered by your NEX standard zoom in any case. The 10-18mm lens seems to be a superb lens, and for landscapes with a lot of detail the Nikon combination will be no match.

On the other hand, you could just pick up the Nikon without needing to faff around changing lenses.

-- hide signature --

"The only thing that gets in the way of a really good photograph, is the camera"
Norman Parkinson

I like normal primes and slightly wide angles mostly which is why the 35mm is top of my wishlist at the moment. To me ultra wide is a nice to have rather than a necessity which is what has lead me to the 6.7-13. At £600 or what ever the 10-18 costs, I cant justify the expendature to myself. We are getting into the 24mm teritory and I already ruled that out due to cost despite the fact that its my favoured focal length on an APSC sensor. Photography is just a hobby for me.

The equivalent f stops it something that concerns me, but having shot with the 30-110 on that system, im happy to shoot with the lens wide open as it seems that is were its at its best. I would do the same with the wide angle zoom. For the type of things I would be shooting with it I wouldnt need shallow depth of field with it anyway. I have no intention of using it in low light, the VR is just a bonus for me as Ill be trying to keep the ISO at 400 or above to landscape type shots.

-- hide signature --

Ben Williams - UK
NEX 5N / E 18-55. E 16. UWA. Fisheye. Sigma 19. / Minolta MC 50 1.4. Tamron 90 2.5 Macro. Vivitar 100 3.5 Macro. Soligor 135 2.8 / Raynox DCR-250.
Nikon V1 / N1 10-30. N1 30-110.
Sony TX10.
Selling: Tamron 18-200 NEX (Sold)
Shopping list: NEX6 + 16-50 (replace 5N + 18-55) (if £600). SEL3518 (if £300). N1 6.7-13 (if £300). Pani wide angle converter GCW1 (if £90). SEL20 (if better than Sigma 19).
Wish list: Fast E mount 24-28 that wont break the bank. Fast Nikon 1 telephoto lens.

 Herts_JoaTMoN's gear list:Herts_JoaTMoN's gear list
Sony Alpha NEX-6 Sony E 35mm F1.8 OSS Sony E 20mm F2.8 Adobe Photoshop Lightroom 4
Post (hide subjects) Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow