G15- Initial Thoughts

Started Oct 16, 2012 | Discussions thread
Flat view
cgarrard Forum Pro • Posts: 15,555
G15- Initial Thoughts

Like many, I dismissed the G15 off the bat because of a lack of articulated screen and/or an improved optical finder (like the X10 has). However, after some thought and cooling off, I began to think in a different way about the G15.

One golden rule I follow is never to dismiss or get overly excited about a camera until you have one in your hand. In the past I've written about cameras I love having initially written them off, and vice versa- and in the end ended up with an entirely different impression and conclusion about the product. So...

I started thinking about the bigger screen, the clean back panel layout, and simplified overall handling vs the G12. And I thought, I've absolutely loved many cameras with a fixed screen, the G15 should be no different. Then, I remembered that I've used the optical finder in plenty of G-Series cameras in the past and been plenty happy with it on those rare occassions. Sure, I'd like a bigger brighter finder like the X10 and do think Canon should have improved on it, however it's not a deal breaker for me in real life.

After I came to terms with those two conclusions emotionally, I then started looking at the benefits of the new items. The lens is exciting, the new sensor and processing better, about a 2 stop advantage through the entire focal range of the G12 when both are factored together and added up- and that realy got me thinking that I just might like the G15 quite a bit.

Now I'm not in the camp of big or small sensors solely, I think there plenty of advantages of larger and smaller sensor cameras and I appreciate them for those advantages- especially when the package is so good around the sensor. The G1X had great IQ but I felt the design overall was unbalanced, it was heavy and clunky to me for a camera of this type, its macro and auto focus performance was sub par to the G12. I preferred the G12 overall as a balanced product in the end to the G1X.

The G15 is also 2 ounces lighter than the G12, and a tad slimmer. When talking cameras this small thats a noticeable difference for a daily shooter. Add that to the cleaner overall exterior and better positioned EV dial, and I actually started getting excited a bit. In retrospect, I think its easy to get caught up in community talk - especially negative talk- and dismiss products too easily. No camera has ever been perfect by my standards, but the G series has always been a very consistently pleasing product, dare I say favorite of mine from Canon overall.

So that said, I requested a review unit to evaluate from Canon and its on the way. In the end I think this post serves as a sort of premonition that I may end up being surprised by the G15 when I use it in hand, vs. judging it solely on specification criteria alone.

Guess we'll find out tomorrow when I get it.




 cgarrard's gear list:cgarrard's gear list
Panasonic Lumix DMC-G6
Canon PowerShot G12 Canon PowerShot G15 Fujifilm X10
If you believe there are incorrect tags, please send us this post using our feedback form.
Flat view
Post (hide subjects) Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow