LumoLabs: Pentax K-5 low light focus study is published

Started Feb 23, 2011 | Discussions thread
moving_comfort Veteran Member • Posts: 8,228
Re: I assume you are redoing some tests with 1.03 (n)


FYI, 1.03 tests are in.

-- hide signature --




Basically, I find no significant difference between firmware versions 1.02 and 1.03 when using my testing scenarios. This means that there is no significant improvement if:

The background is white
The target has high contrast
The AF assist light is disabled

Under the above circumstances, the K-5 auto focus starts to lock focus in a false front focus position at tungsten light levels below 0 EV for a fast lens (like f/1.8) or below about 2-4 EV for slower lenses. This did not change at all with release 1.03. Note that the above light level values would read 2-3 steps higher with a target like a Caucasian skin (18% gray).

Moreover, I found that at low enough light levels, the 1.03 firmware seems to rely more than 1.02 on color information outside the direct selected AF spot. With a uniform color distribution, this can lead to somewhat improved results in the vicinity of the focus shift transition. OTOH, the focus system is more easily fooled by features with a singular color. Overall, the advantages may dominate and the effect is small anyway. Version 1.03 still doesn't seem to make use of white balance information, either manually or automatic.

If I believe that Pentax improved the low light focus situation for many users of the 1.03 firmware, then the progress must be bound to any of the following:

AF assist light engages more actively (not tested by myself).
Focus improved in the presence of dark backgrounds (not tested by myself).
Focus improved with low contrast or dim focus features (not tested by myself).

As I don't have a version 1.02 K-5 anymore, I cannot find it out. But any progress brought by the 1.03 firmware upgrade is limited rather than universal.

As much as I applaud Pentax to having addressed the problem, as much I am a bit disappointed they didn't dig deep enough to address the root problem: that the K-5 AF subsystem locks focus even in a situation where the colorimetric sensor(s) fails to determine the light color. It simply shouldn't lock focus at all then. Or ask for user assistance like a priming shot. The light-sensitive AF system of the K-5 has too strong a color dependency to autofocus if the color of the focus feature remains unknown.

A better workaround than 1.03 in firmware is feasible and should stay on Pentax' agenda.

Please, read the full paper linked above if you have further questions and come back here to leave comments or questions. General comments about the issue should still go to the general (earlier) article while firmware release 1.03 comments should go here. Thank You.

 moving_comfort's gear list:moving_comfort's gear list
Pentax K20D Nikon D800 Nikon AF-S DX Nikkor 35mm F1.8G Nikon AF-S Nikkor 300mm f/4D ED-IF Nikon AF Nikkor 20mm f/2.8D +10 more
Post (hide subjects) Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow