Nikkor AF-D 35 f/2 or AF-S 35 f/1.8 or Tokina 35 f/2.8 macro ???

Started May 7, 2010 | Discussions thread
Flat view
arrakis99 Regular Member • Posts: 275
Nikkor AF-D 35 f/2 or AF-S 35 f/1.8 or Tokina 35 f/2.8 macro ???

I really connot set up my mind... Looking for a 35 all-around lens for my D90

I own the 35 f/2 D Nikkor. But I use it only stopped down to 2.8 / 4 because corner softness at widest aperture...

I really like this lens but I've read very positive opinions about the Tokina 35 / 2.8 Macro especially for the optical qualities, the good bokeh and macro feature

I'm looking for a all around lens with good CLOSE UP abilities... WITH A GOOD BOKEH

So the Tokina really seems better than 35 F/2 D... What do you think ?

I Know... there is also the AF-S 35 f/1.8 BUT while I've read stellar reviews about it what I don't like is its reproduction ratio and minumum focus distance ... so this one it seems to me not so good for close up photography... is it true ?

In the end I'm looking for:
1. Sharpness
2. Close-up abilities (macro feature of the tokina is a strong add-on here)
3. Quality of the bokeh

Please can you guide me ?

Thanks a lot

-- hide signature --

Giulio Acerbi
Cameras: Nikon D90 - Panasonic LX3
Prime lenses: Nik. 35mm f/2 D - Nik. 50mm f/1.8 D
Zoom lenses: Nik. 16-85 VR - Nik 55-200 VR
Flashes: Nikon SB-400

Flat view
Post (hide subjects) Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow