Have a K-7, getting Nikon D40...

Started Apr 16, 2010 | Discussions thread
Flat view
Alek79 Regular Member • Posts: 434
Have a K-7, getting Nikon D40...

My recent trip to Italy revealed shortcomings of my travel setup that currently consists of K-7 + 16-45 + FA 20mm/2.8 + occasionaly 50-200. I also recently acquired an excellent Tamron 28-75/2.8 but will probably limit it to portraits as it's not wide-enough to be of universal use.

The 16-45, as much as I like it is, a little short and on K-7 started showing its corner weakness which was not apparent on my previous K100D.
I definitely need a true wide-angle.
The built-in flash is underpowered for fill-in purpose in daylight conditions.

I also thought about getting a compact body for my girlfriend since many a time we would "fight" over the camera ot get "that" shot.

Looking at possible options I came to this: Get a Nikon D40 (250-300$ 2nd hand) + Sigma 10-20 (450$ 2nd hand) and/or Nikkor 16-85VR (500$ 2nd h.) + SB-400 flashgun (130$) + Nikkor 35/1.8 (250$).
Prices are in 1 Swiss Franc being approx. 1 USD.

In my idea to get a Nikon these are the deciding factors:

Excellent, light, tilt-head SB-400 portable flashgun for mere 130$ which can be left on camera anytime vs. pentax AF200: heavier, bigger, weaker and no tilt-head.

Very good 16-85VR not quite matched by anything in Pentax lineup. Please see the cost comparison below.

Nikkor 30/1.8 - no Pentax equivalent. And finally D40 - beautifuly compact, quiet shutter, 1/500 (!) flash sync speed and my beloved 6MP sensor. Do you really need more for travel?

Here's the price comparison here in Switzerland, prices are for factory new equipment:

N 16-85: 650$
P 17-40: 700$
P 16-50: 1170$

N 35/1.8: 255$
P 35/2.8: 640$

N 50/1.4 USM: 450$
P 55/1.4 SDM: 800$

N 70-300VR: 560$
P 55-300 : 430$

N SB-400: 130$
P AF200FG: 200$

Remember, we're talking a travel setup here. We all know Pentax has great primes that are effectively stabilized. I love my FA20, M28/3.5, K35/3.5, M50/1.7 and M85/2.

These are great lenses and a reason to keep my K-7 but Nikon seems to be much ahead in terms of affordable, versatile kit for no frills holiday shooting.

Tell me what you think, any suggestions, alternatives?



Flat view
Post (hide subjects) Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow