Call for DNG support from camera manufacturers Locked

Started Nov 8, 2008 | Discussions thread
This thread is locked.
OP ted w dillard Regular Member • Posts: 194
Re: Call for DNG support from camera manufacturers

Ted, it took a long time but I read through this entire thread - phew!

no way, really?


I shoot NEF and until mid year this year, used LR and converted all
my files to dng upon import, then 'fiddled' with them so to speak;
this I was happy with. Then I bought another Nikon camera and with
it came NX1.3 and what a difference to the files I've found. Within
NX, I've since upgraded to NX2, even shooting NEF files you retain
all the secret sauce Nikon puts into their camera processing engine
and for me, the files a streets ahead of the files I squirted into LR.

Since the release of LRv2 I haven't as yet upgraded this software and
each day I use LR less and less but do recognise that it appears the
DNG format only gets updated to include new generation cameras rather
a whole new DNG format at each iteration. For this I think Adobe,
love'em or hate'em, is doing a sterling job and should be applauded.

Now, I've signed your petition for I do believe that as consumers we
should be offered the most choice whether that's DNG, NEF in my
case/TIFF or jpeg. My concern though is this...moving to a DNG
shooting format right now would mean I lose the Nikon camera
settings, which now I've discovered them and they work for me, I'm
loathed to change.

Further, NX2 currently is unable to read a DNG file so every DNG file
I possess I still have to use LR to view it which is a pain in the
rear end.

Yeah, the hope is that if the camera makers take the next step, the evolution of the processing will tend to smooth out... getting, as one poster here said, less "amateurish". As Jeff has said, we've been in the Wild West here, it's time to get civilized.

Anyway, good luck and I for one hope that the OEMs listen and take


Ted Dillard

Smart Object Evangelist and digital photo support-

Join the Shoot RAW Smart! forum on Yahoo - dedicated to the Smart Object RAW workflow.

Post (hide subjects) Posted by
(unknown member)
(unknown member)
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow