Nikon D3 vs Canon 5D - test shots

Started Apr 5, 2008 | Discussions thread
greg_thurtle_uk
greg_thurtle_uk Contributing Member • Posts: 679
Re: Nikon D3 vs Canon 5D - test shots

That's my findings too - i even found the canon 24-70 was slightly sharper than the new nikkor 24-70 wide open.

I did find the D3 better at high ISO (3200/6400) which is my primary use for it during weddings.

As an aside why do people always draw the curtains during the ceremony, but, only just before - so that when i check out the lighting initially it looks great then when i arrive just before the bride it's gone to pot?

Greg

jimbobuk wrote:

A few weeks ago i had chance to try and test out my new D3 against
the 5D. At the time i was trying out using Capture One 4, but hit a
snag when one file just converted very very softly for the D3 (iso
12800, yet 25600 was fine).. I then discovered how great Capture NX
was with the same images, and left it there.

I'm currently testing Aperture 2.1 and have used this to convert both
sets of raw files out of the 5D and the D3... the settings are all at
the defaults, so there is more and less NR happening, and seemingly
more and less sharpening.

This test is by no means thorough or accurate but it may be helpful
to some. The details are

Canon 5D
Canon 50mm f1.8 @ f9
Tripod
Mirror lock up, self timer

Nikon D3
Nikon 50mm f1.4 @ f9
Tripod
Mirror lock up, annoyingly no self timer support so i had to leave
each shot 30 seconds for the shot to auto take which sometimes meant
light had changed in that 30 second window.

Also the D3 is a different size to the 5D so i had to adjust the
tripod center column to try and align the photos.. this along with
perhaps differences in the exact FOV of the lenses means that the two
shots are never quite perfectly equivelant.

They are close though, and what can be seen is that seemingly the 5D
is sharper at lower isos, though there isn't a lot in it. Also the 5D
in this scene scales up well through the ISOs.. detail doesn't seem
to suffer much at all, its only in the shadows where the noise
becomes noticably worse than the D3.. and also the details do start
to go by ISO 3200.

Slightly frustrating that the D3 doesn't kill the cheaper canon, but
then again what were you to expect with them being similar megapixel,
and pixel pitch sensors.

Anyways here's the images

http://www.flickr.com/photos/jimbobuk/sets/72157604391617771/

I do remember when shooting this how much more i preferred the feel
of the D3 in my hand.. so quick to get used to nikon after using
Canon for a few years.. oh and the 5D does feel a bit like a toy next
to it.. though part of that is thanks to its extremely light weight.

Hope the shots are helpful to someone.

-- hide signature --

email greg at thurtlepower dot com
Based in Hampshire/Dorset

Post (hide subjects) Posted by
PG
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow