D300 versus 20D continued analysis

Started Dec 5, 2007 | Discussions thread
natureman Veteran Member • Posts: 3,979
Re: D300 versus 20D continued analysis

No, the best way to do this is as Arash did it. Compare both cameras at their megapixel limits.

The 20D is not a 12mp camera and upsizing an image from it would put it at an unreasonable disadvantage. If someone used your illogic, I suppose it would also be fair to upsize an image from a $20 Walmart camera to 12mp, so that it could be compared to an image from a D300?

Something to keep in mind about reviews around the internet: Many or all of those sites take in advertising money from camera companies, just like this site does. The same cannot be said for Arash's comparison here. Sure, it's possible that he faked the pictures. Sure, it's possible that he has a faulty camera and should have it checked by Nikon service. Sure, he may have gotten a really good copy of a 20D. But, at least his comparison is available for us all to see and disect. He is also answering questions generously.

Some of you have posted here that your D300 tests or comparisons have shown Arash's to be flawed. Funny thing is, none of you have posted the visual results from your tests/comparisons, with all the relevant data, but you expect us to just take your word for it? Who really are the ones chasing ghosts?

Arash has shown what he found. The doubters are just saying what they found. Show us the results of your tests/comparisons, and make sure they are credible tests/comparisons. Credible evidence means something. Hearsay means little or nothing.

kevm14 wrote:

natureman wrote:

Arash is comparing 100% crops. That means he's showing both cameras
at their limits. This is NOT unfair to the Nikon D300. If the D300
images have to be downsized to 8mp to look as good as the 20D
pictures, then the D300 is, in reality, an 8mp camera.

The best way to do this is to upsize the smaller images to match the
larger ones. In other words, upsize the 20D shots to 12MP. It
becomes a lot easier to check for detail, noise, etc.

Post (hide subjects) Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow