Sigma 18-50mmf2.8 or Pentax 16-45mm to buy???

Started Feb 4, 2005 | Discussions thread
Howard Contributing Member • Posts: 705
Re: wide angle Pentx 16-45;18-55 Sigma 18-50


I use the *istD and the 16-45DA for commercial ship interior and exterior photography. I would be lost without the flexibility of this lens when doing this work. The metering tends to be 1/2 stop under exposed but I shoot Raw all the time and adjust afterwards with Photoshop CS. Based on your needs, in my book, this lens will be very worthwhile.

Cruise and Ferry Information

Marc Delghust wrote:
I am planning to buy a D-slr, and wide-angles are an important
issue for me as I mostly tend towards architecture and landscape
So I was wondering how they compare, and also on distorion
(probably mostly on barrel distorion at wide-angle).
Are their other issues besides the flash-problem.

distortion, vignetting or sharpness (and eventually price-worthy)?
Pentax 16-45 ; 18-55 (standard kit lens)
Sigma 18-50

hugnut wrote:
I like to point out that the 16-45 is limited when using the
internal flash from about 16-28, the extened barrel will get in the
way and leave a shadow in your picture, I also noticed on mine that
most of the pictures were a stop or two darker then compared to my
Pentax primes and Sigma 18-50. I sold mine a while ago...but
wouln't mind having one back some day for the sharpness and I would
learn to deal or compensate with the underexposure tendency. Last
fall when I was looking to upgrade my Sigma 18-50 I was torn
between getting aonther 16-45(despite it's issues) or another
Penatx zoom model...I eventually went with a couple primes instead
and replced the Sigma with the Pentax 18-55.

ido wrote:

CSLee wrote:

i m planing to buy one of these lens but don't know which one is
better in term of performance (focusing
speed/accurate,sharpeness,contrast and etc.).can anyone please help
me ,i m lose ?.

my opinion is that Pentax 16-45 the best in range 15 to 50 despite
its a bit slower

 Howard's gear list:Howard's gear list
Canon EOS 6D Canon EF 50mm f/1.4 USM Canon EF 85mm f/1.8 USM Canon Extender EF 1.4x II Canon EF 70-200mm F4L IS USM +4 more
Post (hide subjects) Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow