Issue with original 5D (weird spots in image) pls help!

tesin

Member
Messages
36
Reaction score
0
Location
CZ
Hello,

I would need advice what this issue could be.
Camera used: 5D
Lens used: Sigma 50mm at f 1.4
ISO: 400

If you notice - there is on the image, some weird red spots I have never seen before. To me it looks like focusing confirmation box showed in the pictures.

It did only that very day - now it is ok. But being afraid to show up during the wedding or something important.

Any suggestions?





thank you for your advice
--
Benjamin
 
Notice how the orange dots you're talking about strangely have the same shape as the lights in the background. There's the source of your problem, reflected light and it causing ghosting. Change your position or use a lens hood.

That's why chimping is a good thing at times.
--
http://www.kwanonians.com
 
I would guess you are using a lens filter. either don't use it in situations with dim light with bright sources, or use a better one.

probably better to just not use the filter.
 
thank you for your experience

I have never occurred with this very thing - and it looked to me as focusing points reflecting in the image, so I got worried.

yes, Im actually using quite cheap filter for this lens.

thank you, glad my camera is working fine :D
--
Benjamin
 
Only use multi-coated filters. In the US 2filters is a good source.
The B+W multi-icoated filter has the "MC" designation.
 
I have never used filters as for the protection - but I got this filter for free along with purchasing this lens...so I have tried. I see no point of buying expensive ones as well...so I guess I will put it aside and use it without filter.

Thank you for advices
--
Benjamin
 
I am a huge supporter of putting a high quality UV on the end of all my lenses. The last thing you want is for it to take even a little bump on the lens element. Imagine it bumping onto the edge of a table slightly and gashing part of the coating off the lens, you will NOT be happy with the repair costs, trust me. Then let's talk about degradation in image quality with a lens flaw like that, self explanitory.

If you get a good quality filter, you will not see any appreciable loss in IQ of your pictures. I use Hoya Super Multi-Coated filters. If I have $1000s or more invested in each lens, it's not gonna kill me to put on a $50 filter to protect it.

Besides, cleaning the lens elements constantly will wear the coating off the lens too.

--
A picture is no longer worth a 1000 words, it's worth about 25MB.
 
Lamps Reflection on front surface of the lens and reflected back by the inner surface of the filter.

The Candle Light formation is exactly the same as the red dots formation.
Hello,

I would need advice what this issue could be.
Camera used: 5D
Lens used: Sigma 50mm at f 1.4
ISO: 400

If you notice - there is on the image, some weird red spots I have never seen before. To me it looks like focusing confirmation box showed in the pictures.

It did only that very day - now it is ok. But being afraid to show up during the wedding or something important.

Any suggestions?





thank you for your advice
--
Benjamin
 
I am a huge supporter of putting a high quality UV on the end of all my lenses. The last thing you want is for it to take even a little bump on the lens element.
Why? Apart from lenses like Canon's 50/1.4 that has AF so brittle it actually breaks from even a moderate thump to the front element, where is the danger? Particularly if you are using your lens hood as you always should?
Imagine it bumping onto the edge of a table slightly and gashing part of the coating off the lens, you will NOT be happy with the repair costs, trust me. Then let's talk about degradation in image quality with a lens flaw like that, self explanitory.
How is that self-explanatory? I'm ready to put a bet that it would be absolutely impossible to see any degradation because a small part of coating has been chipped from the front of a lens. And, again, with the proper Canon lens hood, your scenario is highly unlikely for most lenses.

When I bought my 5D in 2005, I bought filters for all my lenses but didn't use them with lens hoods. Later, after first real flare issues, I removed the UV filters one by one and started using lens hoods instead. Lens hoods are for protection, and unlike filters they actually improve IQ. And, although I have zero front element scratches, I know that a few of them (would I be unlucky enough to get some) would have no effect whatsoever on IQ. Heck, even a cracked lens can be used! (See link below.)
http://www.lensrentals.com/news/2008.10.30/front-element-scratches
If you get a good quality filter, you will not see any appreciable loss in IQ of your pictures.
Except when you do. There are multiple documented cases where e.g. AF, IQ and strangely also bokeh of the 100-400 has been affected at the long end even when the highest quality filters have been used. Sometimes the differences have been dramatic.
I use Hoya Super Multi-Coated filters. If I have $1000s or more invested in each lens, it's not gonna kill me to put on a $50 filter to protect it.
It's not a question of cost, but of IQ and sense.m Why buy someting that at best doesn't degrade IQ much?
Besides, cleaning the lens elements constantly will wear the coating off the lens too.
Why would you clean the lens elements constantly? A small number of dust specks won't affect IQ one iota. I clean my front elements less often than once in a year and even then only when they have about half a gazillion dust specks on them. There has never been any appreciable before-after difference.

I still have the multicoated UV filters that I bought for my lenses. However, these days I only use them if I know I'm going to shoot in rain, dust, etc. Which happens only twice or thrice a year.

Kind regards,
  • Henrik
--
And if a million more agree there ain't no great society
My obligatory gallery: http://www.iki.fi/leopold/Photo/Galleria/
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top