Filters after the fact: Digital split ND filters versus HDR
A common dilemma when photographing landscapes is that some portions of the scene are far brighter than others. A prime example of this, shown below, is when photographing scenes containing both sky and reflection. The reflection is often several stops darker than the primary subject and of course, the sky.
|This is how the scene is rendered with no density adjustment. The sky is too bright while the geyser is too dark.|
The traditional in-camera solution is to use a split neutral density (ND) filter to balance the overall exposure. A split filter works by reducing the amount of light that reaches one area of the lens. Split ND filters have long been mainstays in the gear bags of landscape photographers. They come in various strengths (able to reduce exposure by 1, 2, 3 or more stops) and are available with transition areas (between reduced and normal brightness) that can either be gradual or abrupt. Yet there are many situations in which they are not ideal.
The most obvious is when the boundary between the area in the scene you wish to darken and the area you wish to leave unaltered is not a straight line, as in the picture of the geyser above. Split ND filters typically change density across half of the filter. Trying to compensate for a V-shape area as might happen if photographing between mountains, or any other non-linear shape will not be as successful. In such cases it’s better to apply a solution in the digital darkroom.
There are several digital solutions that address these issues. Programs such as Nik Software’s Color Efex Pro 4.0, Adobe Camera Raw (ACR), Lightroom and Aperture all have tools that can simulate the effects of a split ND filter, with the great advantage that the density adjustment can be applied to multiple and non-contiguous areas of the image. Alternately, using HDR (high dynamic range) software such as Photomatix or Nik Software’s HDR Efex Pro are options as well.
Whichever program you use, the first step is to look at the histogram of the best-exposed version of the image. The histogram for the image at the top of this article shows clipping in the highlights (notice the spike at the far right of the histogram). An ideal solution would be to combine two bracketed exposures (one containing full highlight data and one with rich shadow detail) into a single image.
|The histogram shows clipping in the highlights.|
If you are working with a Raw file, however, it’s possible that you may be able to reveal more detail in the highlights and/or the shadows from just a single exposure. Unlike 8-bit camera-generated JPEGs, Raw files, with their higher bit depth contain greater headroom. To determine the potential for your file, open it in a Raw converter of your choice. Adjust the overall exposure slider and check the histogram to see how much detail you can pull back in the highlights, even if the rest of the image becomes quite dark. Similarly, adjust the slider in the other direction to check for detail in the shadows.
In our image, decreasing the exposure by 2/3 of a stop regains the highlight detail, as shown below. Even better, in this particular image, I don’t lose detail in the shadows even though the overall image becomes too dark. Therefore I can expect that both single image HDR Toning and digital split ND filters will give good results. In addition, I've applied some fill light to create the best starting place for some of the other techniques.
|With a Raw file, we have brought out highlight detail that appeared to be lost, by applying an exposure value of -.65. Notice the histogram now tapers off at the highlight end.|
If you still see a spike at either edge of the histogram, then these techniques are not going to be able to restore full detail in the highlights and/or shadows - although the resulting image may still be quite pleasing. While our eyes more easily accept some loss of detail in the shadows, if there is significant clipping, the better approach would be to combine two or more exposures of the image into a single file, which I discuss a bit further on.
Digital Graduated ND filters
I tend to use the Graduated Neutral Density filter in Nik’s Color Efex Pro 4 plug-in, because it’s easy to use, you can customize the shape of the filter for each image and it's compatible with Photoshop, Lightroom and Aperture. Initially I set the Upper and Lower Tonality sliders to extreme positions (they determine how far to lighten or darken each section of the image) so that I can accurately place the Vertical Shift (specifies where the transition between upper section changes and lower section changes occurs) as well as the Rotation and Blend sliders which determine the angle for the transition and how wide a transition area there is between the upper and lower effects, respectively.
Then I adjust the Upper and Lower Tonality sliders to give a visually pleasing result. If I need to remove the effect from an area, such as the top of geyser in this image, I add a minus Control Point. Control Points are used in all Nik products to enable you to specify areas to apply, partially apply or disable the current settings. Control points employ auto masking which avoids you having to make time-consuming selections or create and edit layer masks.
You still have the option to tweak the final results using either the program in which Color Efex has been installed or a separate editing program such as Nik Software’s Viveza. Below I used Viveza to add an adjustment to lighten the geyser further.
Photoshop's ACR, Aperture and Lightroom provide adjustment brushes which allow you to simulate a graduated split ND filter with great flexibility. In these programs you create a brush to apply an exposure/brightness change to an area that you define by painting over the image. These programs use auto-masking as well. I do recommend zooming in to 100% magnification after applying the brushes to be certain the masks are accurate. If they are not you can easily modify them.
An advantage of the adjustment brushes in ACR and Lightroom is that you can have a single brush apply multiple changes, so that in addition to exposure changes, it can simultaneously apply clarity or saturation changes, etc. With adjustment brushes you can easily and accurately customize the area that’s affected as you paint with the brush.
In ACR and Lightroom you can also opt to use the gradient tool with the Exposure slider to emulate a split ND filter. Unfortunately you run into the same difficulties and limitations as with a split ND filter used while taking the image; namely that the transition area must be a straight line. It can be a little awkward to then try to add or remove the effect from an area that projects beyond that line. For example in the image above, the geyser would become even darker and would have to be readjusted using the Adjustment Brush. Of course the advantage of this approach is that the changes are made to the raw file itself rather than a converted file
- Realistic and natural looking results.
- Easy to do using several popular software programs.
- May require more steps to achieve final desired appearance.
- May have to check image at high magnification in some programs to ensure transition area is accurate and that any auto masked areas are correct.
An alternative solution is to use single-image HDR toning. To use any of the HDR programs, it’s best to begin with a Raw file or at least a 16-bit TIFF file. Most HDR software programs include options to modify the overall exposure, contrast and color saturation in addition to expanding the tonal range within the image. Some offer considerable choices in both the style of the algorithms as well as the strength of the effects.
Depending on the settings you choose, the results may be fairly realistic or quite surreal. It’s easy to get a bit carried away in some of the HDR programs and in most cases the image will be more dramatic, but potentially less natural looking.
I favor Nik Software’s HDR Efex Pro because of the unusually large number of choices in algorithms the program uses as well as a large selection of presets that serve as good starting points. The image below shows my original Raw file processed in Nik software’s HDR Efex Pro with settings chosen to keep the image somewhat realistic. You can see, however, that this result is different than the split ND version I created earlier, with increased image detail at the highlight and shadow ends and more saturated colors.
|The original image processed in Nik software’s HDR Efex Pro with settings chosen to keep the image close to realistic.|
If the initial histogram indicated significant clipping in your image file and you have several files of the exact same scene photographed at different exposures, combining them in the HDR program of your choice may create the best results. For the best results you want at least three separate image files, each captured at a different exposure. One file should contain no clipping in the shadow areas (even if this means the highlights are blown out) and another file should contain no clipping in the highlights (even though the rest of the image may be too dark) and one or more exposures in-between these two extremes.
|This image was created by combining three separate exposures in Photomatix Pro.|
A more tedious method of achieving a similar effect in Photoshop is to use the command File >Scripts > Load Files into Stack command to create a single image with each exposure as a separate layer. Then you can use layer masks to reveal the best parts of each file. This approach was more common before the arrival of effective HDR tools. Yet in cases where the tonal variation is clustered together in an area such as an overly bright sky or a distractingly dark subject, this approach is still effective and can lead to more realistic results.*
- After adjusting the sliders in a single interface, the image may not need any further work, particularly with programs such as Photomatix and HDR Efex Pro.
- Dramatic results are easy to create.
- Final image may not look as natural as desired unless restraint is used.
Both digital graduated neutral density filters and single image HDR toning, as well as multi image HDR processing can effectively even out the exposure within images that have areas that are far too light or too dark. They are the solutions of choice when the boundaries between the light and dark areas are not a simple straight line. HDR Toning is particularly well suited to images where the light and dark areas may be more scattered throughout the image, whereas digital split ND filters are preferable when seeking the most realistic results and there are discrete large areas of the image that are too light and/or too dark. The techniques discussed here work best when full highlight and shadow detail have been captured by the camera sensor in Raw format.
For full disclosure, I am a member of Nik Software’s Team Nik. However I write about the products I use and use those that are the easiest and yield the highest quality results for me. Of course you may prefer other software to achieve similar results.
*For more details on this see Photoshop CS5 for Nature Photographers; A Workshop in a Book. (Anon & Anon)
Oct 2, 2014
Sep 28, 2014
Sep 27, 2014
Sep 26, 2014
|It's good to be at home by Nightcrawler12|
from Best photo of the week...
|Tiny tree by Kaappo|
The Olympus 17mm F1.2 promises to open up new possibilities for Micro Four Thirds shooters seeking razor-thin depth-of-field and smooth, 'feathered' bokeh. Take a peek at our extensive sample gallery.
Are you a speed freak? Hungry to photograph anything that goes 'zoom'? Or perhaps you just want to get Sports Illustrated-level shots of your child's soccer game. Keep reading to find out which cameras we think are best for sports and action shooting.
Still yearning for an Aperture replacement? Here's a quick overview of RAW Power, a Raw image editor for iOS that pairs with the Mac application introduced in 2016. Take a look at some of its capabilities.
Video features have become an important factor to many photographers when choosing a new camera. Read on to find out which cameras we think are best for the videophile.
Tech lover Albert Lee was one of the first to pre-order the intriguing 16-camera module Light L16. Two months in, here's what he has to say about using this not-so-little computational camera.
The public art installation featured blurred portraits, ostensibly captured by the artist under that same underpass... except they weren't. They were actually portraits of comedians, pulled from the 2015 Edinburgh Fringe Festival program.
Edelkrone has upgraded its SliderOne with a SliderOne Pro and introduced a new generation of Wing and Wing Pro models, all while simultaneously improving the app that controls its entirely lineup.
People have waiting a long time for the Canon 85mm F1.4L IS lens, but how does it compare to Canon's 85mm F1.2L and Sigma's 85mm F1.4 Art? Phillip Pettit of Lensrentals took all three lenses for a spin to find out.
Affinity Photo for iPad, one of the first full-featured Raw editors designed specifically for tablet use, has been named Apple's Best iPad App of 2017. And what's more, it's currently 50% off!
VSCO Messages allows VSCO X subscribers and free users alike to share text, images, photo editing 'recipes', VSCO journal entries and more.
Flickr has revealed their top 25 photos of 2017, and there are some truly stunning shots in the mix.
Testing of the Canon G1 X Mark III is well underway, inside of the studio and out. We've just added it to our test scene comparison tool, where you can take a look at its performance side-by-side against peers like the Sony Cyber-shot RX100 V.
Whether it's a trip to the beach for some snorkeling or scrambling up a 10,000 ft volcano, the Olympus Tough TG-5 proved to be a great travel companion for Jeff. That's why it's his 2017 Gear of the Year.
Last year, the DJI Mavic Pro and the Phantom 4 Professional took top honors in our end of year buying guide. Read on to find out who it this year for beginners, consumers, prosumers, and professionals at a price tag less than $2,000.
Meyer Optik Goerlitz is resurrecting yet another classic lens. This time, the company has set its crowdfunding sights on the Primoplan 75mm F1.9, a lens originally manufactured in a run of just 2,000 back in the 1930s.
The folks at Kolari Vision—an infrared camera conversion company based in New Jersey—recently tore down a brand new Sony a7RIII, giving everybody a peek at the camera's much-improved weather sealing.
Resource Travel's Brandon Cunningham recently joined The Giving Lens for a 10-day adventure in India. A trip he won't soon forget, to a country that left him in "sensory and soul overload."
Meet the new Freefly Movi, a handheld gimbal stabilizer designed by cinema stabilization pros for use with the iPhone. Freefly is calling this little beast "the world's most portable, adaptable, and intuitive cinema robot."
Photography portfolio site PhotoShelter is adding their voice to the growing group of online companies that are speaking out in favor of net neutrality, and against the FCC's upcoming vote to kill it.
The Direct app would replace the current Inbox on the Instagram app, doing for Instagram what the Facebook Messenger app did for Facebook on mobile.
Qualcomm's latest high-end mobile chipset offers higher frame rates and a wider color gamut, among other important camera improvements you can expect to see in next year's flagship smartphones.
Photographer Josselin Cornou recently got trapped in a blizzard in the Snowy Mountains of Australia with his Fujifilm GFX 50S and new Tamron 15-30mm F2.8 lens. Find out how they held up to 110km/h winds and -15°C temperatures.
While film nostalgia reaches an all-time high, Seattle-based pro photographer Sofi Lee is turning back to 'digicams' made between 2008 and 2011.
The fixed prime lens camera market may be a bit niche, but it's here that you'll find some of the best cameras you can buy. Sensors ranging from APS-C to full-frame are designed to match their lenses, which cover ranges from 28-75mm equivalent, so image quality is top-notch.
With a capacity of 512GB, Samsung's new UFS chips take built-in storage on smartphones to desktop-PC levels. Will this eliminate the need for microSD slots?
Photographer Josh Rossi decided to go big for this year's Christmas card, so he recreated the Star Wars: The Last Jedi poster using himself, his wife, and their two kids.
In response to a NY Times article about how some traffickers were using Instagram as part of the illicit animal trade, Instagram has added a content advisory screen that pops up to warn users any time they search for hashtags "associated with harmful behavior to animals."
Kodak is expanding its instant photography lineup today with the release of the Kodak Mini Shot Instant 10MP camera. A tiny little digital camera that spits out either 2.1 x 3.4-inch or 2.1 x 2.1-inch prints.
Huawei'e next high-end smartphone could be the first to take computational imaging to the next level with a triple-camera that spits out 40MP files.
Landscape photographer Spencer Cox recalls the single most rewarding—and frightening—landscape photography experience of his life: photographing a sandstorm.