Amateur filmmaker Marc Donahue of Permagrin Films recently shot a video with an array of fifteen GoPro action cameras to achieve Matrix-like bullet time special effects. The arc-shaped rig allowed him to shoot simultaneously from all cameras. In post, Donahue added the freeze frame and slow motion effects.
There are several videos on Marc Donahue's YouTube channel demonstrating his experiments with the action camera. Also check out the Donahue's interview by FStoppers where he talks about the pre and post -production work and challenges involved. (via Mashable)
Ripcurl also did nothing new, had guarantied ten times the budged and made a boring clip. Einstein nearly failed math in grade seven and 30 years later he led the world into a new area. Well done Marc Donahue, keep on doing it and silence your critics!
Let me get this straight, you take the idea that has been done many years ago, has been perfected in major movie productions, you wait a few years, take a few cheap cameras, do it over, just poorly and then people say, 'so cool', 'such a great idea'. Alright :)
@cacv12000 When I saw the headline I actually got excited and was looking forward to seeing it. I was just disappointed by the poor quality. The cameras were poorly synced and the overall quality wasn't impressive. The hands and feet wobbled when the actual idea was to freeze the moment and have the camera track in 'bullet time'. Overall the quality wasn't that good either. Just funny to see people say 'great imagination' when the neither the idea is original nor is the execution well done. Well done on GoPro's marketing, thought :)
Including early last year a whole launch campaign for a big surf label (I can't remember, but I think it was Quiksilver) was shot entirely with exactly this technique.
they set up scaffolding in a wave pool and at actual surf breaks to mount the Go Pros on.
There is great behind the scenes video of it on the web.
The operators they had computers on set for visualisations also.
From a purely artistic point of view this was impressive and fun. But the question that comes to mind is this: Do you really want to have reality distorted so much? It may be good for a quick thrill but is it good for the spirit, good for the soul and good for the historical memories we leave behind?
Great effort - achieving effects like this with a low budget will inspire others. In a few years we will be seeing a whole new wave of cinema, with low budgets and great results (and a shitload of crap, of course). Isn't that what every filmmaker dreams of?
That's the one I was talking about, thanks! Yeah, aside from the distortion from the water on the lens, their bullet-time is nice and smooth. I'm curious to know what caused the difference in quality between the two videos, and I'm really curious how Rip Curl worked with their video in post: I don't think it's just a matter of taking one frame from each camera, I bet they use some sort of morph transition or something to create that smooth motion.
Good idea, but I agree that it's a bit too herky-jerky. I remember a surf company did this a few years ago but with alot more (30 or 40 if I recall) Gopros, and it looked really good (I'd post the video if I could find it), and didn't have that "twitch" effect that this one did.
I've been wanting to do something like this for a while now, my hope was to try it with iphones (since almost everyone has an iphone), though I'd imagine it'd still be a bit of a hassle.
Right, so with one angle you can get 95% of the 3-dimensional rotation effect ... were that even remotely true, we would see it all the time. But alas, it is not true at all :-)
Good ! -Did anyone ask, exposing the brand-name of equipment used THAT MUCH ? A kind of "deal", coupled to the number of "clicks" on this clip, would do the trick here. I do not express any suggestion of the existence of such a deal here, but do point at the rather obvious possibillity of it...
Brilliant! REALLY like the high-quality home-grown anybody-could-do-it approach, and of course the name says it all - more power to PermaGrin, can't wait to see the next experiments.Fab stuff guys
Jeez. Lighten up. It's just an experiment. Not perfect, but at least they are experimenting. It took a lot more effort than typing a whiny comment into an internet forum.
it looks like at least one or two of the cameras were a bit slower in the shutter-lag department... it demonstrates quality inconsistencies in the GoPro brand.
I think all in all, buying 15 GoPro-cams will still cost someone a whole lot less dough output than getting a single really good pro-class video camera with a decent lens on it, huh?
As stupid as this will sound, GoPros need to be fish eye lenses to catch all the action. When you are surfing or skydiving optical optimization isn't really as much of a priority as just getting the footage.
One place GoPro really does need to improve is with sound. I want to record my motorcycle rides and GoPro's mics are terrible in that regard. They pretty much don't capture anything below 100Hz, I am guessing to minimize wind noise.
@sportyaccordy, record audio separately and sync it later, get a simple recorder like a Zoom H1n with a foam windscreen or deadcat on it and put it in your backpack and set it to 48/24 or 48/16. It still might be too windy. Maybe a super fuzzy backpack would work, and don't let the recorder touch the walls of the backpack, make it suspended in there somehow. Or put it inside a fuzzy seat bag on a shockmount. I've always wanted to try that. Your bike will probably be loud enough to hear through all the wind protection. What kind of bike is it?
Yeah, after getting a giant dose of headache by watching the above posted clip, I was also about to say that the Matrix trilogy was definitely NOT recorded with GoPro-cams.... most fortunately for us, the viewers.
If by "film cameras" you mean movie cameras, you'd be wrong. The original Matrix movie used Canon Rebel SLR still cameras. At the time, these Canon SLRs were loaded with film, but the subsequent Matrix movies used digital Rebel DSLRs. BTW, one of the reasons why they used Canon Rebel DSLR is A) the Rebels used standard mini stereojack-style electronic cable release, B) they were inexpensive. Other brands, as well as Canon's own higher-level DSLRs, didn't use minijack remote connectors.
I think T3 fantasises about it being cheap rebel cameras! ROTFL as if they'd take cheap rebels for that... and as if with million$ in the budget they'd even care about jacks for el-cheapo equipment.
Concept gets an A, Execution gets a D. Keep after it though, this could be very interesting. Though i have seen a couple of other people try it with the 1 and 2 with similar, semi good results.
..and it's a shame really, because the footage quality is barely enough for a video of cats... seriously, lots of artifacts, flickering, pretty awful really..
Not really. The device you linked to permits a visually similar effect, as long as your subject's path is completely predictable, and you don't mind re-shooting if you don't get it right the first time. But if you're capturing live action and you want the footage of an event as it happens, you need multiple cameras.
It's also not clear whether their custom robot is actually a product available for purchase, or whether it costs more or less than 15 cameras.
Lastly, as to the quality - good points, but I don't think his purpose here was cinematic quality. It was proof-of-concept. Sure, now the question is, how good can it get?
But I'm sure something similar could be built with an amateur level budget as well - without all those bells and whistles like a professional 3d modelling interfaces and stuff like that..
@Peiasdf I think most studios do use CGI for effects like those, but it seems this german studio can accomplish similar effect with a single high speed camera mounted on a robotic arm. As a geek, I'm impressed :)
@wlad, thanks very much for sharing that. very impressive!!!
but you have to concede that it's not the same thing. in that video the robot is making the camera move faster than the subject, and it is a very very very expensive setup ($200k for the robot, maybe?). whereas the gopro thing is rather low budget in comparison. would have cost even less if they had used standard wide angle regular cameras (many small cheap portable ones on the market to choose from).
Can someone tell me whats so special with GoPro? What kind of properties does it possess that makes it possible to take photos that normal cameras cant take?
The only property I could see was the one that meant they couldn't actually get all the shots perfectly sync'd. I found the slight "judder" somewhat distracting.
Gopro is great if you need waterproof and wide angle. Not sure why this guy even used gopro 3 models since any cheap little cam that shoots video can do this. Some videos needed the wide angle, but most didnt appear to need it at all.
for this video, nothing special about gopro - you could use just about any camera to do this. (it's the same marketing tactic that apple has been doing for decades now "look at what you can do with apple" and people automatically conclude that you can't do that with any other computer)
this is merely their marketing team finding ways to use a camera, showing it being done with a gopro, and then using social media to get free advertising for the brand. (youtube, fb, vimeo, camera-centric websites like this one)
Actually, I think the timing glitches are a result of the cameras not being genlocked. They're shooting fast, but not fast enough that you can get perfect syncronization of the frames in time domain.
That's what makes this cool - you don't have to have a set of computer synchronized SLRs to create a limited bullet-time effect.
electrons travel at about the speed of light... no matter how long the wires are, a meter or 10 meters, they'll still make the cameras fire at the same instant. the problem here is inconsistencies in the cameras themselves. some just have a longer shutter lag.
As a stills camera the Fujifilm X-T3 is a pleasant update to one of our favorite APS-C cameras, significantly improving the autofocus. If you're interested in stills and video, though, it's knockout.
The Nikon Z7 is slated as a mirrorless equivalent to the D850, but it can't subject track with the same reliability as its DSLR counterpart. AF performance is otherwise good, except in low light where hunting can lead to missed shots.
Nikon's Coolpix P1000 has moved the zoom needle from 'absurd' to 'ludicrous,' with an equivalent focal length of 24-3000mm. So far, it's a fun camera to shoot with – if a bit over the top.
The Canon EOS R is the first full frame mirrorless camera to use the new RF mount. We're well underway putting it through our range of standard tests – take a look at how it compares to the competition and our thoughts on using it so far.
The GFX 50R is a 50MP rangefinder-style mirrorless camera. It borrows heavily from the existing 50S model but in a smaller body and at a lower price. How does it differ?
The instant camera market is heating up, and with four formats and 15+ cameras to choose from, we felt it was high time to examine them all and pick our favorite.
Whether you're hitting the beach in the Northern Hemisphere or the ski slopes in the Southern, a rugged compact camera makes a great companion. In this buying guide we've taken a look at seven current models and chosen our favorites.
What's the best camera for a parent? The best cameras for shooting kids and family must have fast autofocus, good low-light image quality and great video. In this buying guide we've rounded-up several great cameras for parents, and recommended the best.
What's the best camera for shooting landscapes? High resolution, weather-sealed bodies and wide dynamic range are all important. In this buying guide we've rounded-up several great cameras for shooting landscapes, and recommended the best.
What’s the best camera costing over $2000? The best high-end camera costing more than $2000 should have plenty of resolution, exceptional build quality, good 4K video capture and top-notch autofocus for advanced and professional users. In this buying guide we’ve rounded up all the current interchangeable lens cameras costing over $2000 and recommended the best.
An upcoming iOS update is reported to have a fix for the excessive skin smoothing users have been complaining about on the latest iPhone XS and XS Max smartphones.
Canon USA has reintroduced its CarePAK Plus service as a promotional incentive for most of its DSLR cameras, as well as on the EOS R full frame mirrorless body.
We spoke to Toshi Iida of Fujifilm about the future of his company's medium-format lineup, the challenges of 100MP and why Fujifilm will never make a full-frame camera.
Celebrity photographer Manfred Baumann has been using a pre-release version of ACDSee Photo Studio Ultimate 2019, and in this article he shares his impressions of using the software.
As a stills camera the Fujifilm X-T3 is a pleasant update to one of our favorite APS-C cameras, significantly improving the autofocus. If you're interested in stills and video, though, it's knockout.
Photographer Peter Guttman was given some of Kodak's revitalized Ektachrome 100 film and took over Kodak Professional's Instagram page to share the images he captured.
We sat down recently with top Canon engineers to talk about the EOS R, and the delicate balancing act of experimenting with a new platform and the risk of alienating existing users.
Sony has updated its image sensor spec page and as expected, a few of the chips they make bear an uncanny resemblance to sensors found inside Fujifilm and Panasonic cameras.
This week Chris and Jordan are joined by renowned macro photographer Don Komarechka, who demonstrates a few simple techniques that can improve your macro photos in a big way.
The Pixel 3 represents another step forward in computational photography for Google's smartphone. We're just getting started with our testing – for now take a look at some sample images, including 'computational Raw' files available for download.
The Kickstarter campaign for Yashica’s digiFilm Y35 camera has produced a wave of complaints about delays in shipping product as well as cameras that don’t work.
Although Raw performance of the EOS R is very similar to the 5D Mark IV, Canon's done some tweaking on the JPEGs - take a look at our studio scene to see for yourself.
If you've backed one of the company's crowdfunding projects, the reward will not arrive and you won't get your money back either as Meyer Optik Görlitz's parent company, Net SE, is completely dead.
Google's Super Res Zoom technology uses pixel-shifting methods to achieve zoom results comparable to some optical solutions. Google has published an in-depth explanation on its AI blog.
Toy manufacturer Tomy has launched a no-battery-required smartphone printer that is remarkably like the one Holga has been promoting via a Kickstarter campaign but which is already available for $40/£39.
Comments