Lens Reviews Help
8 Lens reviews: Frequently Asked Questions
Frequently Asked Questions
Q. How many copies of a lens do you test for a review?
Results are normally derived from a single lens. It's not practical for us to test multiple samples of a lens as a matter of rule - it would simply take far too long.
Q. So how do you know if you have a good copy?
Our analysis software provides us with more information than reaches the reader of the review. We measure the sharpness across the four diagonals of the frame, before averaging the results for the final data. This shows us whether there is any significant asymmetry, which is a good predictor for whether we have a 'good' or 'bad' copy. When we have a clearly problematic lens, we reject it and request a second copy for test.
Q. Can I compare results obtained using different test cameras?
Strictly speaking, sharpness results should not be directly compared between tests carried out using different DSLR bodies, as the camera itself influences the results. Most notably, results get unreliable at higher spatial frequencies due to the differing effects of the test cameras' anti-aliasing filters.
This shouldn't make a huge difference for cameras with similar pixel counts, and as most of our test bodies are in the 12-14Mp range, the results should be broadly comparable. But it will have a more significant effect the further apart two test cameras are in resolution; for example, if you're comparing data between 12Mp and 24Mp cameras, then any data in the 'blue region' of the sharpness display should be considered to be not directly comparable.
However, all of the other results (chromatic aberration, distortion, and falloff) should be directly comparable regardless of the camera body used, and we’d stress that these are equally as important as sharpness in evaluating the overall performance of a lens.
Q. Will I really see the difference between lenses if I don’t print large or pixel peep?
If you normally view photos full screen on your computer (as opposed to pixel-peeping at 100%), or only print relatively small (6” x 4” or 7” x 5”) you won’t see a huge effect from differences in sharpness, or much colour fringing from chromatic aberration. However, you will still see the effects of distortion and falloff no matter how you view your pictures.
Q. Are your MTF50 numbers in line widths / picture height or line pairs/picture height?
Line widths per picture height.
When we first developed our lens data widget, we made a mistake. We calculated the MTF50 data in line widths per picture height, but labeled the y-axis as line pairs/picture height, and included a dotted line marked 'Nyquist Frequency' at the appropriate point for each camera on that scale.
For a number of reasons, we came to realise that the numbers were mislabeled in the presentation widget, and on going back though our calculations discovered the source of the error. This obviously meant we had to relabel the graphs, and as a direct consequence the 'Nyquist' line has gone too (it would now be off-scale for all of the test cameras we've used). It's important to understand that this change is not about the measured values, and only affects presentation of those values (the scale of the graph) - it doesn't affect the actual MTF50 calculations.
The change to correct the error in the presentation widget doesn't affect the lens review conclusions themselves as these are based on extensive testing, comparison and analysis in and out of the studio, and not on the absolute values presented by the graphing widget.
Apologies to our readers for any confusion caused.
Q. Why doesn't the MTF50 sharpness data in lens reviews match the resolution measurement in camera reviews?
Quite simply, these are different methods measuring different things. The sharpness data in lens reviews is presented as MTF50 (i.e. the spatial frequency at which image contrast is reduced to 50%); this is determined by calculation from a slanted-edge target, using camera raw files subjected to standardized processing with no additional sharpening. In contrast, in camera reviews we're looking at 'resolution', which is a visual assessment of the point where individual lines in the test target can no longer be distinguished. These two tests are therefore fully expected to give different results.
Q. I can't see the lens review widget in my web browser, but get a blank space instead. What's the problem?
The widget requires Adobe Flash Player to operate, so you may need to update to the latest version or uninstall/reinstall if you're having problems. If you're using Flash blocking software (and given the number of bad flash-based sites in the web we can forgive you for this), you'll need to add www.dpreview.com to your list of allowed sites.
Q. I'm looking at a new lens review and the widget doesn't load. Instead it's just showing 'loading CSS...'
Your browser has failed to load the latest version of a configuration file needed to view the test data. You'll need to close the page, clear your browser's cache and try again. Here's how to do it in some of the more popular browsers:
- Internet Explorer: Tools > Internet Options. 'General' tab, under 'Browsing History', click the 'Delete...' button and check 'Temporary Internet Files'
- Firefox: Tools > Clear Recent History. Check 'Cache' and click 'Clear Now'.
- Safari: Click on Cog icon at top right corner, 'Reset Safari'. Check 'Empty the Cache', click 'Reset'.
Aug 11, 2014
Jul 2, 2014
Jun 25, 2014
Aug 29, 2014
|Big Steaming Pile by WhistlerOne|
from Product Shoot: Coffee
|AU4_6418_BB-35 by DaveInHouston|
LEE has released a new series of Reverse ND filters that are most opaque in the middle and become progressively clearer towards the top. This makes them ideal for capturing scenes where the sun is close to the horizon.
A former New York Times photographer is suing both the newspaper and its photography director Michele McNally for over $500,000 for age discrimination and unfair classification as a freelancer for nearly a decade.
"CPS Platinum members will now enjoy next-day service, with equipment serviced and shipped the business day after an estimate is approved. For repairs that will take longer, Canon will offer next-day loaner equipment."
Irix is introducing a new filter system called the Irix Edge 100. The ultra-light, ultra-thin system is build specifically for wide angle lenses like Irix's own 15mm F2.4.
After conducting a series of safety tests, the FAA is recommending that all airlines ban cameras and other electronics with Lithium Ion batteries from checked baggage. The agency believe the risk of a catastrophic fire and explosion is too great.
The Pixentu jackets keep you and your gear warm and dry, offering useful features like lens and tripod pockets, in addition to some quirky ones like an extended hood to protect your camera from the rain.
Adobe gave the audience at MAX a sneak peek at some exciting new technology its developing. It's called Adobe Cloak: a highly capable Content Aware Fill-like feature for video editors.
Earlier today, Flickr moved its photo book printing service over to a third party services, and stopped offering any wall art options entirely.
The patent details a flipping rear LCD screen so large, Canon has had to hide the rear dial and several buttons underneath.
We've added a selection of extra images to our Nikon D850 gallery. As part of the process of rounding off the review we made sure a number of us had shot the camera in a variety of situations, we've added those shots to the gallery to give a broad cross section of how the camera performs.
Wiral LITE is an affordable, easy-to-use cable cam system that can do things a portable slider simply can't do, and go places no slider would dare go.
Not happy with the recent demise of Lightroom as a stand-alone, subscription free service? Macphun's got your back... or they will in 2018.
Once connected to a PC, Mac, tablet or smartphone, Pholio automatically searches through the device storage and backs up all images and videos—complete with auto-tagging and intelligent search capabilities.
The 360 Round uses eight horizontally positioned camera pairs and one upward-pointing single lens to capture and livestream panoramic 4K 3D content.
Introduced just three years ago, the Samsung NX1 was both a technological tour-de-force and a great camera to use, earning one of the highest scores we've ever awarded and winning our 2015 Innovation Award. But its short-lived run in the photo world leaves us wondering what could have been.
The Fujifilm X-E3 is styled like a classic rangefinder, but features a built-in touchscreen, AF joystick, and electronic viewfinder – truly an old school meets new type of camera. Lay some eyes on our sample gallery to see how it performs in the real world.
Like it or not, Adobe is embracing a cloud-centric, AI-rich future with the introduction of Lightroom CC. And that's a great thing, though you may not see it now, argues Rishi Sanyal.
The announcement of a more cloud-integrated Lightroom product sees the death of the company's standalone version. This need to make payments in perpetuity (whether you choose Lightroom Classic or CC), chips away at the idea that your Lightroom library is a long-term solution, argues Richard Butler.
The XPro-C 2.4GHz wireless flash trigger that Godox released for Canon users last month now has a Nikon equivalent—the aptly named XPro-N. Sony, Fujifilm and MFT versions are in the works.
In the aftermath of hurricanes Harvey, Irma and Maria, camera and lens maker Sigma is extending its standard product warranty to cover damage caused by these three natural disasters.
The F4 Plus can can capture 360° stills, videos and broadcast livestream footage at 8K resolution... that's 7680 x 3840 pixels!
Lightroom is hogging the spotlight at Adobe MAX, but Photoshop CC got some substantial improvements as well. Find out what's new in the latest version of Photoshop CC.
The aptly-named 'Nude' app automatically detects NSFW images on your iPhone, moves them to a protected vault and deletes the original files in the camera roll and on iCloud.
The Zeiss Milvus family of manual-focus full-frame lenses just gained a new member. Meet the Zeiss Milvus 24mm F1.4: a fast, rugged new lens designed primarily for landscape and architecture photography.
Lightroom has built a brand new Lightroom CC from the ground up to be faster, easier to use, and cloud-based. The application formerly known as Lightroom CC will continue to exist, and will go by "Lightroom Classic CC."
Google Research did a deep dive on the Pixel 2 smartphone's background-blurring portrait mode that uses neural networking and dual-pixel technology instead of a dual-camera setup.
With the arrival of the PowerShot G1 X III, there are now seven Canon cameras built around the 24MP Dual Pixel sensor and Digic 7 processor. We take a look at the differences and what might prompt you to choose one over the others.
Meet the HP ZBook x2. The so-called 'world's most powerful and first detachable PC workstation,' it was built with creative professionals in mind, and is being debuted at Adobe MAX.
PDN sat down with Ahmed Fakhr, director of photography at RollingStone.com, to talk about how the famed publication is adapting to the changing photo and video needs of the modern era and how he 'evaluates the skills of potential contributors.'
Kudos to Canon. Earlier today, the camera giant announced that it had produced its 90 millionth EOS camera and 130 millionth EF-series lens.