U.S. District Court Rules SanDisk Engaged in False and Deceptive Advertising
Sept. 27, 1999--Lexar Media, a leading supplier of High Performance Digital Film(TM), today announced that United States District Court Judge Charles R. Breyer has granted Lexar's motion for a preliminary injunction against SanDisk(Nasdaq:SNDK - news) in a false advertising lawsuit (Lexar Media, Inc. v. SanDisk Corporation, Case No. C99-02463 CRB). The Court's ruling relates to a chart distributed by SanDisk, which contains claims that a SanDisk memory card product was faster than Lexar Media digital film memory cards in specific digital cameras. Judge Breyer described SanDisk's chart as false and deceptive, and ordered SanDisk to stop distributing the ``Capture Time Comparison'' chart. The Court's decision to grant the motion for preliminary injunction is a major win for Lexar Media.
``It is an undeniable fact that Lexar Media's products are technically superior to SanDisk's products in terms of write speed performance,'' said John Reimer, President and CEO of Lexar Media. ``Most photography enthusiasts and professionals who use high-end cameras use Lexar Media's digital film because of this speed advantage which allows pictures to be captured faster. SanDisk's false and misleading advertising has attempted to distort this truth. We hope the judge's ruling will halt SanDisk's unfair and anti-competitive behavior.''
Details of the Case
SanDisk had claimed for months that its products were faster than Lexar's in SanDisk's Capture Time Comparison chart. Judge Breyer's decision vindicates Lexar's position that the chart was inaccurate and was used to mislead Lexar's customers.
The judge's ruling targets claims in SanDisk's chart that the 'capture times' of SanDisk memory cards in particular digital cameras are faster than those for specific Lexar cards in the same cameras. The Court observed that in the digital camera industry, Capture Time, sometimes referred to as 'click-to-click' time, is the measure of the time elapsed between when ``the camera starts to record and store the image (upon depression of the shutter button) until the camera is ready to take another photo.''
In support of its ruling, the Court noted that Nelson Chan, Vice President of Marketing at SanDisk, did not dispute the widely accepted definition of click-to-click. Accordingly, the Court found that ``Lexar is likely to succeed on its claim that SanDisk's 'click-to-click' comparisons are literally false and therefore violate...the Lanham Act....''
SanDisk's Advertising Likely to Deceive Consumers
By SanDisk's own admission, click-to-click speed is a key factor in a consumer's purchasing decision. The two components of click-to-click speed are 1)camera engine processor speed and 2)the write speed of the digital film. As cameras with faster processing capabilities come into the market, the sustained write capabilities of digital film become more critical in click-to-click comparisons. The longer the click-to-click time, the more likely the user is to miss that ``great'' shot while he waits for the camera to be ready to take the next shot.
The Court found that SanDisk wrongly measured 'release-to-click' time and claimed it was click-to-click time. Release-to-click measures the time when the tester releases the fully depressed shutter button until the camera is ready to take another picture. This methodology is inconsistent with industry standards and more difficult to measure objectively.
Lexar to Seek Damages
The Court found that ``Lexar has suffered irreparable injury'' as a result of SanDisk's false and misleading advertising.
``We believe that SanDisk's distribution of the Capture Time Comparison chart was specifically intended to damage Lexar's credibility and good reputation, and also to divert customers to SanDisk,'' said Carlton Osborne, General Counsel, Lexar Media. ``Plaintiffs in other false advertising cases have sought tens of millions of dollars in damages. We are currently evaluating the magnitude of the damages we will seek.''
Lexar's Speed Claims Verified by Third Party
After learning of SanDisk's chart, Lexar commissioned the independent NTS-XXCAL Testing Laboratories to perform a scientifically designed test of commercially available Lexar and SanDisk cards in the same cameras identified in SanDisk's chart. The NTS-XXCAL testing demonstrated that SanDisk's claims were, in fact, false, and Lexar filed suit on May 25, 1999, in the United States District Court for the Northern District of California in San Francisco.
|The Engineer by EXX|
from Steam Trains
|Madrid subway by MAGMATCICO62|
from Your City - Public Transport
|Incandescent Bulb by Kukla|
from Illuminate- Macro only
|Curiousity by PERCY2|
from Macro - Your Best Macro Ever
|Hoar Frosted Trees by sabishiT3T|
It's been twenty years since Jeff Keller founded the Digital Camera Resource Page, one of the first websites dedicated to digital photography. Jeff, who has been at DPReview for nearly five years, looks back at the rise and fall of consumer digital cameras and his website.
We're counting down our top 10 most popular sample galleries of 2017. At #2 we have another staff favorite – the Sony Alpha a9.
Rotolight has released the Anova Pro 2 circular LED for stills and video, boasting a 70% increase in brightness and what the company describes as "unrivaled battery performance."
Designer Vinicius Araújo has imagined what he believes the perfect Adobe software keyboard might look like. From customizable touch pads, to a scroll wheel, to a little display that shows the tool in use, his design is pretty compelling.
Peak Design has teamed up with Leica to release a limited-edition backpack made special for fans of the Red Dot.
A portrait of an android woman has beaten over 5,700 pictures of humans to take third place in this year’s prestigious Taylor Wessing Portrait Prize. The judges were not told the subject was an 'android' until after the winning images were chosen.
Hauling around C-Stands just got a whole lot less annoying thanks to these new Matthews shoulder and roller bags, which can hold two or three C-stand (respectively) plus accessories.
Neal Preston has shot timeless photos of everyone from Led Zeppelin, to Whitney Houston, to Michael Jackson. In this interview, he offers insights into his craft to up-and-comer Elijah Dominique.
Future prosumer Canon DSLRs might feature light-up buttons, if this newly published patent is any indication of the camera company's plans.
Sony's a7R Mark III shoots 42.4MP files at 10fps and incorporates a robust video feature set, large battery, refined ergonomics and more. It certainly looks impressive, but what is it like to use, and how does it stack up against the rest of the market? Find out in our full review.
We're counting down our top 10 most popular sample galleries of 2017 – the Fujifilm X100F takes the bronze and the #3 spot.
There's never been a better time to shop for a new camera, but the number of options available can be overwhelming. In this series of buying guides we've provided customized recommendations for several use cases, from shooting landscapes to buying a first camera for a student photographer.
Shopping for a camera with a set budget? No problem! We've rounded up our favorite cameras, broken them into price brackets and picked the best of the bunch.
Looking for a lightweight compact camera that's easy to bring with you anywhere? Or maybe you're smartphone-shopping and want the one that takes the best picture. And what if you want to shoot from above? In these buyers guides we have recommendations for the best compact cameras, smartphones and drones.
Despite reports to the contrary, analysis of DPReview images by our friend Jim Kasson confirms a disappointing fact: Sony a7R III is still a Star Eater. But there may be some improvements.
As the saying goes: A photo is worth a thousand words. And if you're sending that photo through Facebook Messenger, your thousand words now look twice as nice after today's update to 4K resolution.
Get to know the new Leica CL in short order by giving our 90 second 'First look' video a watch.
Leica has just released the CL, the forth in its series of APS-C L-mount cameras. Despite sharing a name with a camera released in the mid-70s, the new CL is a thoroughly modern ILC, with a 24MP sensor and built-in electronic viewfinder.
The Leica CL is a 24MP rangefinder-style mirrorless camera, which sits alongside the TL2 in the company's APS-C lineup. We've been using one for a few days – check out our gallery of images.
While it shares a name with one of Leica's most popular and affordable cameras of the 1970s, the new CL is separated from its namesake by more than just years. We've been using one for a few days - click through for a detailed first-impressions report.
We're counting down our top 10 most popular sample galleries of 2017, and the #4 ranking goes to the Leica M10.
Sigma is discounting 13 different high-performance 'Art' series lenses from today until November 30th. The company is calling it an 'unprecedented' sale.
See DJI's 'AeroScope' drone-tracking technology in action. This is the system that DJI says can help law enforcement and airport (among others) track and identify rogue drones.
iPhone X owners can already accessorize their new phone with high-quality smartphone photography lenses courtesy of Moment's new lineup.
Considering buying Sigma's exciting new 16mm F1.4 DC DN Contemporary lens for crop-sensor E-Mount and M43? Check out these official full-res samples first!
Vimeo has just added support for 8K HDR 10-bit content, making it possible to show up to 75% of the colors the human eye can perceive vs the usual 35%. Take THAT YouTube.
The holidays are coming, but your gear isn't cutting it? It's time to treat yourself!
We're counting down our top 10 most popular sample galleries of 2017, and sitting pretty at #5 is the Fujifilm X-T20.
See some of the most iconic black-and-white photographs throughout history brought to life by a community of colorization enthusiasts and professional retouchers in the new book Retrographic.
Shopping for a photographer? Whether you are one yourself or not, chances are you could use some ideas. From stocking stuffers on up, we've got some photography gift suggestions for every budget.