DxOMark: EOS 5DS/R sensor is highest-ranked Canon sensor yet
1 Dynamic Range & SNR
DxOMark just published its report on the 50MP sensor in Canon's EOS 5DS and 5DSR. The company's measurements indicate that the 50MP full-frame CMOS is the best-performing Canon sensor to date, offering massive resolution, roughly a 1/3EV improvement in dynamic range over Canon's previous best-performer in this regard, the EOS 6D, with low light performance only a bit behind Canon's low light king, the EOS-1D X. You can compare the 5DS to the 6D and 1D X, Canon's most recent full-frame cameras, here.
The new cameras don't break any records though - according to DxOMark's tests, the EOS 5DSR and 5DS sit in 21st and 22nd place in the company's overall rankings. This is well behind cameras with current-generation Sony CMOS sensors. DxO's results mirror essentially what we found when we put the 5DS R through our Raw dynamic range tests, and you can read our findings here.
The kind folks at DxO have shared their sensor measurement data with us, so we'd like to take this opportunity to comment a bit further on the performance of the 5DS cameras, especially in relation to their nearest competitor, the Nikon D810. But first, a link to DxO's report:
We took the liberty of normalizing 5DS R dynamic range data from DxO to 36MP for a fair comparison against the Nikon D810. This process of normalization effectively ensures we're comparing cameras at a common viewing size, as if you were comparing prints of the same size. This helps cameras with higher pixel counts, which would otherwise be unfairly hurt by their noisier pixels. Since we view pictures, and not pixels, it makes sense to consider noise at the image level, not at the pixel level. By normalizing the 50MP of the 5DS R to 36MP, we're essentially comparing the 5DS R and the D810 on the same, level playing field.
DxO does something similar in their 'Print' mode display of their data; however, that assumes a very low output resolution of only 8MP, which is probably below the resolution most users of these high resolution cameras will desire. Here, we compare at the highest, common denominator: 36MP. Have a look below to see the Raw dynamic range of the cameras, stated in EV, as a function of ISO.
|Raw dynamic range of Canon 5DS R vs. Nikon D810, as a function of ISO. 5DS R dynamic range has been normalized to an output of 36MP, for fair comparison against the Nikon D810. At base ISO, the 5DS R has 11.2 EV of dynamic range, while the D810 has 13.7 EV. That's a 2.5 EV advantage of the D810 at base ISO. By ISO 800, differences are minimal. Raw data courtesy of DxO|
At base ISO, which is 100 for the 5DS R and 64 for the D810, the difference in 'engineering' dynamic range* is a rather hefty 2.5 EV, with the D810 and 5DS R exhibiting 13.7 and 11.2 EV dynamic range, respectively. That means that, down at the darkest levels of exposure on the sensor, tones that receive nearly 6x less light on the D810 will yield similar noise levels to those that received 6x more light on the 5DS R. This explains why you can push and reveal much deeper shadows with D810 Raw files than you can with the Canon files. This ability allows one to expose high contrast scenes for the highlights, which yields a traditional underexposure of midtones and shadows. Due to the low noise of these darker tones recorded on a D810 sensor, one can then push them to make them visible again in a manner one cannot do as effectively on a 5DS R.
Differences in dynamic range between these cameras continue to hold, albeit decrease, all the way up to ISO 800, at which point any differences become minimal at best.
The advantage of ISO 64
There are two things that enable the much higher dynamic range of the D810: first of all, low read noise due to on-chip ADC architecture means your camera's electronics don't have such a high noise floor that dark tones run into them. Second, Nikon implemented ISO 64 on the D810 by actually extending the saturation capacity of pixels (we're not sure how) relative to ISO 100 on previous D800/E cameras. This means that every pixel can capture more light before saturating and clipping. Now if we give the sensors more exposure to take advantage of the increased well-capacities, then darker portions of the scene get cleaner, due to less shot noise and lower risk of running into the, albeit low, noise floor. These are the features that lead to wide dynamic range on the D810, none of which are found in the 5DS cameras.
Having compared the 5DS R vs its nearest competitor, the Nikon D810, with respect to dynamic range, we thought it'd be interesting to see if any of the tones - bright to dark, white to black - of the 5DS R can compete with the best the D810 can do. We can do this by plotting the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of every tone the sensor of each camera can record, from raw data provided to us by DxO. All you need to know about SNR is this: the higher it is, the 'cleaner' and less noisy the tone is.
Looking at the SNR plots below, it's clear that the D810 has a higher SNR for virtually every tone the sensor can record compared to the 5DS R. This is due to the technologies we've already discussed that give it high base ISO dynamic range: a higher full-well capacity of pixels means the camera can actually capture more light, while the lower read noise means that at darker tones (on the left end of this graph) suffer less from noise due to the camera's sensor and electronics. In fact, it's the higher read noise of the 5DS R that causes the continuous drop in SNR relative to the D810 for all lower tones (left side of the graph).
|Base ISO signal:noise ratio (SNR) in dB for all tones the 5DS R (blue) and D810 (red) can record. Higher SNR is better. For all tones, the D810 benefits from a higher full-well capacity of pixels, which means the sensor in its entirety can record more light, which reduces shot noise. The lower (downstream) read noise of the D810 also ensures that darker tones have far higher SNR, and therefore less noise, than the 5DS R. This is why the red line pulls further and further away (tones get cleaner and cleaner) from the blue line for darker tones. Raw data courtesy of DxO|
An interesting aside: the high SNR of tones the D810 records, by capturing more light and contributing less read noise, actually makes it a competitor for modern medium format sensors - from Sony itself - found in Phase One backs, and the Pentax 645Z. It's why some of the ISO 64 shots on the D810 just look so sharp and clean and, dare we say, almost have that 'medium format look'. With the D810, Nikon improved on an already class-leading sensor with the introduction of a native ISO 64. But we digress, and will save a SNR comparison between the D810 and 645Z for a separate article.
What's this all mean in the real world? You may remember the tulip sunrise shot from our 5DS R dynamic range analysis. We've included it on the next page of this article. Some of the shadows, including the greens of the tulip stems, in that shot have a Raw signal that translates to a grey level of approximately 0.26 in the graphs above (on an 8-bit, 255 scale). For the 5DS R, that yields a SNR of 6 dB, while the same signal yields a SNR of 18 dB for the D810, which is actually a 16-fold higher SNR (every 3 dB increase is a doubling in absolute SNR). That is impressive, and accounts for the real-world difference photographers see in noisiness of shadows between these cameras.
On the next page, we'll look at Color accuracy and ISO performance
* Engineering dynamic range (EDR) reports the range of tones between clipping and a the lowest tone, on the dark end, that still has an 'acceptable' noise threshold of SNR = 1. Oftentimes this leads to a higher range than is actually usable, as most photographers will not consider tones with SNR = 1 as 'acceptable'. EDR is still useful as a point of comparison between cameras, though quoting absolute EDR numbers may have questionable relevancy. We've been investigating the idea of using a higher SNR threshold on the low end and, indeed, the 'Photographic Dynamic Range' popularized by Bill Claff uses a higher SNR threshold to yield some very useful comparisons and absolute dynamic range numbers, which Bill calculates himself independently on his excellent site.
|Montréal Dépaneur Out of Business DP by MarioSS|
from Your City - Out of Business
|Wish You Were Here by Dutch Newchurch|
from Street musician playing
|Flight of a Puffin by cjf2|
Super macro photographer Can Tuncer captured these incredible close-ups of a single peacock feather using a special setup and three different microscope lenses.
After successfully crowdfunding the Biotar 75mm F1.5, Oprema Jena is at it again. This time they're bringing back the Biotar 58mm F2: the world's only lens with a 17-blade aperture.
Adobe's move to a subscription model is treating it very well indeed. The company has posted record revenue for the second quarter in a row, hauling in a mind-boggling $1.84 billion.
More details have emerged about the potential sale of Blackstone's 45% stake in iconic camera brand Leica.
Popular mobile editing app Snapseed just got a major update that includes a new interface and 11 new presets for both Android and iOS, as well as adding the Perspective tool to the iOS version.
It might sound like a strange idea, but taking macro photos of boiling water can actually result in some really cool photographs. A good photo experiment for a rainy day.
The database was created to "break with the narrow lens through which history… has been recorded" by equipping those who commission photography with "the resources to discover photographers of color available for assignments.
Lensbaby has released two new optics for their special "optic swap system." The Lensbaby Sweet 80 Optic gives you that trademark sweet spot of focus, while the Creative Bokeh optic gives you 9 different drop in aperture plate options to play with.
TechCrunch has already posted their review of the upcoming iPhone 8 (not yet the iPhone X), and they're calling it "a look into the augmented future of photography."
Affinity Photo is a $50 photo editing software with no subscriptions. That's it – pay for it once and you're done. And we think it's actually pretty darn good.
Instagram is currently testing a major change to the app's profile layout: replacing the 3-photo across grid with a 4-photo grid... and some users are NOT taking the news well.
A report by USSRPhoto is shedding some light on the return of the famed Zenit camera brand. It seems the full-frame mirrorless camera they're working on will be made in part by Leica using components from the Leica SL.
According to a reliable Korean report, Samsung is developing a smartphone sensor that's capable of super slow motion. Translation: Samsung's next batch of Galaxy smartphones may be able to shoot 1,000fps.
This simple photograph of a seahorse and Q-tip has taken the internet by storm. We spoke to photographer Justin Hofman about how it was captured, and what it means to him.
After a massive leak last week, Profoto has officially debuted the Profoto A1: the company's first on-camera flash system that they're calling "the world's smallest studio flash."
"When the first hyperfocal distance charts were designed, someone decided that an acceptably sharp background contained some blur — enough to notice in a medium-sized print [...] After that point, nearly every other hyperfocal chart followed suit."
The Canon EOS Rebel SL2 (also known as the EOS 200D) is the company's impressively compact entry-level DSLR. Packing a 24MP APS-C sensor, DIGIC 7 processor and Dual Pixel AF, it promises a lot of bang for the buck. And while not mind-blowing, it handles most tasks very well.
Correct these four common composition mistakes and your photos will be more balanced, tell a better story, and lead your viewer's eye where you want it to go.
The rugged, compact 360° action camera Kodak unveiled at Photokina in 2016, the Kodak PixPro Orbit 360, is finally available in the United States.
iOS 11 launches tomorrow, and it'll save all of your pictures in a new high efficiency image format called HEIC. Fortunately, there's now a converter that will let you turn those photos back into JPEGs.
Photo protection company ImageRights recently released a new service that lets non-subscribers take advantage of their streamlined copyright registration system that checks for errors and fills out all the required forms for you.
What's the difference between a $200 circular polarizing filter and a $100 circular polarizing filter? Roger Cicala at Lens Rentals put six different filters through a few tests to find out.
A flurry of leaks reveal that GoPro's upcoming Hero6 will shoot 4K at 60fps, 1080p at 240fps, will cost $500, and is scheduled for announcement/release on September 28th.
Before he became the iconic director whose name we've all heard, a teenage Stanley Kubrick struck up a business relationship with New York’s Look magazine. No surprise: he was an incredibly talented photographer.
WD's new G-Technology G-Drive mobile SSD R-Series is a portable solid state option for photographers who want the reliability of an SSD in a rugged water and dust-resistant package.
Fast, stabilized and affordable is an appealing combination when it comes to lenses. With its latest 24-70mm F2.8, Tamron aims to upgrade autofocus speed and stabilization. We've got a full gallery from this updated full-frame zoom.
Photographer Clay Cook tells the story of his most ambitious photographic dream and career goal coming true: photographing A-list actress Jennifer Lawrence.
In an interview with a Chinese website, Nikon Japan's Director of Development dropped a bombshell, saying that a Nikon mirrorless camera "must be full-frame."
Here's a side-by-side spec comparison of two flagship devices with particular attention to the things that really matter – at least to people who prioritize photography features.
A month and a half after revealing the finalists of the 2017 EyeEm Awards, the photo sharing community and licensing marketplace has finally revealed the winners.