DxOMark: EOS 5DS/R sensor is highest-ranked Canon sensor yet
2 Color Accuracy & ISO Performance
Color Accuracy and ISO Performance
Early reports speculated that the 5DS cameras were capped at lower ISOs due to an increase in color accuracy over previous Canon cameras that came at a cost of low light, high ISO performance. One of Canon's best high ISO performers was the EOS 6D, but its Sensitivity Metamerism Index (SMI), which describes the ability of a camera to reproduce accurate colors, was relatively low at 69 (click on 'Color Response'). This prompted some to hypothesize that color selectivity of the filters in the 6D's color filter array was sacrificed to let in more overall light to boost low light performance. Increasing color selectivity on the 5DS cameras, then, may have come at the cost of low light performance, while catering to, for example, landscape photographers who care about color.
It turns out that the SMI, while improved over the 6D, remains the same for the 5DS R and 5D Mark III. Again, follow the links and click on 'Color Response' to view SMI. SMI for daylight (CIE-D50) and tungsten-balanced (CIE-A) light are 74 and 75 for both cameras. Oddly enough though, the 5DS scores for daylight and tungsten-balanced light are 82 and 71, respectively. Given that all Canon sensors hover around the 75 range for CIE-D50, 82 for the 5DS does seem like an outlier, especially consider the 71 rating for CIE-A, and we've reached out to DxO for a comment on this.
Regardless, color accuracy seems about on par with what we'd expect from Canon cameras, with the 5DS perhaps breaking into SMI numbers generally reserved for Nikon and Sony cameras.** Hence, we'd venture to guess that a dramatic increase in color accuracy is not the reason for the capped ISO. Furthermore, results for the 5DS R at least still fall behind those from a Nikon D810, which scores 80 and 78 for CIE-D50 and CIE-A, respectively.
Whether or not there are color accuracy tradeoffs, the fact of the matter is that ISO performance of the 5DS cameras, when viewed at common output size, is quite good. It's only a little behind the Nikon D810 according to DxO's low light score, and as verified by our own Raw studio tests, which you can see in our normalized comparison here. Back in February, when we interviewed him at CP+ 2015, Mr. Maeda of Canon suggested it was a performance bar on pixel-level image quality that drove Canon to cap ISO performance on the 5DS cameras, but since high ISO performance is right up there with the 6D when viewed at common size, we think a higher ISO limit might have been appreciated by some of the cameras' users.
So what does all this mean?
|Tulip sunrise at Skagit Valley Tulip Festival, Mt. Vernon WA. Taken with a pre-production Canon 5DS, with a Canon 11-24mm f/4L lens. Click to enlarge|
Canon's new 5DS and 5DS R cameras have certainly raised the bar when it comes to resolution, and we look forward to seeing the combined resolving power of 5DS bodies with Canon lenses in DxOMark's 'Perceptual Megapixel' ratings of Canon mount lenses. But while DxOMark scores them as Canon's best sensors to-date, they don't raise the bar in other performance areas, instead falling behind class-leaders in both ISO and dynamic range performance. The sheer light-gathering and low-noise abilities of cameras like the Nikon D810 and Pentax 645Z mean I hardly find myself shooting with graduated ND filters or using HDR bracketing techniques in the field when dealing with high contrast scenes with these cameras.
This opens up creative opportunities that are too numerous to get into here. Dynamic range shortcomings won't matter if you're using the 5DS bodies in the studio, but for the very landscapes and environmental portraits these cameras will otherwise excel at capturing, they're an unfortunate shortcoming. Our own Raw dynamic range analyses along with DxO's indicate Canon has a ways to go before catching up to others but, hey, 50 megapixels!
** Nikon and Sony cameras, most using Sony (or Toshiba) sensors, tend to consistently score at 80 and above for CIE-D50, while maintaining class-leading ISO performance. The D7200, for example, shows the best ISO performance to date, yet scores a SMI of 85. Our point being: color accuracy and ISO performance certainly are not mutually exclusive, but they can be if a manufacturer chooses to boost ISO performance by sacrificing color accuracy.
It's been twenty years since Jeff Keller founded the Digital Camera Resource Page, one of the first websites dedicated to digital photography. Jeff, who has been at DPReview for nearly five years, looks back at the rise and fall of consumer digital cameras and his website.
We're counting down our top 10 most popular sample galleries of 2017. At #2 we have another staff favorite – the Sony Alpha a9.
Rotolight has released the Anova Pro 2 circular LED for stills and video, boasting a 70% increase in brightness and what the company describes as "unrivaled battery performance."
Designer Vinicius Araújo has imagined what he believes the perfect Adobe software keyboard might look like. From customizable touch pads, to a scroll wheel, to a little display that shows the tool in use, his design is pretty compelling.
Peak Design has teamed up with Leica to release a limited-edition backpack made special for fans of the Red Dot.
A portrait of an android woman has beaten over 5,700 pictures of humans to take third place in this year’s prestigious Taylor Wessing Portrait Prize. The judges were not told the subject was an 'android' until after the winning images were chosen.
Hauling around C-Stands just got a whole lot less annoying thanks to these new Matthews shoulder and roller bags, which can hold two or three C-stand (respectively) plus accessories.
Neal Preston has shot timeless photos of everyone from Led Zeppelin, to Whitney Houston, to Michael Jackson. In this interview, he offers insights into his craft to up-and-comer Elijah Dominique.
Future prosumer Canon DSLRs might feature light-up buttons, if this newly published patent is any indication of the camera company's plans.
Sony's a7R Mark III shoots 42.4MP files at 10fps and incorporates a robust video feature set, large battery, refined ergonomics and more. It certainly looks impressive, but what is it like to use, and how does it stack up against the rest of the market? Find out in our full review.
We're counting down our top 10 most popular sample galleries of 2017 – the Fujifilm X100F takes the bronze and the #3 spot.
There's never been a better time to shop for a new camera, but the number of options available can be overwhelming. In this series of buying guides we've provided customized recommendations for several use cases, from shooting landscapes to buying a first camera for a student photographer.
Shopping for a camera with a set budget? No problem! We've rounded up our favorite cameras, broken them into price brackets and picked the best of the bunch.
Looking for a lightweight compact camera that's easy to bring with you anywhere? Or maybe you're smartphone-shopping and want the one that takes the best picture. And what if you want to shoot from above? In these buyers guides we have recommendations for the best compact cameras, smartphones and drones.
Despite reports to the contrary, analysis of DPReview images by our friend Jim Kasson confirms a disappointing fact: Sony a7R III is still a Star Eater. But there may be some improvements.
As the saying goes: A photo is worth a thousand words. And if you're sending that photo through Facebook Messenger, your thousand words now look twice as nice after today's update to 4K resolution.
Get to know the new Leica CL in short order by giving our 90 second 'First look' video a watch.
Leica has just released the CL, the forth in its series of APS-C L-mount cameras. Despite sharing a name with a camera released in the mid-70s, the new CL is a thoroughly modern ILC, with a 24MP sensor and built-in electronic viewfinder.
The Leica CL is a 24MP rangefinder-style mirrorless camera, which sits alongside the TL2 in the company's APS-C lineup. We've been using one for a few days – check out our gallery of images.
While it shares a name with one of Leica's most popular and affordable cameras of the 1970s, the new CL is separated from its namesake by more than just years. We've been using one for a few days - click through for a detailed first-impressions report.
We're counting down our top 10 most popular sample galleries of 2017, and the #4 ranking goes to the Leica M10.
Sigma is discounting 13 different high-performance 'Art' series lenses from today until November 30th. The company is calling it an 'unprecedented' sale.
See DJI's 'AeroScope' drone-tracking technology in action. This is the system that DJI says can help law enforcement and airport (among others) track and identify rogue drones.
iPhone X owners can already accessorize their new phone with high-quality smartphone photography lenses courtesy of Moment's new lineup.
Considering buying Sigma's exciting new 16mm F1.4 DC DN Contemporary lens for crop-sensor E-Mount and M43? Check out these official full-res samples first!
Vimeo has just added support for 8K HDR 10-bit content, making it possible to show up to 75% of the colors the human eye can perceive vs the usual 35%. Take THAT YouTube.
The holidays are coming, but your gear isn't cutting it? It's time to treat yourself!
We're counting down our top 10 most popular sample galleries of 2017, and sitting pretty at #5 is the Fujifilm X-T20.
See some of the most iconic black-and-white photographs throughout history brought to life by a community of colorization enthusiasts and professional retouchers in the new book Retrographic.
Shopping for a photographer? Whether you are one yourself or not, chances are you could use some ideas. From stocking stuffers on up, we've got some photography gift suggestions for every budget.