Mars rover camera project manager explains 2MP camera choice
A number of factors led to the use of 2MP sensors in the main imaging cameras used on NASA's Mars rover, Curiosity, says the project manager responsible for their development. The slow data rates available for broadcasting images back to Earth and the team's familiarity with that family of sensors played a part, says Malin Space Science Systems' Mike Ravine, but the biggest factor was the specifications being fixed as far back as 2004. Multi-shot panoramas will see the cameras deliver high-res images, he explains, but not the 3D movies Hollywood director James Cameron had wanted.
'There's a popular belief that projects like this are going to be very advanced but there are things that mitigate against that. These designs were proposed in 2004, and you don't get to propose one specification and then go off and develop something else. 2MP with 8GB of flash [memory] didn't sound too bad in 2004. But it doesn't compare well to what you get in an iPhone today.'
|The 34mm (115mm equiv.) Mastcam from the Curiosity rover - developed by Mike Ravine and his team at Malin Space Science Systems.|
The first consideration when choosing a sensor was the amount of data it would produce.
There are three ways for Curiosity, to broadcast data back to Earth - but it's only the UHF transmitter that can be used for transmitting the amounts of data required for sending back images. 'The UHF antenna transmits to two spacecraft orbiting Mars, which relay the results back to Earth. That's where most of the data is coming from. It gives us on the order of 250 megabits per day, and that's got to be shared between a bunch of instruments, so there's not much bandwidth for the cameras.' Ravine explains.
Another factor was that the same sensor had to meet the needs of four different cameras (MAHLI, the two Mastcams and MARDI, the camera tasked with capturing the rover's descent to the planets' surface). 'Everything in a project like this is sensitive to price and risk, both real and perceived. The cameras differ in terms of their optics, but by building them around a single platform, we didn't have to re-test and qualify each of them separately. This makes them more dependable and less expensive than if you have to do it four times.'
'We developed all four cameras around a common architecture so the choice of sensor was hedged across all of them. We wanted to be able to capture high frame rates, particularly with the descent camera.' he explains. MARDI, the downwards-pointing 'descent camera' had just a two-minute descent to the planet's surface, so a high frame rate was essential. The KAI-2020 chip was the smallest Kodak made capable of 720p HD video. 'We also looked at a 4MP sensor but it would have run around half as fast. And the state of CMOS sensors wasn't credible in 2004. They're an interesting option now, but they weren't then.'
|The initial thumbnail image from the MARDI descent camera, showing the heat shield dropping away, just before the final descent begins. Click here to see a video of the heat shield falling away, based on these thumbnail images.
Image Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/MSSS
The other advantage of the Truesense Imaging chips was the team's familiarity with their behavior. 'We've built-up decades of cumulative experience of working with Kodak and now Truesense interline sensors. We know how to clock them and drive them - they're a very easy CCD to drive,' says Ravine. A similar level of confidence was needed for the cameras’ memory, he says: 'the flash we ended up using was because we had a lot of radiation test data for it.'
| The full-resolution image, released August 8th, giving a clearer idea of what the 2MP cameras onboard the Curiosity rover with be capable of.
Image Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/MSSS
And the low (by modern standards) pixel count needn't be a problem, Ravine says, since the Mastcams will produce stitched images from multiple exposures. 'A mosaic produced from a higher pixel count camera wouldn't offer huge benefits over what we'll be getting.'
Ravine is understandably proud of the work his team has contributed to the project, on the day the rover's mast is raised for the first time: 'We're getting pictures from Mars,' he points out. But it's not hard to detect a note of disappointment in his voice when he mentions the zoom lenses that were being prepared for the project: 'they're currently sitting in a container on the other side of the building.'
Sadly, the cancellation of the zoom lens project for MSL means that it won't produce the 3D footage the team originally hoped for. 'They were going to be 6.5-100mm zoom lenses, which would allow us to set them both to the same focal length for capturing stereo images,' he says. However, problems designing the lens without using wet lubricants (which would require battery-sapping heating to ensure continued operation in Mars' extremely low temperatures), proved difficult and the development was halted.
|The benefits of stitching: a two-image panorama shot with the rover's 1024 x 1024 mono navigation cameras. The Mastcams should produce higher-resolution, color images.
Image Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech
Hollywood director James Cameron was part of the team and successfully lobbied NASA to re-start the zoom project, with talk of 3D movies showing Curiosity's progress across the Martian landscape. Sadly, although the project was re-started, even Cameron's enthusiasm wasn't enough to ensure they'd be ready in time. 'We're going to get some great mosaics with the focal lengths we've got, but we're not going to get the wide-field cinematic moments or the 3D movies from Mars that Cameron wanted.'
|Another perspective - polar projection of the rover's deck and its surroundings. The image is composed of low-res thumbnails, except the two full res panels used in the image further up the page.
Image Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech
Jun 25, 2015
Jun 22, 2015
Jul 21, 2015
Apr 28, 2015
|Waffles with fruits by Coolinarka|
from Food photography (desserts)
|Vestrahorn Frozen Reflection by Will B Milner|
from Ice cold
Google has updated its Photos mobile apps to support the recently announced service for creating and printing physical photo books.
Europeana Photography is a new online image archive that includes more than 2 million historical photographs from European collections in 34 countries, covering the first 100 years of photography. Read more
Manufacturers love to state CRI (color rendering index) numbers to prove that their LED lights will provide great color, but a single CRI score doesn't tell the whole story.
NASA's Juno spacecraft is sending back its first images from Jovean orbit, and they're beautiful. Read more
We got our hands on the first zoom lens available for Fujifim's new digital medium format system. Check out the samples
As summer really gets going over here in the Northern hemisphere, the team at Imaging Resource has put together a list of the best cameras for backpacking.
The Ukrainian Parliament banned statues of Lenin in 2015. Two years later, the monuments no longer adorn public buildings or stand watch over town squares, but they're still there.
If you had to choose one camera to bring along for the ultimate West coast road trip, what would it be? DPR's Sam Spencer choose the X100F. Read more
The a9 boasts impressive capability. As more examples of it in practice pour in, Sony's claims hold up. Watch the a9 track and maintain focus on a rapidly approaching basketball.
Last week, more than a million tonnes of Californian coastline slid into the ocean, taking part of Highway 1 with it. Check out the remodeling in photos taken before and after the landslide.
Even after eighteen months of reviewing the latest, greatest, shiniest and must-buy-me-est new gear, DPReview staffer Carey Rose has continued to use older DSLR cameras for his freelance work. But now, that might be changing. Read more
Sony is the world's leading mirrorless camera brand but remains third for ILCs overall, it's said in a presentation to investors. A focus on high value cameras and lenses should boost operating income, it says. Read more
It's nicknamed the 'Cycloptic Mustard Monster,' and is a 3D printed medium format camera. Read more
The new NanGuang LED lights are battery powered and come with accessories including filters and diffusers.
Have you been telling yourself, "Hey, I really need one of those 8K displays?" A video about Dell's new 8K monitor shows you what to expect. Is it really that much better?
Tamara Lackey, a Nikon ambassador USA and pro shooter, discusses embracing self-consciousness as a means of connecting with subjects.
There's a new Spiderman movie coming out and the poster been generating a lot of online chatter. Mostly about how it looks like the creation of a fevered teenager that just discovered Photoshop.
An honest defense of the system's merits, with photos as proof.
Copyright disputes are no fun at all. 'Binded' is a new startup that aims to simplify the process of registering - and enforcing - copyright for photographers. Read more
Not everyone wants to pay a premium for a long zoom camera. Thankfully, there are many reasonably priced cameras available, though they won't offer the same image quality as enthusiast models. In this updated roundup we look at big zoom cameras with more consumer-friendly price tags. Read more
Think Tank Photo has updated two of its popular bag lines with improvements to functionality. Read more
We’ve all seen Bob Jackson’s Pulitzer Prize winning photo, but there's another.
The sample footage looks good.
It will automatically pick the best camera settings depending on shooting conditions. It even promises enhanced functionality for your camera, like exposure and focus stacking. It already supports many cameras from Canon, Fuji, Nikon and Sony. Read more
As if $13,950 wasn’t enough to pay for a special edition lens, the Leica Store in San Francisco is offering a prototype of said lens for $24,995. Read more
Make those old photos disappear without deleting them forever.
Firmware updates enable 10 fps shooting with adapted A-mount lenses, and faster startup times and better compatibility for 20 fps shooting when using native lenses on the a9.
Fujifilm has released firmware updates for its camera models X-T2, X-Pro2, GFX 50s, X-T20, X100F and X-T1 and updates to three of its software products.
A 22 year-old Romanian photographer uses his DJI Phantom 4 drone to capture unique perspectives of the city where he now lives.
What's it like to ride the waves with champion surfer Kelly Slater? This VR video from Teton Gravity Research gives you a taste.