agentul: regarding my disqualified entry, i would like to clarify:
it is in fact a seedless sunflower, used for decorative purposes. i bought them myself a few years ago as a bouquet. they are hard to find.
the challenge rules did not specify whether the sunflower had to be fertile or not. i can provide a few more photos that show the leaves and the stem, which are identical to those of fertile sunflowers.
edit: here is a link to a Romanian company selling the decorative sun flowers. http://agrosemimpex.ro/produse/search/category/88/page/2
also, another Romanian company: http://www.seminte.de/Seminte-de-flori/Floarea-soarelui/Floarea-soarelui-umpluta-oxid.html
there are photos but no scientific information
xml6000: Are pink gerbera's allowed (part of the sunflower family)
Nigel J Watts: Is that Forrest or Forest?
forest of course... sorry for the extra "r"
Some of the entries are not minarets.. Host should disqualify such entries
Wildbegonia: Kudos to the host for accomplishing the daunting task of keeping this challenge clean of entries that do not meet the rules.
Had I known mimosa was such a confusing flower, I would have not chosen this topic for sure!! :-)
RuthC: Hi vqueen,Your sample picture looks very much like the flowers of the Acacia trees, (or wattles, as they are known in Australia.) I Wikipedia-d 'Mimosa' and became further confused because the botanists themselves have been confusing the Mimosa, Acacia and Albizia species for many years.Will you accept acacias and albizias as well as mimosa flowers in your challenge?Thanks, Ruth
Hi RuthC,Thank you for this message. I did not know about acacia trees' flowers but I looked it up after reading your message and yes, you are right, the flowers are very similar. In this case, as it will be impossible for me to differentiate between acacia and mimosa, yes I will also accept acacias. But albizias look rather different, therefore I would say no albizias. Thank you once again for this chance for clarification
anisah: Question - are jellyfish and starfish allowed?
No, thanks for asking
FranKois: vase- not pot? How to make the difference?
Usually a pot contains soil, while vase contains water to feed the flowers, but both of them could be made from transparent glass or opaque ceramique. The difference concerns transparency, esthetic aspect or mouth diameter?My definition: I will consider a pot as containing soil, of conical shape, made of simple raw clay to be used outside in the garden.I hope it will suit you.RegardsF
Thanks for this definition, it's exactly what I wanted to emphasize
Objectiveman: I have submitted a new cropped picture as in the old one the animals were not clearly visible as donkeys. There should not be any doubt about this one as the distinctive marking and color of the Kiangs can be verified.
ConanFuji: I can't recognise an olive tree even if walk onto one
I think olive trees are recognizable mainly to those who live around Mediterreanean region
My submission was disqualified. I do not understand why...http://www.dpreview.com/galleries/8698213068/photos/2792456/
Which part of the rules do you believe I broke? It was cropped and exp adjusted in LR.Perhaps you want to see the RAW-file?
I post this here as the feedback link you provide in the email malfunctions.
Hi, I sent you a personal message explaining the reasons. Best regards
Philip Lanoue: So is *open sky only* acceptable as a background or is water, trees, mountains, etc. OK?
Water, trees and mountains are okey as long as we can also see the sky.
jetals: Does this mean just a bird in flight, or does the sky have to be in the background as well?
Sky must be in the background
Jack Cat: I see the sample photo shows one bird. Just to clarify, is one bird in the photo acceptable or does it have to be more than one?
More than one birds are also acceptable
SHR100: I hope it's okay for the challenge. If not I'll change a different image.
fireplace33: Can it be one car and one person alone on a road?
LoneReaction: Does any four wheeled vehicle qualify as a "car"?
CalBoy87: Just to clarify, is more then one OK?
more than one ship is okey
TheLoneRanger: Hi there vqueen, i have just entered the Bell challenge but won't be able to do any voting as I will be heading for Argentina and the Antarctic next week.
Just thought I would let you know as I have just joined recently and in some challenges there is an expectation in voting.hope that is okay?Adios Martin
That's perfectly okey as in my challenges voting is not compulsary for the entrants. Have a nice trip to Argentina and Antarctic.
Jack Sofield: Reason for disqualification???
You have been sent a message about it on 12th of November, the reason is that you photo does not abide by "no participation to other dpr challenges" rule of this challenge