l_objectif: Nick, congratulations; this was one of my tops.
It is a really beautiful shot, but I took you for someone else! :-)
Nick, congratulations; this was one of my tops.
Can beak be considered as nose?
teo stab; how come the 5.0 points have been downgraded to 4.0 and 3.5?...Common man; don't be shy; we know you! :-)
l_objectif: A cheater and his 5.0 votes!
he is very well known in the Challenge forum!... People proved it!...
Hi teo stab; you are back with your 5.0 votes and a new username?...
A cheater and his 5.0 votes!
hello, teo stab!... :-)
Dear Barb, somehow, I have the feeling this sweet shot was from you! :-)
Congratulations, dear George. I always knew this shot was a winner!
webmonkey128: What's also strange is the that winning entry is a poorly done composite image - a fine image without the cut and paste cello; the rules on which was clearly stated.
Good job, Conan! :-)
l_objectif: By number; do you mean one person in the shot is OK?
Sorry, I didn't explain it right! I was wondering if there must be numerous persons or one is also OK. You gave my answer; thanks! :-)
This is the shot I first entered, but then, I thought the background is too busy to be minimalist and changed it! :
If I knew the results....
amosf: 14 5 star votes. Cool. I need some friends like that. lol.
LOL....The so called "sunset" is in front, but the light on the rocks comes from the right side!... I guess all the friends were there with candles!... :-)
The processing rule says: "Please, feel 100% free"But 5.0 X 14 ; I have never seen that!... Comparing to many shots that are placed after; this one is at most very average to me!... But whom am I, after all!...
By number; do you mean one person in the shot is OK?
ChristophH: Wonderful capture!!! Well deserved 1st place.
Ohhhh! How nasty!.... jealous; heh?First, you have no idea what "minimalist" means; then, this is a composed picture!...I am certainly not jealous of this crap!....
ConanFuji: love the colours.. very moody
But this is not "Minimalist"!
l_objectif: Very strange! Some real "minimalists" get negative votes and some that are not minimalist at all or don't have title and date as required by the rule and the theme well placed!..
They should have been DQ! ....This is not fair for those who followed the rules!The same goes for the challenge "Smoker"! In the winner shot the subject is not smoking and the photographer admits it!...
Do you really think this is "minimalist"?
Get a weekly update of all that's new in the digital
photography world by subscribing to the Digital Photography Review