4x5 Guy

4x5 Guy

Lives in United States United States
Joined on Mar 16, 2012

4x5 Guy's recent activity

  • Replied in Chaos
    Wow. That hurts me a lot. And I do have many images on my website. Excuse me while I go have a good cry.
  • I am sorry, but I don't see any of the things that john does. I don't think this captures any of the milieu of the immigrants coming to the US. One hand completely covers the face of one off the ...
  • Replied in Untitled
    The connection is way too vague to be successful. Imagination is one thing, but this is beyond that. And that object on the right is very intrusive.
  • This is making me very ill, as did the video. These are pathways to failure if you actually are trying to create an image.
  • Counterpoint? How so? It's totally unrelated to the dog. It's a piece of a car stuck in a corner of the photograph. It's completely distracting and completely ruins the photograph. What could have ...
  • Just a coincidence. He's not me. But I am quite unique. While not really photography, they are interesting to look at.
  • Replied in Recently born
    pm is personal message on this forum. or just respond here and I'll check later on.
  • Replied in Recently born
    There are some issues here. I tell you my thoughts if you want me to (pm me and I'll post here). Otherwise I'll keep quiet.
  • I don't see anything artistic, attractive, innovative or anything positive in this. The personality of the subject doesn't even begin to come through. Extremism is one thing, but this is very ...
  • Replied in Gourd Pots
    My comments will run counter to the others, so feel free to disregard them. After all, I haven't posted any images, so my comments are useless. Not a single part of any gourd is in focus. I don't ...
  • Not at all complementary to the plants. No sense of illumination from the plants. And the interplay with the very bright background just doesn't work.
  • Replied in Labrador
    I really like this one. It really shows some nice emotion and seems to reflect the photographer's feeling about the dog. The interaction of the feet and water, with the reflections, works very ...
  • The first three of poor snapshots at best. They convey nothing of the photographer, i.e. a snapshot. The fourth is minimally interesting.
  • Replied in Chaos
    Your hypocrisy is amazing. You say I have no credibility because I don't post my work. I would respond that your opinion is without merit and is entirely useless without explanation. To think that ...
  • Replied in Chaos
    Hehe. And with you we have a perfect example of someone who does post pics yet has meaningless and blah blah critiques, of "good series", "excellent", and "i hate grass". Why is it that every time ...
  • I didn't miss any point. And just what program is it you want me to get with? How dare you tell anyone to "make your responses relevant to question you pose"? You just can't see your own arrogance ...
  • Replied in Couple of Dafs
    Very distracting backgrounds. Unexciting composition and no sense of illumination. Score 2-3/10
  • Replied in miscellany
    Whatever this next one is, it is has absolutely no appear to me. Score 1/10 Uninteresting composition and harsh lighting with no good sense of illumination Score 3/10.
  • Mundane composition and uninteresting lighting. Score: 4/10 Very harsh lighting. Has a blocked up look. Deep shadows without detail Blurred foreground and background. Score 2-3/10
  • Don't like at all. Photo should stand on it's own. This is not some profound story that needs to be told. This is not some fabulous picture that brings us closer to the creator. The composition ...
Activity older than 12 months is not displayed.
4x5 Guy has not added any gear yet.
Total messages 1197
Threads started 4
Last post 1 week ago
Total comments 0
Total likes 0
Total reviews 0
Entries 0
Votes cast 0
Photos uploaded 0