Irakly Shanidze

Irakly Shanidze

Lives in United States Grosse Pointe, United States
Works as a photographer
Has a website at www.shanidze.com/en
Joined on May 21, 2004
About me:

I am a founder of International Academy of Photographic Arts that provides
workshops in the US, Canada and around Europe and full curriculum (Currently
only in Moscow, Russia) studies in fine art photography ith an emphasis on
creative approach and non-standard thinking.

Comments

Total: 36, showing: 1 – 20
« First‹ Previous12Next ›Last »
On Leica S2 against megapixel arms race article (17 comments in total)
In reply to:

VladimirPlugnikov: Very interesting article.
But I have some questions:
Leica S2 has 37 MP, Leaf Aptus – 80 MP and, as I can see in shops, prices for these cameras also very different. So is it correct comparison?
And what about Nikon D800 ? His 36 MP more closer to Leica` 37 MP?
Thank you very much in advance for your answer

What i am comparing is results of real life practical applications. Very rarely you will need 80MP, and other things become more important for getting the best result than megapixel count.
Nikon D800 is not a medium format camera. Its sensor size despite its resolution cannot capture as much information as a larger frame of smaller resolution. It is like comparing a on-camera flash to a studio strobe.

Direct link | Posted on Dec 2, 2014 at 23:00 UTC
On Leica S2 against megapixel arms race article (17 comments in total)
In reply to:

Phobiz: An excellent review, thanks very much, have you tried the newer S (Typ 006) yet? Would be intrigued by your findings on the newer improved(?) body.

Also, have you kept those Contax 645 lenses??? I see that there is now an adapter for the S-System which allows full use of Contax 645 lenses including Autofocus, Auto aperture etc! Looks great! And could save a packet on good old Zeiss Glass?

yes, I kept all the Contax 645AF lenses :)
haven't tried Typ 006 yet.

Direct link | Posted on Dec 2, 2014 at 22:54 UTC
On Leica S2 against megapixel arms race article (17 comments in total)
In reply to:

EricHiss: You mentioned the 2.8 schneider lens from TLR fame but these also are available in MF SLR cameras - the Rolleiflex Hy6 Mod2 is the latest.

TLR lenses are different, they have rigid design with no moving optical elements and simpler optical formulas. It provides for optical quality superior to SLR lenses.

Direct link | Posted on Dec 2, 2014 at 22:53 UTC
On Leica Noctilux: Overkill or Necessity article (25 comments in total)
In reply to:

RodluvanII: "When working on assignment, being able to shoot at f/1 (or f/0.95 with the last version) frequently means getting the shot versus not getting it. In professional photography it easily translates into thousands of dollars."

I hear this all the time, but I can not image one occasion where a professional photographer would spoil an assignment or 'not get a shot' for not having shallow enough dof or enough available light. Assignments are planed ahead and so is the gear and lighting, not considered on a whim. Apologetics like that I would only expect coming from dentists with too much money, to whom this lens is for. Hardly a professional (the few Leica using professionals there are left).

The most challenging assignments of this kind I used to get from Japan Tobacco International. Their ad campaigns are very intricate, as advertising cigarettes these days is not easy. One time at the core of the campaign we had a photo contest in which I had to shoot an example that participants had to try to imitate. So, my examples had to have a high level of technical difficulty and at the same time conform to color themes of different JTI brands. Noktilux came in very handy indeed :)

Direct link | Posted on Dec 2, 2014 at 15:24 UTC
On Leica Noctilux: Overkill or Necessity article (25 comments in total)
In reply to:

magneto shot: there is a hyperprime now, so noctilux is for those who must have "leica" name in it or perhaps resale value. If low light is the main reason, reviews so far indicates the hyperprime is a better buy. There is also the nokton 50 1.1 for great value but debatable bokeh.

Thanks for writing this article, one can sense your iron clad defense of the lens even if some of the reasons when weight against the price looks dubious to some. For leica owners, the noct is a "must try" itch simply because the price will no doubt makes the mind wonders.

Is it really worth the asking price? The author in this article clearly thinks it is and it moves him to get great pictures in his work. Inspiration is always priceless.

It is not only softness. In fact, transmission factor of Nokton wide open is lower than of 50mm Summilux at f/1.4. At least my M9 built-in light meter thinks so.

Direct link | Posted on Nov 30, 2014 at 16:43 UTC
On Leica Noctilux: Overkill or Necessity article (25 comments in total)
In reply to:

RodluvanII: "When working on assignment, being able to shoot at f/1 (or f/0.95 with the last version) frequently means getting the shot versus not getting it. In professional photography it easily translates into thousands of dollars."

I hear this all the time, but I can not image one occasion where a professional photographer would spoil an assignment or 'not get a shot' for not having shallow enough dof or enough available light. Assignments are planed ahead and so is the gear and lighting, not considered on a whim. Apologetics like that I would only expect coming from dentists with too much money, to whom this lens is for. Hardly a professional (the few Leica using professionals there are left).

of course, anyone can plan a fashion shoot on location, and what if your assignment is ten street candids featuring a certain color combination? ever heard of something of this sort?

Direct link | Posted on Nov 30, 2014 at 16:38 UTC

I really want to meet a person who bought one of those masterpieces :)

Direct link | Posted on Nov 15, 2014 at 05:01 UTC as 12th comment
In reply to:

darngooddesign: The glee shown over people losing their jobs is pretty sad.

I cannot believe that people who were actually doing the designs did not understand how deeply flawed the whole idea was. What it tells me, they did not have enough professional integrity to acknowledge that and act accordingly. I do not feel bad for those who do not respect what they do and still do it.

Direct link | Posted on Nov 15, 2014 at 04:58 UTC
On Mysterious photo in Irina Sh's photo gallery (2 comments in total)

хорошая

Direct link | Posted on Sep 1, 2014 at 06:06 UTC as 1st comment | 1 reply

Maybe I am in no position to make these type of statements, but to me it looks like a major marketing flop on Hasselblad's part. This is indeed pitiful.

Direct link | Posted on Nov 14, 2012 at 17:30 UTC as 13th comment
On Shooting with the Leica M9-P article (648 comments in total)

Frankly, I am a bit puzzled by this article. I mean, handling and operation of M9P is identical to M9, which has been extensively covered. What's the point?
The real advantage of M9/M9P is in its low-light performance. By performance here I mean camera's ability to consistently deliver professional-grade pictures that could be used in publications and commercial applications. Your conclusion is exactly opposite, which I can attribute only to lack of specific knowledge and skill in rangefinder low-light photography.

Direct link | Posted on May 7, 2012 at 08:07 UTC as 92nd comment
On Leica Noctilux: Overkill or Necessity article (25 comments in total)
In reply to:

David Strachan: The girl with the dog...in my opinion the bokeh is really ghastly.

isn't it supposed to be that way considering the subject matter?

Direct link | Posted on Mar 8, 2012 at 15:43 UTC
On Leica S2 against megapixel arms race article (17 comments in total)
In reply to:

topstuff: How very, very interesting.

Considering the Leica S2 is of a similar size to a Nikon D3X or Canon 1DS series, the sheer usability of the camera is fascinating and compelling.

I wonder how the Pentax 645 ( possessed of a similar sensor to the Leica I suspect) would perform? It too, offers larger sensor than 35mm in a format designed for hand holding. And it can take a wide range of lenses. Very good value too for the aspiring photographer.

Thank you for the hard work and the very interesting conclusions you reach.

Thank you. Most likely, I will be able to do the comparison in a couple of weeks. It will be very interesting to include the results in the sequel of this review, which I am already working on. I am comparing Leica S2 to Hasselblad HD4, and it is always good to have an independent standard. In this review I used Sinar M. For the next one Pentax 645D seems like an ideal choice because of its claimed similarities with Leica S2.

Direct link | Posted on Feb 28, 2012 at 20:46 UTC

This is certainly a great achievement... I, however, would appreciate an adaptor that would let me use my Contax 645AF lenses on Leica S2 much, much more. Like, in monetary terms, 150% more.

Direct link | Posted on Jan 19, 2012 at 02:56 UTC as 12th comment | 2 replies
On Fujifilm produces limited edition of 10,000 black X100s article (100 comments in total)

LOL, I hope that the black paint job will make the lens more contrasty :)))

Direct link | Posted on Jan 12, 2012 at 19:03 UTC as 26th comment

Since lightroom comes bundled with Leica M9, I am wondering if this is the time to light my candles on Adobe writing profiles to at least wide angle lenses and 50mm f/1...

Direct link | Posted on Jan 10, 2012 at 18:26 UTC as 18th comment
On Introduction to Food Photography article (57 comments in total)

Matt, this is great. Wonderful job!

Direct link | Posted on Jan 9, 2012 at 14:13 UTC as 13th comment
In reply to:

Andy Crowe: Interesting they're quoting the T stops rather than f stops (guess that comes with the video focus of the lens). If it's capable of T0.95 then the actual f stop must be even less than 0.95

LOL use manual mode :))))

Direct link | Posted on Jan 5, 2012 at 21:46 UTC
In reply to:

micksh6: Forget $10K Leica. The real question is will it be better than Voigtlander Nokton 50mm F1.1 that costs $1000 and has been available for a while instead of 9 months later.

And why to announce 9 months ahead? They just conceived a baby? They haven't started delivering 12mm F1.6 lens that was promised in November. So, I doubt they know that the conception was successful.

4/3 Rumors mentioned it might cost $2K (5 times cheaper than Leica) so $1K Voigtlander Nokton (not to be confused with NoktoR) should be the competitor. BTW, the Nokton weights 425 gram instead of 975.

you are right, it is voightlander that has to be concerned, not leica.
as to the weight, do not forget that this lens is almost a 1/2 stop faster. maybe it does not sound like much to you, but believe me, makes all the difference.

Direct link | Posted on Jan 2, 2012 at 09:02 UTC
In reply to:

Andy Crowe: Interesting they're quoting the T stops rather than f stops (guess that comes with the video focus of the lens). If it's capable of T0.95 then the actual f stop must be even less than 0.95

interesting lens...
bokeh is a bit strange... i wonder what's those concentric circles inside OOF highlights?

Direct link | Posted on Jan 2, 2012 at 00:54 UTC
Total: 36, showing: 1 – 20
« First‹ Previous12Next ›Last »