Saswata

Saswata

Lives in India Kolkata, India
Works as a Consultancy
Joined on Feb 4, 2010

Comments

Total: 65, showing: 21 – 40
« First‹ Previous1234Next ›Last »
On Useless challenge (18 comments in total)
In reply to:

RaptorUK: Can I enter a picture of your Bridge Over The Brook Challenge ? it was totally Useless.

I personally don't need any one to judge my challenges and, I am quite certain, neither do dpreview (otherwise there would have been a system to rate the challenges based on 'useful'-ness) .

I am quite satisfied with the volume of the entries and votes my challenges get, and this is enough indication how 'useful' the challenges are.

If some raptor thinks my challenges could not live up to his expectation my earnest request to him would be: please stay off from my challenges, stop polluting the challenge environment with gem of your comments and find out better and more useful place to blabber.

Direct link | Posted on Sep 18, 2012 at 03:48 UTC
On Useless challenge (18 comments in total)
In reply to:

RaptorUK: Can I enter a picture of your Bridge Over The Brook Challenge ? it was totally Useless.

If your intelligence tells you that all the 100 photographers who participated and all 2290 votes cast for 'Bridge over the Brook' were for something useless you sure can post a photograph from that challenge.
And title it 'This is what my useless intelligence could think of'

Direct link | Posted on Sep 16, 2012 at 08:58 UTC
On Useless challenge (18 comments in total)
In reply to:

Deleted pending purge: This is a tough one. Perhaps the Challenge Intro should read "... useless in the opinion of the photographer". Otherwise, one could argue that there is not anyTHING being quite useless, and as for anyONE... it would be hard to present an image without being offensive. Or political.

Agree to your point.
But there are few things which can safely be called 'useless'... like old cars in a junkyard.
'appearing useless', perhaps, is the point to be noticed.
:-)
cheers !

Direct link | Posted on Sep 16, 2012 at 02:05 UTC
On Bridge Over The Brook challenge (22 comments in total)

Dear Participants,
We have already DQ'd many entries of this challenge.
While choosing the photographs we have been lenient and DQd only those which were going outright against the theme.
If any of the current snaps still looks DQ-material please mention (PM me).
Cheers,
Saswata

Direct link | Posted on Sep 8, 2012 at 08:24 UTC as 9th comment | 1 reply
On Where I Have Been Last Night challenge (8 comments in total)
In reply to:

tasad: "Where I have been last night" ... and no restrictions about "capture date rules" ?

will definitely raise the limit...
we have discussed (why /why not) the capture date rule already.

Direct link | Posted on Aug 26, 2012 at 16:18 UTC
On Where I Have Been Last Night challenge (8 comments in total)
In reply to:

tasad: "Where I have been last night" ... and no restrictions about "capture date rules" ?

yes, of course

Direct link | Posted on Aug 26, 2012 at 07:08 UTC
On Where I Have Been Last Night challenge (8 comments in total)
In reply to:

Wildbegonia: Finally! not caption date rules! K)

No date rule
:-)

Direct link | Posted on Aug 24, 2012 at 17:58 UTC
On Where I Have Been Last Night challenge (8 comments in total)
In reply to:

tasad: "Where I have been last night" ... and no restrictions about "capture date rules" ?

Now if we really become serious about the date, tell me which one you would prefer ?
25th August ? since on 26th the submission begins
or
31st August ? as on 1st September the submission ends.

For us this is just about the story of a night, any night

Direct link | Posted on Aug 24, 2012 at 17:58 UTC
On It's for you dear challenge (3 comments in total)

'It's for you dear'. Bring all the emotions surrounding the act of gifting something tangible or intangible to somebody

Direct link | Posted on Aug 22, 2012 at 02:40 UTC as 1st comment
On It's for you dear challenge (3 comments in total)
In reply to:

wolfbane: Incomplete instructions? "All the emotions surrounding........."
Perhaps it's for Zen masters.
Alistair

Sorry,
It was entirely my mistake.
Perhaps the right statement would have been ''It's for you dear'. Bring all the emotions surrounding the act of gifting something tangible or intangible to somebody'

Direct link | Posted on Aug 22, 2012 at 02:39 UTC
On While We Were Painting challenge (2 comments in total)
In reply to:

ws1967: some persons in these pics aren't painting - they're drawing.

True.
We are considering drawing as painting.
:-)
Thanks for mentioning.
Sas

Direct link | Posted on Aug 11, 2012 at 12:21 UTC
On Silence is Golden challenge (3 comments in total)

Wow !
On the very first day the challenge is full !
Thanks for your responses...
Currnetly facing problems with my internet access (some curious IE bug not letting me to increase the number of entries)
Will soon raise the entry numbers from 50 to at least 200...
Those who are wishing to take part please keep your photographs ready... in a day or two you will be able to take part.
Thanks again.
Cheers !

Direct link | Posted on Aug 6, 2012 at 04:10 UTC as 2nd comment | 1 reply
On Blown with the wind... challenge (1 comment in total)

Because of huge response the entry limit has been raised.
Cheers !

Direct link | Posted on May 30, 2012 at 09:20 UTC as 1st comment
On Mirror Mirror on The Wall challenge (6 comments in total)
In reply to:

Wildbegonia: I would have love to participate, but I am not able to upload any photos to my gallery neither to any challenge. And it seems that no one is there to contact and fix the problem either. This is the third challenge I am missing because of problems with DP site

ooops...
it has reached the 100 mark !
extending it... hope you get to participate.
:-)

Direct link | Posted on May 3, 2012 at 17:33 UTC
On With that glass of red wine challenge (4 comments in total)
In reply to:

RuthC: Do you want us to drink the glass of red wine BEFORE the photo shoot, or after? I think I'd end up taking my photos UNDER the table, after a few test shots.... Just joking. :-)

Our suggestion would be: take the shot when you are halfway done.
Thereby the liquid impacts on your imagination, yet, the camera gets to see the red.
;-)

Direct link | Posted on Apr 29, 2012 at 03:42 UTC
On Flowers in My Room challenge (29 comments in total)
In reply to:

TX Photo Doc: I'm very disappointed that my tulips entry was disqualified AFTER submissions ended for having a black background. I have another version with the table lamp in the photo that I could have replaced it with.

Dear friends,
'Flowers in my Room' has turned out to be the most difficult challenge to moderate.
We received complains for photographs taken out-door. We disqualified. Then we received complains on photographs which were difficult to find where actually had been taken... we disqualified. Then we started getting complains 'Why you DQ-d my snaps? Those were ACTUALLY taken indoor'.
In entirety, it has become very difficult to ascertain where exactly those snaps were taken.
So, we decided to be strict (which was the most difficult and heart-wrenching decision ever taken) and planned to keep only those snaps which are distinctly taken inside a room.
We DQ-d 75%.
We understand some of the snaps were taken indoors but those were not evident.
So, dear friends, thanks for your overwhelming response. Hope in future you all will show equal enthusiasm and take part.
All the very best!
Cheers!

Direct link | Posted on Apr 27, 2012 at 03:51 UTC
On Flowers in My Room challenge (29 comments in total)
In reply to:

kenner1: I have no problem with disqualifying my entry if there was some consistency with the rules. Seems like a bit of a joke and waste of time to me.

Dear friends,
'Flowers in my Room' has turned out to be the most difficult challenge to moderate.
We received complains for photographs taken out-door. We disqualified. Then we received complains on photographs which were difficult to find where actually had been taken... we disqualified. Then we started getting complains 'Why you DQ-d my snaps? Those were ACTUALLY taken indoor'.
In entirety, it has become very difficult to ascertain where exactly those snaps were taken.
So, we decided to be strict (which was the most difficult and heart-wrenching decision ever taken) and planned to keep only those snaps which are distinctly taken inside a room.
We DQ-d 75%.
We understand some of the snaps were taken indoors but those were not evident.
So, dear friends, thanks for your overwhelming response. Hope in future you all will show equal enthusiasm and take part.
All the very best!
Cheers!

Direct link | Posted on Apr 27, 2012 at 03:51 UTC
On Flowers in My Room challenge (29 comments in total)
In reply to:

Mutaz: Dear Saswata,

I am really disappointed that my entry was deleted from the challenge, can you please inform me about the reason specially that you have listed no rules when you announced this challenge.

Regards

Dear friends,
'Flowers in my Room' has turned out to be the most difficult challenge to moderate.
We received complains for photographs taken out-door. We disqualified. Then we received complains on photographs which were difficult to find where actually had been taken... we disqualified. Then we started getting complains 'Why you DQ-d my snaps? Those were ACTUALLY taken indoor'.
In entirety, it has become very difficult to ascertain where exactly those snaps were taken.
So, we decided to be strict (which was the most difficult and heart-wrenching decision ever taken) and planned to keep only those snaps which are distinctly taken inside a room.
We DQ-d 75%.
We understand some of the snaps were taken indoors but those were not evident.
So, dear friends, thanks for your overwhelming response. Hope in future you all will show equal enthusiasm and take part.
All the very best!
Cheers!

Direct link | Posted on Apr 27, 2012 at 03:50 UTC
On Flowers in My Room challenge (29 comments in total)
In reply to:

ema-art: Well, I did ask politely and twice as to why both my entries have been disqualified, since they completely conformed to all the rules and suggestions within this Challenge. I was expecting at least an equally reasonable explanation which you never supplied. Now you announce the 75% of the entries being DQ'd, and still give no explanation about such drastic percentage!
Would you sincerely expect me to enter any more of your Challenges after such treatment?
Regards

Dear friends,
'Flowers in my Room' has turned out to be the most difficult challenge to moderate.
We received complains for photographs taken out-door. We disqualified. Then we received complains on photographs which were difficult to find where actually had been taken... we disqualified. Then we started getting complains 'Why you DQ-d my snaps? Those were ACTUALLY taken indoor'.
In entirety, it has become very difficult to ascertain where exactly those snaps were taken.
So, we decided to be strict (which was the most difficult and heart-wrenching decision ever taken) and planned to keep only those snaps which are distinctly taken inside a room.
We DQ-d 75%.
We understand some of the snaps were taken indoors but those were not evident.
So, dear friends, thanks for your overwhelming response. Hope in future you all will show equal enthusiasm and take part.
All the very best!
Cheers!

Direct link | Posted on Apr 27, 2012 at 03:50 UTC
On Flowers in My Room challenge (29 comments in total)

Dear friends,
'Flowers in my Room' has turned out to be the most difficult challenge to moderate.
We received complains for photographs taken out-door. We disqualified. Then we received complains on photographs which were difficult to find where actually had been taken... we disqualified. Then we started getting complains 'Why you DQ-d my snaps? Those were ACTUALLY taken indoor'.
In entirety, it has become very difficult to ascertain where exactly those snaps were taken.
So, we decided to be strict (which was the most difficult and heart-wrenching decision ever taken) and planned to keep only those snaps which are distinctly taken inside a room.
We DQ-d 75%.
We understand some of the snaps were taken indoors but those were not evident.
So, dear friends, thanks for your overwhelming response. Hope in future you all will show equal enthusiasm and take part.
All the very best!
Cheers!

Direct link | Posted on Apr 27, 2012 at 03:50 UTC as 4th comment
Total: 65, showing: 21 – 40
« First‹ Previous1234Next ›Last »