Tapper123: Perhaps the metallic awards system should be done away with? It just leads to contention. Seems the numerical scores are enough, not to mention the conclusion text, for people looking for a summation.
Personally I thought this was a fair review, and I own an EM5 II and enjoy it. Pair it with some really good lenses and it's as good as almost anything except for perhaps some extreme situations where a 35mm sensor has an advantage. I see it as a great all-arounder, a camera that does everything reasonably well, with world class IS, solid build and weather resistance. If you can't get a good image from this camera paired with a good lens, then I suspect the problem is not the camera.
Anyway, gold, silver -- it doesn't matter. It's a great camera, capable of great images, and has a remarkable lens selection. Enjoy it.
How about using different kinds of sea cucumber?
Wouldn't it be totally awesome to see people arguing about why camera A got a Bohadschia argus award while camera B got the Benthodytes award? Oh, the drama!!! The enjoyment!
RichRMA: Ergonomics means nothing, when compared to performance. People will put up with some real horrors. A sharp-edged machined aluminum cube would sell if you could have resolution like a medium format 80mp Phase camera and the noise control of this Sony 12mp.
Give me that cube! Now!
King of Song: The public is very fickle. We photographer's never expected too much from Sigma. It was always just a cheap 3rd party lens. Suddenly, Sigma does something extraordinary and comes out with the 35 1.4 Art, and blows away both Canon and Nikon versions. We all rally behind Sigma, because the unexpected underdog becomes the hero.
On the other hand, we photographer's expect monumental achievements from say Canon. Canon just announced a 5fps, 50MP camera. There are thousands of negative posts on this site regarding that camera not meeting expectations. Even if the camera woke up in the morning and cooked breakfast, some would complain the eggs were too hard.
If Canon just put out the exact same lens as Sigma, a 24 1.4 for $849, nobody would have anything nice to say.
I still hope that Canon can fix the egg-to-hard issue with a firmware patch.
PhotoKhan: Oh boy...these guys can't win, can they?If they do, it's because they do, if they don't is because they don't...
Give them a rest (...if for nothing else, because they're probably still jet-lagged :) )
...by the way, if you can't do a general appraisal of the lens performance, after having being informed what is used with for the provided samples, I suggest you shoot more and "analyze" less.
In the meantime I can help you out: This is a most excellent lens, the full excellence of which, will be clarified with more formal evaluations.
You missed the fact that most posters here are highly experienced and renowned optical engineers! Each of them at least designed a distortion free 8mm f/1.2 prime with no corner CA wide open, a razor sharp 10-500mm f/1.8 pancake not to mention the legendary nuctulox 50mm f/0.8. They declined Sigmas extremely well endowed job offers over and over again because creating a trivial thing like a 24mm f/1.4 is just no challenge for them.
These images have been made under less than optimal conditions with a less than optimal camera for a wide angle lens and with no lens profile correction going on. A 24mm lens will have CA in the corners. Some of this CA will be LCA, some will be TCA (that can be corrected). But still, thanks to DPR for these shots!Let's wait for images taken on a D810 with a proper lens profile.
Made me smile! Ahh, D800 + the Sigma... my favorite combo!
Simple yet very effective!
Soon. :) (http://knowyourmeme.com/memes/soon)
I love this challenge (or whatever you might call it)!
Our world is so beautiful and it is great so see it through other people's eyes. Inspirational and wow!-ing.
When I saw the image in the gallery, I immediately thought: "Wow, a fire dragon!". Phantastic capture!
JoEick: Cool thing to do for the users of the website. Thanks DPR staff for putting this together. There are many talented photographers here who deserve a bit of recognition for their hard work.
I didn't take any keeper photos in 2014, so it will be nice to see what others have done.
I did not meant to be rude. The comment was supposed to be funny but obviously it wasn't. My humblest apologies. :(