Putting the 18-35/3.5-4.5G in context

Started Mar 23, 2013 | Discussions
Shop cameras & lenses ▾
Michael Siemon Regular Member • Posts: 372
Re: Putting the 18-35/3.5-4.5G in context
2

J Craig H wrote:

Very useful thread, thanks.

I'm wondering if anyone has any updates to this - either from using the 18-35 g more or from getting one recently? (Particularly on a D800/E.)

I'm thinking about ordering one tonight. So far it seems like an ideal wide zoom for hiking and travel but with good quality too.

Craig

Mine just came yesterday, and I spent an hour or so walking around with it. I am impressed; it is hard to see any difference with the much heavier (and pricey!) 16-35 VR. I'm not sure how big an image I can post here, but here's an attempt at about half size, with light cropping and fiddling in Photoshop.

St. Albert's Priory Gate (Oakland, CA): 18mm, f/8 1/90sec ISO 100

-- hide signature --

Michael L. Siemon

 Michael Siemon's gear list:Michael Siemon's gear list
Nikon 1 V2 Nikon D810 Nikon D500 Nikon AF-S Nikkor 16-35mm F4G ED VR Nikon AF Nikkor 105mm f/2D DC +16 more
J Craig H Regular Member • Posts: 161
Re: Putting the 18-35/3.5-4.5G in context

Thanks, Michael. Does indeed look sharp. Good to hear you're impressed with it.

WildlifeBio OP Junior Member • Posts: 39
Re: Putting the 18-35/3.5-4.5G in context
1

OP here.

I've been holding off, both for financial reasons and in the hopes of reading some 'comprehensive' tests from the various lens-testing sites.  Just found this one, posted back on April 4th:

http://www.ephotozine.com/article/nikon-af-s-18-35mm-f-3-5-4-5g-ed-lens-review-21687

It's nice to see some Imatest results.  These seem to mirror what many users are reporting regarding sharpness characteristics across the frame and at various apertures.

 WildlifeBio's gear list:WildlifeBio's gear list
Nikon D600 Nikon AF-S Micro-Nikkor 105mm f/2.8G IF-ED VR Nikon AF-S Nikkor 50mm f/1.8G Nikon AF-S Nikkor 18-35mm f/3.5-4.5G ED Nikon 200-500mm F5.6E ED VR +1 more
gatorowl
gatorowl Senior Member • Posts: 1,035
Re: Putting the 18-35/3.5-4.5G in context

J Craig H wrote:

Very useful thread, thanks.

I'm wondering if anyone has any updates to this - either from using the 18-35 g more or from getting one recently? (Particularly on a D800/E.)

I'm thinking about ordering one tonight. So far it seems like an ideal wide zoom for hiking and travel but with good quality too.

Craig

I have some thoughts (I shoot with a D800E), although I need to do a lot more testing before I'm completely confident about my observations.

I just got my Tokina 16-28mm back from the service center.  It suffered from decentering problems.  It is a whole let better now, so I did some preliminary (informal) testing against my 18-35mm, which I like a  lot.  My testing consists simply of comparisons.  Since it's preliminary, I'm not ready to post any images.

It seems that at like apertures  the 16-28mm is marginally sharper in the center from 18-35mm.  However, from 24-28, the 18-35mm is sharper in the center. I'm not at all impressed with the 16-28mm at 28mm although it is adequate.   What is truly amazing, however, is that the 18-24mm edges are sharper throughout the overlapping zoom range. It's not that the Tokina is super soft, I think that it's more that the Nikkor just does a truly excellent job on the edges.

If these observations hold up under more rigorous testing, I need to decide how much that extra 2mm of reach is for me.  The additional sharpness in the center at wider FLs is not so great as to overcome the consistency edge that the 18-35 provides over a longer range of FLs. However, more testing is needed before I decide whether to keep the Tokina. The 18-35mm is without a doubt a keeper.

 gatorowl's gear list:gatorowl's gear list
Canon EOS Rebel SL1 Nikon D7200 Nikon D500 Canon EOS 80D Canon EF 85mm f/1.2L II USM +12 more
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum MMy threads