Are there any generic inks that truly match OEM?

Started Aug 20, 2010 | Discussions
Anthony
Veteran MemberPosts: 5,104
Like?
Are there any generic inks that truly match OEM?
Aug 20, 2010

I just picked up a rebated Canon Pro9000 MKII for a decent price.

After having Epson for years, the thought of paying for ink, is like having my finger nails pulled.

I'm looking at generic ink options.

Are there any truly good generic inks that match up to OEM? I dont want to be "close", I want to look identical.

If I have to settle for less, I'd rather pay for Canon OEM inks, and print more conservatively.

irvweiner
Contributing MemberPosts: 705
Like?
Re: Are there any generic inks that truly match OEM?
In reply to Anthony, Aug 21, 2010

Please review/search my recent posts--

irv weiner

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Petruska
Veteran MemberPosts: 6,635
Like?
Simple answer - NO!
In reply to Anthony, Aug 21, 2010

You will most likely have a color shift that is noticeable.

You must custom profile your 3rd party and papers to obtain the best results.

What is the closest (95%) to OEM, Image Specialists inks (you can buy them on ebay at Precision Color).

It's worth a try for you as they sell 2oz bottles at a cheap price which includes nice fill plugs and syringe, you should also purchase their bottom output port clips, these are excellent. You also need a chip resetter.

There are also 3rd party refillable cartridges with ink and auto reset chips for about $8 each. Irv, here can fill you in.

I only use OEM cartridges as they are known to work the best to control proper ink flow. The bottom line is how picky you are with your prints.

Bob P.

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Adam2
Veteran MemberPosts: 5,734
Like?
It depends
In reply to Anthony, Aug 21, 2010

On the type of printer, ink, and expectations. For the Epson 3800 for example, Jon Cone produces a wonderful k2 ink that mimics OEM quite well with the exception of pK. I'm testing IJF's V3 ink for the K2 in set and preliminary results suggest that it is exceedingly comparable with deeper pK. In terms of longevity, the word is still out and I would steer you towards Mark McCormick's work at Aardenburg Imaging.

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Petruska
Veteran MemberPosts: 6,635
Like?
He's using a Canon printer.....
In reply to Adam2, Aug 21, 2010

there just aren't any ink sets that match the Canon OEM, all 3rd party ink sets that I have tested shift the gamut. IS was the closest to OEM. Otherwise you need to generate custom print profiles.

I think that this has been brought up countless times here on DPR that if you are extremely serious about photo printing you definitely need to buy profiling equipment for the monitor and printer, and great editing software. The ColorMunki profiles both the monitor and printer for about $350.

Even if you use OEM inks and papers there is a difference if you cutom profile them, the gradients are better.

Bob P.

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Sherman Mechanic
Junior MemberPosts: 32
Like?
Re: Are there any generic inks that truly match OEM?
In reply to Anthony, Apr 20, 2013

None that I have tried or anybody I know has tried. Usually the colors are off, some times they clog, or worse yet sometimes the generic cartridges sometimes leak and then you can have a real mess on your hands. Especially because of the leakage potential I do not take any risks anymore.

I also have a Canon Pixma Pro 9000 II and also a Canon Pixma IP 4300 which I have had for years  and which also uses CLI-8 cartridges. I have never had a problem with the Canon OEM cartridges even though I think they are outrageously overcharged for but that is why I guess these manufacturers sometimes almost give away their printers or sell them below actual cost.

With the Black and White laser printers I have had (HP and Brother) I use generic toner save a ton of money and I usually get from Amazon and never really have had a problem.

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Frank
Regular MemberPosts: 332Gear list
Like?
Re: Are there any generic inks that truly match OEM?
In reply to Anthony, Apr 26, 2013

I use Precision Color Inks in OEM carts. I cant tell the difference .

 Frank's gear list:Frank's gear list
Voigtlander 58mm F1.4 Nokton SL II Nikon D600 Nikon AF-S Nikkor 300mm f/4D ED-IF Nikon AF Nikkor 85mm f/1.8D Nikon AF-S Teleconverter TC-14E II +4 more
Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
jtoolman
Senior MemberPosts: 4,330
Like?
Re: Are there any generic inks that truly match OEM?
In reply to Anthony, Apr 26, 2013

Anthony wrote:

I just picked up a rebated Canon Pro9000 MKII for a decent price.

After having Epson for years, the thought of paying for ink, is like having my finger nails pulled.

I'm looking at generic ink options.

NONE

Are there any truly good generic inks that match up to OEM? I dont want to be "close", I want to look identical.

NOPE

If I have to settle for less, I'd rather pay for Canon OEM inks, and print more conservatively.

Buy Image Specialists inks and a reseter from Precisioncolors.com

and learn to refill you OEM carts.

Do not EVER use compatible or refillable carts on ANY Canon!

Joe

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum MMy threads