17mm TS-E and some NYC landmark skyscrapers

Started Jul 24, 2009 | Discussions
jimcreative
Senior MemberPosts: 2,547
Like?
17mm TS-E and some NYC landmark skyscrapers
Jul 24, 2009

The Flat Iron Building...

This was the geometry straight out of the camera. Yeah... I faked the sky. So sue me.

Chrysler Building...

This one had to be taken with full vertical shift PLUS a little PS correction since I still had to tilt the camera up (not to be confused with tilting the lens). Another faked sky. Charge me on 2 counts.

BTW, you almost NEVER see a photo of the Chrysler Building that runs from the base to the top taken from ground level.

-- hide signature --

'Truth is stranger than fiction, for we have fashioned fiction to suite ourselves.' G.K. Chesterton

http://www.jimroofcreative.net
http://www.jimroofcreative.com
http://www.healthdesignphotography.com

can_ka_no_rey
Senior MemberPosts: 1,564
Like?
Re: 17mm TS-E and some NYC landmark skyscrapers
In reply to jimcreative, Jul 24, 2009

Great shots, almost unreal, due to the corrected distorsion...

Did you shoot handheld or on a tripod?

Thanks for sharing... I would love to buy this lens but it's very specific and very expensive...
--
Cheers,
Ed
-----------
http://www.ebphoto.be
http://ebphoto.over-blog.com

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
jimcreative
Senior MemberPosts: 2,547
Like?
Re: 17mm TS-E and some NYC landmark skyscrapers
In reply to can_ka_no_rey, Jul 24, 2009

These were hand held. I would focus using live view on the 1DsIII and then either use the live view to compose or the viewfinder.

-- hide signature --

'Truth is stranger than fiction, for we have fashioned fiction to suite ourselves.' G.K. Chesterton

http://www.jimroofcreative.net
http://www.jimroofcreative.com
http://www.healthdesignphotography.com

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Kjeld Olesen
Veteran MemberPosts: 3,611
Like?
Oh no!!!
In reply to jimcreative, Jul 24, 2009

Not again!!

I think I may have to get one of this little darling for myself :-/

Great pictures by the way - puts my software corrected Flat Iron with D30 + Sigma 8 mm fish to shame!

-- hide signature --
Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Eric Sorensen
Veteran MemberPosts: 4,636Gear list
Like?
Very impressive in-lens correction
In reply to jimcreative, Jul 24, 2009

I'm sure you will put your new lens to very good use. Does the shift seem to have more or less range than the 24mm T/S?
--

Bossier City, Louisiana
http://www.pbase.com/ericsorensen
Shreveport Photographic Society: http://www.spsclub.org/

 Eric Sorensen's gear list:Eric Sorensen's gear list
Canon EOS 5D Canon EOS 5D Mark II Canon EF 35mm f/1.4L USM Canon EF 85mm f/1.2L II USM Canon EF 70-200mm f/2.8L IS USM +3 more
Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
TunicaAdventitia
Forum MemberPosts: 65
Like?
Re: 17mm TS-E and some NYC landmark skyscrapers
In reply to jimcreative, Jul 24, 2009

great shots! did people walking by stare at you?

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Freddy Mercurio
Regular MemberPosts: 371
Like?
Re: 17mm TS-E and some NYC landmark skyscrapers
In reply to TunicaAdventitia, Jul 24, 2009

How is the image quality when shifted?
Dan
http://www.danbrownphotography.com

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Yellonet
Senior MemberPosts: 1,250
Like?
Doesn't look right to me...
In reply to jimcreative, Jul 24, 2009

Do the buildings really look like that, it looks very wrong to me... in the second shot none of the buildings' corners are 90 degrees.

-- hide signature --

********

  • Yellonet

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
jimcreative
Senior MemberPosts: 2,547
Like?
Re: 17mm TS-E and some NYC landmark skyscrapers
In reply to Freddy Mercurio, Jul 24, 2009

Image quality is ridiculously good. Fully shifted the corners (at the extreme shifted part of the frame) are sharper than the 16-35II corners (at 16mm) except for maybe the very last little bit of the corner that probably is considered out of the intended range of use from a strict sense.

I have never been happier with a lens. It is absolutely ridiculously good.

-- hide signature --

'Truth is stranger than fiction, for we have fashioned fiction to suite ourselves.' G.K. Chesterton

http://www.jimroofcreative.net
http://www.jimroofcreative.com
http://www.healthdesignphotography.com

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
jimcreative
Senior MemberPosts: 2,547
Like?
Re: Doesn't look right to me...
In reply to Yellonet, Jul 24, 2009

It does take come getting used to when you look at extreme wide angle lenses that are perspective corrected. I could go into the whole perceptual/psychology thing to tell you what is going on but it would bore most people to tears.

Suffice it to say that when the verticals are rendered in true parallel fashion the extreme edges of the image may appear stretched, such as the building to the right in the second shot. It is a matter of taste as to what is more offensive - the apparently stretched rendering of a few outlying details or the wholesale non-verticality of a non-shift perspective.

I prefer the verticals to be straight as do 99.97% of my clients.

-- hide signature --

'Truth is stranger than fiction, for we have fashioned fiction to suite ourselves.' G.K. Chesterton

http://www.jimroofcreative.net
http://www.jimroofcreative.com
http://www.healthdesignphotography.com

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Keith Cooper
Contributing MemberPosts: 852
Like?
Re: Doesn't look right to me...
In reply to Yellonet, Jul 24, 2009

The projection you get when using this lens can easily make some aspects look a bit 'wrong' still impressive though

Look at the difference between the base and top of this view of the clock tower in Leicester (UK)

17mm at full shift

-- hide signature --

bye for now

Keith Cooper

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
bronxbombers
Forum ProPosts: 18,226
Like?
wow the flat iron has never looked more precarious!
In reply to jimcreative, Jul 24, 2009

yikes

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
mmarian
Contributing MemberPosts: 646
Like?
Re: 17mm TS-E and some NYC landmark skyscrapers
In reply to jimcreative, Jul 25, 2009

Very impresive indeed. It makes me to want to see more such amazing shots demonstrating what is this lens capable of. I can't wait to get it myself, I am on a long waiting list........

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
canon_lover
Regular MemberPosts: 138
Like?
the blur quality
In reply to mmarian, Jul 25, 2009

hi Jim and Keith and all

can you pls post some photos of the extreme tilt and shift to show the blur qualities of this lens, i know most people who buy this is to correct the images, I'm more interested on its artistic potential and wanted to see images where the blur is more artisticly used.

thanks
--
Canon Shooter:
5D Mark II, 1D Mark II and 1D Mark II N

15mm Fisheye, 16-35L2, TS-E 24L, 24-105L IS, 24-70L,
28-135 IS, 50L, 50 1.8, 85L2, TS-E 90, 135L, 75-300,
70-200L IS 2.8, 200L 2.0, 1.4X Tele, 2X Tele

580EX II (3x), RadioPoppers (3x), ST-E2, CP-E4,
White Lightning X1600, Vagabond II, V2s Wireless Trigger
Zeus 2500 w/ Z2500HS (2x), 47' Octabox, Calumet Strip Box
Sekonic L-758DR & Calibration Target

Manfrotto 058B & RC322, Manfrotto 055XBPro and Manfrotto Monopod.

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Stephen Reid
Junior MemberPosts: 41
Like?
Re: Doesn't look right to me...
In reply to Keith Cooper, Jul 25, 2009

Keith Cooper wrote:

The projection you get when using this lens can easily make some aspects look a bit 'wrong' still impressive though

Look at the difference between the base and top of this view of the clock tower in Leicester (UK)

So are you not correcting the vertical perspective with the trade off of the horizontal being exaggerated?

I see a similar effect in the OP's first image. The top of the building looks significantly larger and more angled than the bottom.

While these are very pleasing images on the whole, there is something just a little bit weird about them that doesn't sit well with me.

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
rockrose
Regular MemberPosts: 140
Like?
Re: Doesn't look right to me...
In reply to Yellonet, Jul 25, 2009

The images indeed aren't 'right' compared to the perspective as you see it: parallel lines should converge in the distance. Some architects and people how know about architectural photography want parallel verticals and prefer this kind of distortion.

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Keith Cooper
Contributing MemberPosts: 852
Like?
Re: Doesn't look right to me...
In reply to Stephen Reid, Jul 25, 2009

It's an interesting trade-off that works for some images (and clients) but not for others.

I'd noticed the effect sometimes with the old TS-E24 I've used for several years, but the extra width of the 17mm makes it more noticeable.

This is one aspect of the 17mm that needs some practice - not just to find out what it will do, but also to get a better feel for when not to use it.

For this picture, yes I got the whole cathedral spire in the shot, but it hardly gets over the proper feel for the narrow lanes in the area.

This one next to the cathedral does give more of a feel for the scale

-- hide signature --

bye for now

Keith Cooper

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Keith Cooper
Contributing MemberPosts: 852
Like?
Re: the blur quality
In reply to canon_lover, Jul 25, 2009

I'll have a look when I'm out using it.

Tilt just isn't something I expect to use much with the 17mm (I'll admit that once I've seen a couple of 'miniature' type shots, I'm ready to turn the page)

Time to check my tilt tables

-- hide signature --

bye for now

Keith Cooper

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Keith Cooper
Contributing MemberPosts: 852
Like?
with tilt
In reply to Keith Cooper, Jul 25, 2009

Here's the view outside my front door

TSE-17 at f/4

6.5 degrees of tilt, which from my printed tilt table puts the focal plane distance 'J' about 15cm to the left of the camera.

Focus adjusted to move the sharp zone onto the building near the skips

Tilt tables used are the ones at:
http://www.northlight-images.co.uk/article_pages/using_tilt.html

-- hide signature --

bye for now

Keith Cooper

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Khun_K
Contributing MemberPosts: 761Gear list
Like?
Re: 17mm TS-E and some NYC landmark skyscrapers
In reply to jimcreative, Jul 25, 2009
 Khun_K's gear list:Khun_K's gear list
Phase One Capture One Pro
Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum MMy threads