Forum indexCanon EOS 7D / 10D - 60D TalkChange forum

10D for "Fine Art" - pros say no.

Started Oct 12, 2003 | Discussions thread

Forum

Parent

First

Next unread

Flat view

John Lehmkuhl

Senior Member • Posts: 1,709

Like?

10D for "Fine Art" - pros say no.

Oct 12, 2003

Went to the arts and crafts fair being held this weekend here in Studio City. Jim Zukerman (amazing wildlife/landscape photographer), Michael Ambrose and many others were there. Probably 8 different photographers selling photos. NONE of them use digital or had digital prints up to sell. They all said digital is not for fine art.

Do you agree ?

-John Lehmkuhl
--
*********************************************************
Los Angeles Canon digital SLR Group -
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/lacdg/
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
My Photo Galleries: http://www.pbase.com/realkuhl
Lens Example Galleries: http://www.pbase.com/realkuhl/lens_examples

Reply to thread Reply with quote Complain

Forum

Parent

First

Next unread

Flat view

Post (hide subjects)	Posted by	When
10D for "Fine Art" - pros say no.	John Lehmkuhl	Oct 12, 2003
They're just afraid...	tanneuby	Oct 12, 2003
Re: They're just afraid...	John Lehmkuhl	Oct 12, 2003
Re: They're just afraid...	Ed Halley	Oct 12, 2003
Re: They're just afraid...	mike_botelho	Oct 13, 2003
Re: They're just afraid...	Lin Evans	Oct 17, 2003
Re: They're just afraid...	Max Lyons	Oct 13, 2003
Here's a counterpoint......	Lin Evans	Oct 17, 2003
And another link to valuable information....	Lin Evans	Oct 17, 2003
I agree with Terry 100%!	Willa	Oct 12, 2003
Re: I agree with Terry 100%!	Dave Lewis	Oct 14, 2003
hmmm.... yes and no...	Shutter.	Oct 12, 2003
Re: hmmm.... yes and no...	Thomas Gardner	Oct 13, 2003
Re: hmmm.... yes and no...	Shutter.	Oct 13, 2003
Re: hmmm.... yes and no...	Thomas Gardner	Oct 13, 2003
"E=mc2 +/- 3 db"...	mplkn	Oct 14, 2003
Re: 10D for "Fine Art" - pros say no.	VG	Oct 12, 2003
Re: 10D for "Fine Art" - yoyos and clowns?	Len_Gee	Oct 13, 2003
Re: 10D for "Fine Art" - yoyos and clowns?	Thomas Gardner	Oct 14, 2003
Re: 10D for "Fine Art" - yoyos and clowns?	Len_Gee	Oct 16, 2003
And they still listen to vinyl records and not CD's	Jim Campbell	Oct 12, 2003
Rresolved:	bigprints	Oct 13, 2003
I don't think so.	Jeremy Kindy	Oct 14, 2003
This is how "giclee'" became the 'acceptable' word....	Diane B	Oct 16, 2003
Re: This is how "giclee'" became the 'acceptable' word....	Thomas Gardner	Oct 16, 2003
I wouldn't let it bother you	Roy Wood	Oct 13, 2003
Re: I wouldn't let it bother you	Andy 10D	Oct 13, 2003
Re: 10D for "Fine Art" - pros say no.	JRG-Imaging	Oct 13, 2003
Re: 10D for "Fine Art" - pros say no.	Steven Lott	Oct 13, 2003
if they were doing art	wmcdowell	Oct 13, 2003
Re: if they were doing art	Itstheimage	Oct 13, 2003
Re: if they were doing art	Stanley W. Rogouski	Oct 16, 2003
No, it's bigger scale than just a&c	John Lehmkuhl	Oct 13, 2003
Re: 10D for "Fine Art" - pros say no - those pros are wrong	John Davis	Oct 13, 2003
Re: 10D for "Fine Art" - pros say no - those pros are wrong	I_ShotEm_All	Oct 13, 2003
Re: 10D for "Fine Art" - pros say no - those pros are wrong	John Davis	Oct 13, 2003
Not sure they are wrong.... or scared.	John Lehmkuhl	Oct 13, 2003
So is fine art only landscapes?	Michael Le	Oct 13, 2003
Re: So is fine art only landscapes?	Thomas Gardner	Oct 13, 2003
160 year print??	Scot Perry	Oct 14, 2003
No.	MystPri	Oct 13, 2003
Re: No.	Thomas Gardner	Oct 13, 2003
Re: 10D for "Fine Art" - pros say no.	Itstheimage	Oct 13, 2003
good points but it's a slippery slope	John Lehmkuhl	Oct 13, 2003
Re: good points but it's a slippery slope	Thomas Gardner	Oct 13, 2003
Re: 10D for "Fine Art" - pros say no.	Thomas Gardner	Oct 13, 2003
It's all good...	Richard Smith	Oct 13, 2003
I totally agree	John Lehmkuhl	Oct 13, 2003
did you ask them what "fine art" is?	Zidar	Oct 13, 2003
How many people want really large prints?????	Amac	Oct 13, 2003
Art is not technique	razzi	Oct 13, 2003
yes and no	Andy Biggs	Oct 13, 2003
Hey Andy!	Thomas Gardner	Oct 13, 2003
Re: Hey Andy!	Andy Biggs	Oct 13, 2003
Re: Hey Andy!	Thomas Gardner	Oct 14, 2003
Re: Hey Andy!	Andy Biggs	Oct 14, 2003
Re: Hey Andy!	Thomas Gardner	Oct 14, 2003
yes, and what about this as a compensation??	Daniella	Oct 13, 2003
Re: yes, and what about this as a compensation??	YosemiteSam	Oct 13, 2003
Re: yes, and what about this as a compensation??	Daniella	Oct 14, 2003
How could the "medium" define it as art or not? (nt)	sjstokes	Oct 13, 2003
My thought exactly. (nt)	Yohan Pamudji	Oct 13, 2003
Professional cooks use gas ranges...	Stuart Allen	Oct 13, 2003
Re: Professional cooks use gas ranges...	Thomas Gardner	Oct 13, 2003
Agree? Yes and no.	Jamie W	Oct 13, 2003
Re: 10D for "Fine Art" - art? ART?	Sievert	Oct 13, 2003
Re: 10D for "Fine Art" - art? ART? (re-prise..corrected version)	bustianu	Oct 13, 2003
Pros don't read the dictionary I guess...	Vern Stevens	Oct 13, 2003
Re: Pros don't read the dictionary I guess...	Thomas Gardner	Oct 14, 2003
The reality is	aevoegels	Oct 13, 2003
The Process of change	John Lehmkuhl	Oct 13, 2003
Re: The Process of change	aevoegels	Oct 13, 2003
Re: The reality is	Thomas Gardner	Oct 14, 2003
I'll bet Ansel Adams+10D+35-80=Art NT	50/1.4	Oct 13, 2003
Re: 10D for "Fine Art" - pros say no.	Steve Hoffmann	Oct 13, 2003
Re: 10D for "Fine Art" - pros say no.	baruth	Oct 13, 2003
Re: 10D for "Fine Art" - pros say no.	Daniella	Oct 13, 2003
Re: 10D for "Fine Art" - pros say no.	Godfrey	Oct 13, 2003
Disagree with this pro	Stephen Cook	Oct 13, 2003
Just spent a week with film artists . . .	1ofUs!	Oct 13, 2003
wanna do 60mp with your D60 or 10D? it'S possible	Daniella	Oct 13, 2003
Re: wanna do 60mp with your D60 or 10D? it'S possible	Pete Perry	Oct 13, 2003
Re: wanna do 60mp with your D60 or 10D? it'S possible	Max Lyons	Oct 13, 2003
Re: wanna do 60mp with your D60 or 10D? it'S possible	Pete Perry	Oct 14, 2003
Re: wanna do 60mp with your D60 or 10D? it'S possible	Max Lyons	Oct 14, 2003
Re: wanna do 60mp with your D60 or 10D? it'S possible	Thomas Gardner	Oct 14, 2003
Re: wanna do 60mp with your D60 or 10D? it'S possible	Max Lyons	Oct 14, 2003
Re: wanna do 60mp with your D60 or 10D? it'S possible	Thomas Gardner	Oct 14, 2003
Re: wanna do 60mp with your D60 or 10D? it'S possible	Daniella	Oct 14, 2003
Re: wanna do 60mp with your D60 or 10D? it'S possible	Thomas Gardner	Oct 14, 2003
Re: wanna do 60mp with your D60 or 10D? it'S possible	Daniella	Oct 14, 2003
Re: wanna do 60mp with your D60 or 10D? it'S possible	Thomas Gardner	Oct 14, 2003
Re: wanna do 60mp with your D60 or 10D? it'S possible	Daniella	Oct 14, 2003
Re: wanna do 60mp with your D60 or 10D? it'S possible	Thomas Gardner	Oct 14, 2003
then it looks like a complete kit	Daniella	Oct 14, 2003
Re: wanna do 60mp with your D60 or 10D? it'S possible	MEMO	Oct 17, 2003
Re: wanna do 60mp with your D60 or 10D? it'S possible	Thomas Gardner	Oct 17, 2003
Re: wanna do 60mp with your D60 or 10D? it'S possible	Daniella	Oct 14, 2003
Re: wanna do 60mp with your D60 or 10D? it'S possible	Max Lyons	Oct 14, 2003
Re: wanna do 60mp with your D60 or 10D? it'S possible	Daniella	Oct 14, 2003
Well, they're about to become obsolete!	Pete Perry	Oct 13, 2003
Galen Rowell prints are digital!	Zdoc	Oct 13, 2003
Not totally...	Pete Perry	Oct 14, 2003
I'm going to try Lightjet next week!	John Lehmkuhl	Oct 14, 2003
Re: Well, they're about to become obsolete!	Andy Somnifacient	Oct 16, 2003
There romanticizing the process!	Scot Perry	Oct 14, 2003
more to picture quality than resolution	Luther Foreman	Oct 14, 2003
Boring!!!	dr_nikon	Oct 14, 2003
no don't, but i understand them because....	Gillis Danielsen	Oct 14, 2003
I don't even...	Gillis Danielsen	Oct 14, 2003
Yes and/or No	Louis44	Oct 14, 2003
Painters might say photography is not art ....	Z H J	Oct 14, 2003
Fine Art...	Louis44	Oct 14, 2003
Re: Fine Art... Definition	aevoegels	Oct 14, 2003
Re: Fine Art... Definition	Louis44	Oct 14, 2003
Re: Fine Art... Definition	aevoegels	Oct 14, 2003
So what?	dnjake	Oct 14, 2003
I totally agree, however	John Lehmkuhl	Oct 14, 2003
Re: I totally agree, however	Thomas Gardner	Oct 14, 2003
Re: I totally agree, however	aevoegels	Oct 14, 2003
Re: 10D for Fine Art Pros say YES!!!	lm31	Oct 15, 2003
Re: 10D for "Fine Art" - pros say no.	andrea buso	Oct 16, 2003
Re: 10D for "Fine Art" - pros say no.	Thomas Gardner	Oct 16, 2003
Re: 10D for "Fine Art" - pros say no.	andrea buso	Oct 20, 2003
Re: 10D for "Fine Art" - pros say no.	Thomas Gardner	Oct 20, 2003
It always occours to me	andrea buso	Oct 20, 2003
Re: It always occours to me	Thomas Gardner	Oct 20, 2003
Re: 10D for "Fine Art" - pros say no. Bailey, Lichfield, Swannel	cbish	Oct 16, 2003
Re: 10D for "Fine Art" - pros say no. Bailey, Lichfield, Swannel	Thomas Gardner	Oct 16, 2003
Art World	Desafinado	Oct 16, 2003
Agreed in all respects, for example...	mplkn	Oct 16, 2003
Desafinado & mplkn	Tomrok	Oct 20, 2003
Re: 10D for "Fine Art" - pros say no.	emily knight	Oct 16, 2003
That was Ansel who said that....(nt)	BobbyC	Oct 16, 2003
Re: 10D for "Fine Art" - pros say no.	eyeDreamer	Oct 16, 2003
Re: 10D for "Fine Art" - pros say no.	Thomas Gardner	Oct 16, 2003
Re: 10D for "Fine Art" - pros say no.	Rip57	Oct 21, 2003

Forum

Parent

First

Next unread

Keyboard shortcuts:

FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads

Color scheme? Blue / Yellow

Editorial content

Product database

Community

Samsung gets it right - look here, Oly!	123
Which camera, driving me crazy!!!	64
New rumour on SAR	60
* Wed C&C (No Theme) Thread, Ed. 269, 13 06 19 *	60
If I owned an NEX-3 or NEX-5 variant, THIS is ...	56
Why 'Sony' not taken seriously?	54
Considering switching systems	46
$2000 mft Budget	43
Looks like Nikon's new 18-35 is kicking some butt!	41
GF6 gets DxOmarked	40
Excellent IQ from Fuji X : show me.	39
SL1: Urban wildlife up close	37
All Shots are soft 7D	36
OM-D E-M5 after 1 (one) year owner reports	34
Why no more CCD sensors?	33
post process this image	30
Fuji X-E1 vs Canon 6d with 24-105 L	30
Purchasing opinion	30
Next Pentax release (september) choose ONE option	29
RX100 Price Drop? When?	27