Making a superzoom for a compact is easy, but for a DSLR, it's hard?

Started 6 months ago | Discussions thread
Leandros S
Contributing MemberPosts: 740Gear list
Like?
Re: Making a superzoom for a compact is easy, but for a DSLR, it's hard?
In reply to MatsP, 6 months ago

MatsP wrote:

MatsP wrote:

Leandros S wrote:

People say that interchangeable superzoom ("travel") lenses can't manage good sharpness, yet superzoom compacts do just fine in terms of sharpness. Why is that?

It is possible to make good and sharp superzooms for all formats. They exist. Take for instance the Canon EF 28-300/3,5-5,6 L IS which is a very sharp superzoom for FF cameras. But it's heavy and expensive, around 3000$ I guess. And for APS-C cameras we have many examples. Many say that the Tamron 18-270 is sharp, and probably the best APS superzoom, but when checking reviews it's obvious that it can't match shorter zooms or primes through it's full range. So with an interchangable lens camera there are always better alternatives regarding sharpness. On a compact you have no choice, and the built-in superzoom is sharp enough for compact camera users, who from start made the choice to sacrifice some IQ for a small and versatile alternative.

May I add that it's not easier to construct a smaller format superzoom than one for a bigger format. It's rather a question of cost when you scale it up. A lot of glass is needed for a bigger lens, and glass is expensive. In the movie business superzomms are much used, they are designed for 35 mm film format, very sharp and smooth and extremly expensive.

Okay, so the example I found is the Canon CN-E30-300mm, which is still a lot narrower at the wide end than your typical current superzoom compact camera, but retails for 30k British Pounds. Zeiss has a 16.5-110mm that I've seen for 60k USD, but it's rather short... Are there better examples out there? Even so, the price would need explaining...

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Post (hide subjects)Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow