PIX 2015

Why magnesium alloy????

Started Apr 19, 2013 | Discussions thread
Shop cameras & lenses ▾
hariseldon2007
Regular MemberPosts: 118
Like?
Toolmakers perspective
In reply to Cliff Fujii, Apr 21, 2013

As previously owning and running a uk toolmaker ( us term is tool and die) , a die casting tool is of similar cost to a plastic mould tool. release times for a plastic mould tool are not 4 minutes for a well designed tool which will use water cooling channels to  aid release.

aluminium in the raw form is very soft and is in my experience always an alloy, there  a large number  of alloys, various heat treatments and surface treatments to give different properties, some of which are very strong, as strong as a low carbon steel but much lighter.

Magnesium alloys die cast very well and have proven to be satisfactory for camera bodies over a period of time.

Titanium again comes in many forms and is very difficult to machine without expensive tooling, generally hard to fabricate, bit over the top for a camera.

Having a lot of design experience , selection of the right  materials, treatments is important and has to be balanced with how good does it have to be and how expensive is it to make a product. A durable, shock resistant plastic over a lightweight metal frame is  pretty good. An aluminium high tensile alloy chassis machined from sold would be  a technically sound solution but expensive, but a precision machined die casting is a pretty good compromise.

A camera needs a dimensionally stable frame for lens mount and shutter and sensor mount, pretty much the rest could be a tough plastic outer shell.

Apple have demonstrated that machined from solid aluminium alloy laptops are very good and economic for a high end , volume product. A MacBook is much stiffer and visually more attractive than a typical plastic laptop.

An expensive plastic we used in down hole oil field  instrument tooling is Peek, hard, rigid and very low thermal coefficient ( does not change dimensions very much when exposed to variations in temperature) , could form a good chassis for a camera body but I think there is little alternative to a hard wearing metal bayonet for the lens mount, and a metal thread insert for the tripod mount.

I suspect the camera manufacturers work on the principle of it ain't broke don't fix it!

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Post (hide subjects)Posted by
(unknown member)
(unknown member)
gunsNew
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow