Return of Interesting article on DxO about 5D III and D800...

Started Apr 10, 2013 | Discussions thread
qianp2k
Forum ProPosts: 10,319Gear list
Like?
Re: Return of Interesting article on DxO about 5D III and D800...
In reply to jayrandomer, Apr 14, 2013

jayrandomer wrote:

schmegg wrote:

qianp2k wrote:

Steen Bay wrote:

qianp2k wrote:

Steen Bay wrote:

qianp2k wrote:

Steen Bay wrote:/

We can also see that the 7D actually has a higher resolution. The 5D's MTF curve stops at app. 61 lp/mm because it runs out of vertical pixels (app. 61 lp/mm represents the 5D's Nyquist frequency), while the 7D's MTF curve continues to app. 72 lp/mm (on 24 x36mm). The contrast is rather low, but the 7D's resolution is nevertheless higher.

I'd suggest everyone reads these articles to understand these concepts first and understand what that means in real world photos.

http://www.normankoren.com/Tutorials/MTF.html

http://www.imatest.com/docs/sharpness/

From above two DXOMark MTF tests, we can see 7D only extends at MTF 15% or below that virtually invisible by eyes in real world photos even at base ISO when 7D photos buried by higher noises/grains. So that 7D higher resolution (18mp vs 12.8mp from 5D) is only on paper or reflected in larger CR2 file size but unless you have an eagle eye, you just cannot see it

A bit of sharpening makes it easier to see. It's clearly visible if comparing the resolution test chart shots in DPR's 5D and 7D reviews.

a) that depends from shooting distance.  A meaningful test should be done from at least 50x focus-length distance; b) depends on which lens. 7D needs a really good prime such as 100L (85/1.8 is also very nice lens) under perfect neutral gray and grainless/noiseless light condition at base ISO 100; c) doesn't reflect in real-world photos in outdoor harsh light or indoor poor light.

Not 100% sure, but think that DPR uses EF 85/1.8 on Canon FF and EF 50/1.4 on Canon APS-C. Agree that the 5D has better sharpness/contrast/acutance, but the 7D's higher MP count will most often also give it a higher 'resolution' (at least at low ISOs).

As shown in the two snapshots of old MTF charts between 5D and 7D, even with two excellent prime lenses, 100L and 85/1.8, 7D still only outresolves 5D around MTF 15% and below ....

Fail.

It doesn't show that at all. You have a fundamental misunderstanding of what these graphs represent it seems.

It simply shows that the 5D has higher acutance down to around MTF 15% (where it runs out of resolving ability all together and the 7D keeps going) - not that it resolves more! And this is from a raw image that has not been adjusted in post processing at all - it has only a passing bearing on the obtainable final image detail and the test is simply designed to compare lenses on a given camera.

What's unacceptable about comparing two curves at fixed ordinate value?  That is certainly a standard way of using graphical information.  It may not be the way the data were generated, which is typically by measuring (or calculating) the acutance at a given resolution, but the ability to compare curves at fixed ordinate values is one of the reasons scientists and engineers employ graphs in the first place.

Agreed.

In other words, if one asks the question, "what is the maximum resolution which has a minimum MTF of 15%?" the value assigned for the 5d would indeed be larger than the value assigned for the 7d.  What he says is correct given his caveat of 15% MTF.  If he had said, "the 5D has higher resolution than the 5D" without such a caveat he would have failed, but we already know that the absolute resolution of the 7D is higher than the 5D simply from the number of pixels.

To me it's only matter if my eyes actually can see (resolve) otherwise "paper" resolution (if merely judged by amount of pixels) is meaningless.  I am the one think DXOMark Perceptual Sharpness (or Resolution) makes sense.

-- hide signature --
 qianp2k's gear list:qianp2k's gear list
Sony RX100 Canon EOS-1D Mark III Canon EOS 5D Mark II Canon EOS 5D Mark III Sony Alpha 7R +20 more
Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Post (hide subjects)Posted by
SameNew
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow