A list of good/bad MFT lens for new owner?

Started Oct 1, 2012 | Discussions thread
josbiker
Regular MemberPosts: 321Gear list
Like?
Re: 45-150 or 45-200
In reply to shihhan, Feb 28, 2013

shihhan wrote:

josbiker wrote:

Please can you or some one else inform me about the shutter problems with the 45-175x.

I like the specs. etc and I am on the point to buy this lens in combination with the 12-35/2.8 lens and sell the 20/1.7, the 14-140 and the 100-300 lens.

I have made some test with ETC and I am satisfied with my results.( 175 and above with the 45-175 lens)

The zooming smoothnes is for me important with the elec. zoom lever from the 45-175.

So my nearby future should be: my GH3 with the 12-35/2.8 and the 45-175 that means for me lighter and less swaps and much more quality.

Please help me?

Jos

Jos, I think if you're absolutely scared/worried about the shutter shock issue, then it is best to avoid the 45-175 X lens all together.

If you google around, basically some people have reported image softness when the 45-175 X lens is used on Panasonic bodies. The problem appears most when:

- Zoomed in to 175mm
- Shutter Speed between 1/60 - 1/150

There has been some explanation online explaining that it may be due to the harsh shutters of Panasonic cameras causing lens vibrations that the OIS is unable to correct. (similar to the issues some people experience with the 14-42 X lens).

Apparently there has been a firmware update, but it may or may not fix this... and not everyone has experienced this issue (so it may only be bad copies of this lens)... there is currently no annoucement from Panasonic regarding this either...

Personally, I've used both the 14-42 X and 45-175 X on the GX1 and I've followed the steps above and have not really experienced the shutter shock problems as described. Other people may agree or disagree with me, but if you're absolutely worried about it, then it's perhaps better to get an alternate lens to save the hassle?
What about the 12-35 X, 35-100 X, 100-300 ultimate lineup? (if budget is not an issue?)
I'm currently on 12-35 X, 45-175X, 100-300 as an interim setup until I can afford a 35-100 X, and I'm pretty happy with my setup so far... oh, and the slowness of the portrait range is sorted by the 45 f1.8 which I bought second hand for £200...

Thanks very much for your clear answer on the 45-175 lens.

Sure I am on a budget that is why i have tested with my 100-300 lens with the ETC functie and I did that also with my 14-140 lens.

These results made me think that with the ETC functie on the 45-175 I can use the 45-175  in ETC mode  above the 125mm, 150 mm so I get the same range as on my 100-300 lens!?

If this all correct than I buy the 12-35/f2.8 lens and buy the 45-175 lens??

I sell my 100-300 my 14-140 and my 20/f1.7!!!Is the low-light better or worse, the 12-35 have OIS is that enough compensation for the lost os 1 1/4 stop?

If I have done that, I gain a lot of  image quality and less swapping with my stills and I am gaining also my video zooming smoothness

What do you think about this move? I like a lot of reactions  so I can reach my "problems" with different ways too look at it. Other members on this forum are also invited to express their opinions,the more the better .( i am new on this)

Jos

 josbiker's gear list:josbiker's gear list
Panasonic Lumix DMC-GH4 Panasonic Lumix G 20mm F1.7 ASPH Panasonic 12-35mm F2.8 Panasonic Lumix G X Vario 35-100mm F2.8 OIS +2 more
Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Post (hide subjects)Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow